This site is an independent public archive. It is not an official Chino Valley Unified School District site. Not an official Chino Valley USD site
In the Minutes Chino Valley USD
Transcript ← All meetings

Board of Education — November 18, 2021

Part 1 of 2 · 0:01:50 Watch this part
UNKNOWN 0:00:00

Okay, thank you. Okay, thank you.

SPEAKER_01 0:00:28

Recording in progress.

SPEAKER_00 0:01:09

Good evening, everyone. It is 5 o'clock. I now call to order the regular meeting of the Board of Education Thursday, November 18, 2021 at 5 PM with Bridge, Cruz, Gagne, Na, and Schaefer present. Pat, are there any speakers for closed session items?

SPEAKER_01 0:01:23

There are none.

SPEAKER_00 0:01:24

Thank you. We will now adjourn to closed session regarding the following matters, which are all described in detail on the printed agenda. A student discipline matter, conference with labor negotiators, ACT and CSEA, and public employee appointment, coordinator special projects, and elementary, junior, and high school assistant principals. We will now adjourn at 5.01. We'll see you back at six o'clock.

Part 2 of 2 · 3:42:55 Watch this part
UNKNOWN 0:00:00

I don't know.

SPEAKER_29 0:00:28

Okay, good evening, everyone. It is 6 o'clock. I now reconvene the regular meeting of the Board of Education at 6 p.m. with Bridge, Cruz, Gagne, Nahn, Schaefer present. Before we begin, please silence all electronic devices and note that these proceedings are being recorded and live-streamed on the district's YouTube channel. Pass, please.

SPEAKER_11 0:00:46

The board met in closed session from 5.01 to 5.23 regarding a student discipline matter, conference with labor negotiators, ACT and CSCA, and public employee appointments, coordinator special projects, and elementary, junior, and high school assistant principals. The Board appointed John Ashby as Coordinator of Special Projects in Curriculum, Instruction, Innovation, and Support, Human Resources, effective November 29th, 2021, by a vote of 5-0, with Bridge, Cruz, Gagne, Na, and Schaefer voting yes. No further action was taken, which requires public disclosure.

SPEAKER_29 0:01:23

Thank you, Pat. Now, leading us in the pledge tonight would be Mrs. Gagne.

UNKNOWN 0:01:35

I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

SPEAKER_47 0:01:50

Dr. Enfield.

SPEAKER_01 0:01:52

I would like to say something. And remember, there's no policy. I have the authority to speak right now because there's no policy right now for me to speak. So I want to say something.

SPEAKER_47 0:02:05

You know, it's very frustrating. A mom wrote to me something that really bothered me, and she asked, is it the board accommodating the venue request? First, the board tells us to take our fight on the vaccine to Sacramento where state legislators and representatives have the power to make changes since the board said it's out of their hands. So we did. But now we are asked for something that's under the board's control, like a venue change. We're met with silence and contempt. A venue change is within the scope of our decision making. We preach about how concerned you are about public health and safety and how community engagement is so important, but our action says otherwise. We are hypocrites. You know, we have big crowds at the meeting. We decided to pack us into a smaller venue, have forth knowledge that parents are coming. Your decision is not in the interest of public health and safety, but the interest is our ego-driven selves, and that's shame on us. There wasn't much I could say to her because, frankly, I don't know the reason why the requests were ignored. And she's right. It would have made more sense to continue having meetings at a larger venue until maybe two or three meetings where parents stopped coming. But what I can do is request a venue change for the next board meeting, for the board to change its meeting venue in the spirit of community and engagement in the interest of public health and safety, in alignment with Governor Newsom's recent declaration of continued state declaration of emergency until March 2022.

SPEAKER_47 0:03:34

Thank you. Thank you.

SPEAKER_29 0:03:40

So we're moving back onto our agenda item, now agenda item 1C, presentation to teacher Ms. Amber Fellows, a teacher at Colorado Preserve. She was the 2021 Educator of the Year recipient from State Assemblymember Freddy Rodriguez. Mr. Bridge, please.

SPEAKER_22 0:04:08

good evening everyone it's uh always a pleasure to do these types of uh of awards and uh this is a very very special one as many of you know uh his fellows was honored by assembly member freddie rodriguez last month at his uh teacher of the year for his assembly district with teachers from all of the school districts that were in his assembly district. And unfortunately, it was during our school board meeting and we couldn't be in attendance. So we wanted to recognize Ms. Fellows tonight for the wonderful work that she has done in our district. Amber was hired in the district in 2014 as a substitute teacher, then later on in October was brought on as a secondary teacher at Colorado Preserve Academy. She holds a bachelor's degree in liberal studies from Cal State University San Marcos and received her teaching credentials from California State University Fullerton. And what we'd like to present to her is a certificate that says Chino Valley Unified School District in recognition presented to Amber Fellows CalAero Preserve Academy for her commitment to public education 2021 educators of the year recipient this 18th day of november 2021 signed president president joe shaffer cbusd board president so amber congratulations

SPEAKER_53 0:05:34

I'm completely honored to be here tonight with all of you. I know a lot of good teachers in CVUSD. I went K-12 in CVUSD, so it's an honor to teach here, to be back here, and I'm just blown away and very, very, very grateful and honored for this award. Thank you so much.

SPEAKER_29 0:06:03

Okay, moving on. Item 1D, comments from student representative. Ms. Esther Kim.

SPEAKER_28 0:06:08

Ms. Esther Kim.

SPEAKER_10 0:06:30

Thank you.

SPEAKER_58 0:06:32

Good evening, everyone. My name is Esther Kim, and I'm honored to participate in this movement as the student board member of the Chino Valley Unified School District. I first thank everyone of our legislative offices, civil rights unions, allies, parents, staff members, State Superintendent Thurmond, and most of all students for being here or lending us your energy from afar. Your presence means so much to your peers at school, the transgender and non-binary community throughout the state, and anyone watching this gathering. As a cisgender person, I cannot in any way speak in your place, but I am here today as your student board member to amplify your voice and support you in any way I can. Before we listen to our voices today, I want to tell you all a story of growth. When we are born, we see in black and white until up to three months of age. But as we grow up and we develop as a person, we open our eyes to new colors. For a while, everything is new and undefined. But as we are taught words, we learn to label our colors. red, yellow, orange, green, blue, and purple. Our world is no longer an innocent flurry of wonder, but an organized orchestra of labels and words. I learned the word spectrum for the first time in elementary school. The definition of spectrum is a condition that is not limited to a specific set of values, but can vary, without steps, across a continuum.

SPEAKER_58 0:08:07

In this society of words, labels, and norms, what we often don't realize is that we are too grown up for a monochromatic world. We're old enough to know how to label, but too grown up to limit ourselves to labeled colors. Society has matured enough for us to understand that we live in a spectrum. We label increments in a way that makes sense to us and defines ourselves. However, we must remember that we cannot limit others to a singular form of expression, a form that they are not comfortable in, a form that they do not identify with. We cannot define these vibrant identities for them and hold them back from expressing themselves. In my past few months as a student board member and two years in education advocacy, I have been able to see a very small portion of the spectrum in Chino Valley. With over 27,000 students, we are a big district with flourishing diversity. In the quest to provide equitable education across all of our schools, we must safeguard this diversity and understand that we cannot define each other's colors. This can only be achieved once you throw away old prejudice and stereotypes to create a culture where we truly see each other, human to human, as people who deserve their rights to life, liberty, and pursuit of happiness. Today, we are witnessing incredible leaders and allies fighting to defend a right to being that should have never been threatened. As a student, an ally, and a board member of the Chino Valley Unified School District, I implore all of you to listen to these voices

SPEAKER_58 0:09:47

not through the filter of labels or stereotypes, but through a human heart, a grown mind, through a spectrum, and channel this energy into conversations about the discrimination still rampant in schools, as well as the importance of preserving fundamental human rights that extends far beyond this boardroom. Thank you.

SPEAKER_29 0:10:16

Thank you, Esther. Now moving on to comments from our employee representatives. I see Ms. Emily Lau here tonight, I believe Vice President of CHAMP currently?

SPEAKER_34 0:10:24

Yes.

SPEAKER_36 0:10:31

Good evening, President Schaffer, school board members, cabinet, and Chino Valley community. I see she's already left, but I'd first like to also congratulate Amber Fallows. I had the privilege of working with her and can honestly say that she always puts children first and brings out the very best in her students. Congratulations to Amber. Tonight, I'd like to highlight some of the heartwarming accomplishments that several of our Chino Valley schools have been working on. E.J. Marshall, Magnolia Junior High, and Oak Ridge Elementary Schools have all had food drives this month. They've collected thousands of items to be donated to local charities. I'm sure many of our community families are extremely grateful for their kindness. Way to go to Townsend Junior High for collecting hundreds of pairs of socks to donate to veterans in our community. Lastly, this month, Ramona Junior High participated in the 2021 Great Kindness Challenge. Ramona students collaborated with students from 702 schools across the globe to set a Guinness Book World Record. Together, they created an 18-mile recycled paper chain with over 360,000 messages of hope, love, and inspiration. On behalf of CHAMP, I'd like to wish everyone a very happy Thanksgiving and remind our parents and students that there is no school next week.

SPEAKER_29 0:12:17

Is Ms. Walker with us via Zoom? How about Mr. Hernandez? Okay, seeing neither, we will move on. All right, now comments on items not on the agenda. Pat, were there any requests to speak on non-agenda items?

SPEAKER_38 0:12:50

20 requests to speak.

SPEAKER_29 0:12:55

Speakers will be called in the order the request was received. Please listen for your name and be prepared to approach the podium. Any comments on agenda items will be accepted during consideration of that item. Once the board has commenced deliberations on an issue, speaker cards will not be accepted. The board is very interested in your comments, but please bear in mind that the board typically does not respond to comments during this time on the agenda, as is reserved specifically for public comments. Individual members may respond during board comments at the end. Additionally, the board does its best to support the public's right to address its elected officials. It is important that the board conduct its business in an orderly and fair fashion, as provided in board bylaw 9323. In the event that an unusual amount of speaker cards are submitted for any item, the board will hear up to 30 minutes of comments. In the case of non-agenda items, the board can, if it chooses, hear the remainder of comments after all business has been conducted. Mr. Bridge, will you please explain the light system?

SPEAKER_22 0:13:54

Speakers, you have three minutes to address the board. Please limit your remarks to new points. Again, comments of the green light. Yellow light means you have 30 seconds left. The red light means your time is over. Please adjust the microphone as necessary so you can be heard clearly. audience members please refrain from making comments while speakers are at the podium and please note that board policy 1312.1 outlines the procedure for anyone who wishes to file a complaint against a district employee the first speaker is parent advocacy of chino valley followed by kelly allen followed by sonia sing

SPEAKER_41 0:14:46

Good afternoon, Dr. Enfield, board members, and community. My name is Sonia Shah, the president of Parent Advocacy Chino Valley, giving an update from our group. We have a lot of exciting things going on. As we continue to reach and connect with groups and representatives around California, we have started some great relationships. Just as Martin Luther King says, and I quote, we must learn how to live together like brothers and sisters or perish together as fools. We have recently had a parent and teacher meeting for the Chino Valley community. It was a beautiful thing to brainstorm, talk, and share things. We also had members attend various events in our community in efforts to join together as one to work on issues our students and staff face. We have attended some Zoom meetings and recently joined the Unity Project. You guys should look that one up. Our director of the Parent Advocacy Group recently spoke at the Capitol. It was beautiful to see our state come together in all these recent events. We have other parents in various school districts around California reaching out to us asking for help and guidance, and I cannot explain how exciting this is because we know together we are stronger and together we are better. We have also set up some meetings that are coming up soon with state and local representatives, and we encourage the community to continue to reach out to them asking for their help in these challenges we face today, which brings me to the next recent event in my meeting with Dr. Enfield.

SPEAKER_41 0:16:05

We are extremely thankful and excited for the opportunity to link up and work together. There's a lot of exciting things and this goes a long way. There have been many great events and so much progress made. I can't tell you how excited we are to link up with our own staff members here. This is a beautiful thing, as most of them, some of them, because they don't have a venue large enough to seat them, are sitting behind us. This is a beautiful thing for our children, as we really do have some of the most amazing teachers and staff worldwide, and I say that with much confidence. It would be awful for our children if we didn't continue to find ways to get through the obstacles together. I do have to say from one leader to another, whether you are a staff member, a parent, a board member, or any other leader in any position, if you don't stop using our children to benefit your personal gain and agendas, there will be consequences, and that will include but not limited to legal action taken. We have avoided much of that given many opportunities. But knowing it will cause our district tons of money, we decided to hold off on those things. We hope that those that continue to be vile will walk away and do the right thing. We are working day in and day out to make sure our district is a leading example of what a united community looks like because it's then we have achieved a place where our kids will flourish and grow.

SPEAKER_41 0:17:26

There has been one major issue that does not sit right if safety and continuous efforts to involve the parents is a priority, and that's the venue change. We today officially demand a resolution be added to the agenda. Using the California Ed Code 35145.6, we request a venue change until March 22nd, since that's the date Gavin Newscum said we are in an emergency state.

SPEAKER_04 0:17:49

We will- Time.

SPEAKER_41 0:17:51

I can wait for the next one. We'll wait for the next one.

SPEAKER_11 0:17:57

Kelly Allen, followed by Sonia Singh, followed by Sonia Shaw. Kelly Allen. We're right here.

SPEAKER_41 0:18:09

I'm speaking for part of hers.

SPEAKER_34 0:18:19

Thank you.

SPEAKER_41 0:18:21

We will follow up in writing with this request. With much hope and continuous efforts, we are a team that are growing and we hope everyone joins and uses their gifts to help our community through these challenging times. And to the gentleman behind us, you asked to join our group recently. We denied you for that very reason.

SPEAKER_16 0:18:43

Under government code 54957, we are making an official complaint against board member and vice president Christina Gagne. We are requesting the district performs a public censure on Ms. Gagne, an investigator for Brown Act election and campaign violations in her attempt to bypass and violate CVUSD bylaws and policies for personal and political gain. Within one day of the vote, Ms. Gagne voiced her opposition to the vote in a very private setting and set out to take measures to, in some way, influence future actions in this area. With the assistance of Jim Gallagher, Democrat operative and activist, she posted a call to action behind closed doors. They utilized a hidden Facebook page run by Mr. Gallagher, which is not even visible to the public, in a search. The page is Concerned Parents and Citizens of CVUSD. Mr. Gallagher posted this letter from Ms. Gagne where she clearly represents herself as vice president of the board. Ms. Gagne falsely states that unfortunately last night the school board passed a resolution announcing their opposition towards continuing to take appropriate steps to defeat COVID-19 and keep us moving ahead. This statement is not true at all. Ms. Gagne clearly does not care about procedures to defeat COVID-19 as she continues to wear a mask in board meetings to portray fear, yet has been photographed in public and social settings not wearing a mask at all. We contend that Ms. Gagne is using her position as Vice President to take unethical advantages being an elected official and the fact that she is a board candidate for 2022 election and she's using both areas of status to abuse her position of power to gather signatures to lobby the CVUSD Board of Education.

SPEAKER_16 0:20:20

She has violated numerous bylaws and board policies and we are concerned that she may have gone as far as violating election and campaign policies, ethics and law. This opposition to the resolution also affects our teachers and staff, not just the students. We are proud to stand here today in support of our teachers and staff whom stand for choice. We want you all to know that we are here with you because together we are better and stronger. Lastly, I would like to demand an action item be placed on the agenda to request a change of venue for the foreseeable future or as long as Newsom continues this ridiculous emergency order. And for anybody who did not get a C today, we have a complaint that you can fill out set up here today for whoever didn't get a seat and wanted to make it in here. Thank you.

SPEAKER_03 0:21:11

Under government codes section five, four, nine, five, seven. I'm making an official complaint against board member and president Joe Schaefer. I'm requesting the district issue a public censure on Mr. Schaefer for his attempt on October 27th, 2021 to intimidate myself and all the members of the parent advocacy group, Chino Valley unified school district. Then this incident was described by Caitlin Martinez on November 4th in a meeting where she filed her own complaint. And she asked the board to investigate these actions. All of you are aware of the events of that day, so I'm not going to rehash them. For those of you who missed it, you can watch the live stream from YouTube from that day. Whatever was said to the Chino Police Department that produced the deployment of five units to a mother's home must have been an exaggeration of the truth and a manipulation of facts that you used as an opportunity to send us all a message. I, along with many more of our members, are filing this complaint to let you know that we will not be intimidated into silence. Dr. Enfield, I demand an agenda item be placed on the agenda for the soonest board meeting possible to discuss in public the implications of misconduct by Mr. Schaffer and now Ms. Gagne. A written request will be submitted tomorrow per board policy. I would like to use the rest of my time for Dr. Enfield to tell the community what he and the board have done since the last meeting to investigate and resolve the complaint brought by Ms. Martinez.

SPEAKER_43 0:22:35

This is not my time to talk.

SPEAKER_03 0:22:38

I'm giving you my time.

SPEAKER_43 0:22:39

It's not my time to talk.

SPEAKER_34 0:22:41

Do you have any other comments for the board member?

SPEAKER_41 0:22:44

She still has time.

SPEAKER_03 0:22:50

I'm going to be done. I don't even have words. Is there a policy? Can we get an answer? Anybody? Is there a policy? Is there a censure policy? Is there a disciplinary policy for any of these complaints?

SPEAKER_41 0:23:04

I mean, bylaws are broken. Oaths are broken. You guys swear by an oath. You keep putting that in our face to help us advocate for the kids.

SPEAKER_34 0:23:11

Pam, do you have any other comments for the board?

SPEAKER_41 0:23:13

We are having comments. These are our comments.

SPEAKER_34 0:23:15

This is her comment. I'm not yours.

SPEAKER_03 0:23:17

The bylaw says not typically respond to comments after a board is a speaker is finished. I'm not finished. I'm still have my time. You can based on bylaws respond to my comments.

SPEAKER_41 0:23:31

Or make a public apology for what you did.

SPEAKER_34 0:23:34

Do you have any other comments for the board, ma'am? The floor is open.

SPEAKER_53 0:23:36

Hope you guys see this.

SPEAKER_55 0:23:42

Thank you, Pat.

SPEAKER_00 0:23:47

Can I have a point of information?

SPEAKER_34 0:23:49

Please.

SPEAKER_00 0:23:51

I will make sure to move forward your public censure request of me.

SPEAKER_48 0:23:55

Thank you. I appreciate that. Thank you very much.

SPEAKER_11 0:24:05

Sonia Shaw, followed by Julie Santosola, followed by Yi Yu Banks.

SPEAKER_41 0:24:10

Right now I speak as a parent and not the president of the parent advocacy. But what's happening today is disgusting. It's embarrassing. We continue to try to reach out to you guys and things are going on behind our backs. These are our children.

SPEAKER_23 0:24:24

It doesn't bother you that there's so much hate in this room outside. We asked for a venue change. We didn't ask you to break a bylaw or rule. You're doing that on yourself. You continue to do it. That's embarrassing for us. We asked to work together. We don't we can't stand being in the room with some of you because of the things that you have done. And it's really embarrassing when you continue to do them. And then there's no apology. There's nothing that you're trying to do to move forward. When is it gonna stop? When are you guys going to actually put the kids' best interests in? You, we tried hard with you and then you link up with him? What does he have with our kids? It's disgusting. He's the leader of the Democrat Chino Valley and I don't care what political party you're involved in, but that's embarrassing that you're linking up with him and to go beyond a board, break bylaws and go beyond, you know better than anybody. You're a lawyer. It's embarrassing. When they vote on something, you move as a unit. How many times did they get voted the majority against them, and they had to move on as a unit? They didn't go behind your backs getting surveys and using our campaign pages. You, Mr. Schaffer, a public apology for what you pulled, deleting text messages and calling coughs on a mother. let's go come on you're a man say sorry that would have went a long way and it would have shut up a lot of people but your behavior continues it's embarrassing i really truly hope that those of you that don't have the best interest of the kids walk out and leave because if not you're going to continue to expose yourself we have tons of dirt on a lot of you have you ever seen us publicly posted everywhere no because our kids would be hurt

SPEAKER_23 0:26:13

We have lawyers available at for us for lawsuits. Have we done it? No. Why? Because that's our kids money and we'd rather see you guys do the right thing. This is awful. This is disgusting and it's heartbreaking. These are our children. We never asked you to break a law. We asked you to work with us and give us the tools. You gave me senators and state people that were from your political party. Shame on you. Why didn't you give me everybody? Come on, you think I'm stupid? We're up at night reading the bylaws and Brown's Act. We're well versed. We're not just some angry parents. We're parents that will not go away until change is made and the people up here represent the children. I promised you that five months ago. Five months ago, I promised that, and I promised I would do everything possible with this group. We have parents working day and night, not taking a paycheck. Shame on you for taking a paycheck and then doing those things, not protecting our children. That is embarrassing.

SPEAKER_38 0:27:19

Julie Santosola, followed by Yi Yu Banks, followed by Caitlin Martinez.

SPEAKER_14 0:27:33

Good evening board and community. As you may know, my middle son, as you may know, my middle son has medical issues due to past vaccine injuries. Two weeks ago, he had his six month checkup with the specialist and we discussed the C-19 shot. excuse me, our doctor stated that under no circumstance should we at this time risk the shot due to his past reactions, current medical condition, as well as high risk to the side effects that are occurring in young males. With that said, the doctor wrote a medical exemption and then I proceeded to contact the school to find out what I could do to get it filed in his medical 504 plan that he currently has. I was told by the nurse that the exemption um would not be accepted because the pro district does not have any protocol so i and was told to contact sherry johnson which i did thursday and twice again this week and had to cc mr enfield to get a response um finally i was able to speak to mr gomez her administrative secretary wednesday morning that explained the sit i explained my situation and after um, placing me on a brief hold. And I'm assuming he talked to Mrs. Johnson, um, got back to me and stated, um, that at this time, the district was instructed to tell all the schools to not accept a medical exemptions because they are not required at this time. It was his understanding that the COVID-19 vaccination, um, has to go through legislation before it is added to the requirements.

SPEAKER_14 0:29:10

Okay, great. But no, of course there's a, but then he informed me that the letter that my doctor wrote would not be accepted. Um, per, um, current medical exemption processes effective January 1st. the medical exemptions would need to be submitted through the California Immunization Registry. Medical exemptions care me website, and he gave me the website, www.shotsformyschool.org was the most current information regarding care.me and vaccine requirements. As you can imagine, my shock that my son's medical exemption would not be accepted, nor I nor my doctor was aware of this website or that had been made effective January 2021. Going on to the website, I did look at these requirements. I could not find the requirements. The long list of things that need to be done, now I'm not gonna read this, long list of things that need to be done make it nearly impossible for my son in this government website to have his medical exemption approved. So it's being taken away from me as his parent and his doctor, it's being taken out of his hands. Because if it's denied, then it has to go through a long process. My understanding is the district knew about this in January, and shame on you guys for not making it public to any of your staff, to any of your parents. It needs to be made available.

SPEAKER_38 0:30:45

Yew banks, followed by Caitlin Martinez, followed by Byron Gonzalez.

SPEAKER_37 0:30:57

Dear Dr. Onsfield, members of the board, parents, teachers, and staff, my name is E.U. Banks and I'm currently a special ed teacher at the district and I'm also an Army veteran. When I was stationed in Panama, one of the first things that we were briefed on was not to get sunburned since Panama is one of the countries that's closer to the equator and we could be easily sunburned. We were warned that if we get burned easily, we could be charged with damage to government property. And that's when we first learned that military members could be technically considered government properties. As technically a piece of government property, we lose a lot of freedoms that we used to enjoy prior to signing up, such as when to wake up, when to sleep, what to wear down to our underwears, how to style our hairs, where we're allowed to go, when we're allowed to go, how far we're allowed to go, what color makeup we can use, and the list goes on and on. That is why, as a veteran, we more than anyone else value our freedom, our freedom to choose, the freedom to speak up, and the freedom to make the best choice we can for ourselves. We knew what it was like to not to be able to make our own choices. I got my American citizenship while serving in the Army, and it was the proudest moment in my life to choose to be a citizen of one of the most freest country in the world.

SPEAKER_37 0:32:19

I do not want my freedom to choose to be jeopardy at this time. I choose not to get the vaccine and I should not have to choose between my job or the vaccine. I got my freedom to choose back when I left the military because I'm no longer a piece of government property. We are not piece of government property where you can dictate what vaccine I should get. Thank you for listening.

SPEAKER_38 0:32:48

Kaitlyn Martinez, followed by Byron Gonzalez, followed by Carla Vandestique. Caitlin Martinez. Caitlin Martinez. Brian Gonzalez. They can't hear.

UNKNOWN 0:33:28

Thank you.

SPEAKER_32 0:33:58

Okay, good evening. I'm here to follow up again on my Schaefer complaint. So when I filed that, I filed it against an elected board member. I didn't file against an employee. So why do I have HR calling me who says he doesn't normally follow up on these for elected board members? Why am I not seeing an attorney or speaking with an attorney? Why am I not getting any of this in any kind of documentation? This is unethical and I know this isn't the approach that you guys are supposed to be taking. So I want to know where your guys' approach is supposed to be. There needs to be some guidelines you're following. I shouldn't be speaking to HR. You are elected. You're not an employee. HR doesn't represent you. He even said I don't speak to normally speak to people filing a complaint against the board. You guys have had complaints before. Have you had HR use them? Used HR? No. This needs to be addressed properly. He filed a false police report. That's not something minor. That's illegal. He broke bylaws here. That needs to be addressed properly. I shouldn't be speaking to Eric from HR. Lovely guy. Not the person I should be speaking to. You guys are dropping the ball time and time again. Tonight, this is absolute wreck. You should be ashamed of yourself, Schaefer, denying these venue changes. We shouldn't even be having to request them at this point. There's hundreds of parents out there.

SPEAKER_32 0:35:27

Hundreds. You can hear them. We shouldn't even be having to ask. Last one, even if it was only one-third of the way full. That's still over 100 parents. How many are here, minus the senior citizens? 15? For 26,000 students. That's ridiculous. Do better with this, follow up on my complaint properly, or I will make sure I get an attorney involved. So you guys make sure you get to get your attention. Let me know how you want to do it. I'm sure you don't want to go that way, but I will trust me. The last one already got a lot of attention. I already got a lot of offers on taking this and I will go that route. That's not what I'm here for. I'm here to try to work with you guys, but you guys have to start working with us. This is ridiculous. Do better.

SPEAKER_38 0:36:19

Brian Gonzalez, followed by Carla Vandesteeg, followed by Deborah Rosen.

SPEAKER_26 0:36:31

Hello there. I'm here to speak about the vaccine mandates because of course it started with the, of course it first started with the 15 days to flatten the curve. 15 days turned into 18 months. 18 months turned into get the vax or get fired against your will. Now that is being enforced by state and federal law. Now the fully vaccinated has changed from two shots to a third shot, which in Israel, the fourth shot is being tested as we speak. We are experiencing or willing authoritarianism as we speak, or in other words, communism. In other countries, this has led to millions and millions of murders. Here's the data. Vietnam, 1 million murders. Eastern Europe, 1 million murders. Ethiopia, 1.5 million murders. North Korea, 2 million murders. The Soviet Union, 20 million murders. China, 65 million murders. And my father's home country, Nicaragua, 30,000 murders. And those numbers are very low estimate. And to those of you who support these vaccine mandates, as well as those of you who are enforcing them, Once they're finished with us, they're coming after you. Thank you.

SPEAKER_18 0:38:02

Good evening, I'm Karla Vandesteg. Following me, most of them are all outside, are my colleagues, your employees who have worked relentlessly for this district and mostly for our students. Our government companies, district board, and even our very own unions are not fighting for us, so we'll stand in the gap and we'll fight for medical freedom ourselves. Right now, we have adopted a new form of discrimination and segregation in our district. It's called COVID-19 testing. Once a week, those of us that have exercised medical freedom of choice have to go to our supervisor, get a test, take it, and return it. Vaccinated people can get and spread COVID too, but they're not being discriminated against. the fact that on our campuses we teach and train against discrimination and now our district is implementing it is very hypocritical and in direct opposition to how we train our own students what a confusing message what's next separate drinking fountains separate bathrooms the sewing on of stars if we continue this that is where we are headed also if you enforce this unconstitutional mandate you will be having to terminate 400 to 500 employees this will put this district in extreme hardship You will also be putting yourselves in a tight spot since you'll be breaking the Nuremberg Code, Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act, and FDA's own policy. Have you considered what you will do to run this place once these 400 to 500 employees are terminated?

SPEAKER_18 0:39:16

Remember, we don't have enough subs on any normal day. Parents and teachers are saying they are willing to give up everything if this mandate is enforced here and some people laugh at that but it's true. I've literally already calculated what I will sell and I've started a business plan if I get terminated. We are standing against these mandates and none of us are walking away or being coerced. will have to terminate us i hope you have a plan we are all about data here in this district if the data matters in our teaching of standards then for sure the data matters for this vaccine you have been presented data over and over i'm not going to go over it if data matters then you must look at the data for this virus and this shot do the very thing you make us do There is no fully FDA approved COVID-19 shot available in America. The only fully approved one is available in Germany. FDA's own policy says if something is under emergency usage authorization, there must be informed consent. This mandate breaks their own policy. Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 also says that we can't be discriminated against because of our beliefs. Therefore, exemptions must be allowed. many people don't want to get an unproven shot because we're concerned and we want medical freedom and now we risk getting fired it's ludicrous that the hard-working people who are once heroes are now going to get terminated board dr infield i want to challenge you to stand up for the right thing and show that you value your employees and your students the very people that do their job well every day you have the opportunity to stand out like calaveras unified happy valley and many other districts that are standing against illegal mandates

SPEAKER_18 0:40:48

and are protecting their employees and students because you value those human beings. How about you act in bravery and show that you value the very students that you're responsible for and the teachers and staff that you employ and do the right thing and ignore this mandate, give us choice so that we can continue to do the jobs that we are passionate about. I'm going to stand up for the right thing. Your staff and your students, you won't regret it.

SPEAKER_11 0:41:16

Debra Rosen, followed by Jessica Brainitz, followed by Christina.

SPEAKER_25 0:41:35

Hi. Good evening, board. Hi. Good evening, board and bosses. I am a proud product of the Chino Valley Unified School District. I have promoted from Cortez Elementary, Magnolia Junior High, graduated with honors from Chino High School. My name is Deborah Rosen. I wanted to give back to the district and community who helped me to be all of who I am. I've given this district 29 years of service. I've been a substitute teacher, high school teacher at Iyalla, department chair. I've written grants for this district, helped on the WASC accreditation team. I've organized International Day for Students and started the Key Club over at Iyalla High School. I've been a master teacher helping college students become teachers. I've taken dozens of students and parents to Washington, DC, our capital, so they can experience what I have taught them in my classroom. I've been a school administrator. At Canyon Hills Junior High, I've started the study skills intervention class for at-risk students. I've developed Team Time, an organization to help general ed students help special ed kids acclimate into the school community. I've been on the instructional leadership team, an advisor for the Christian Club on campus for over a decade, a mentor teacher to struggling students. I've helped to develop many programs on campus, such as emergency procedures, student and staff recognition, and intervention for EL special ed and at-risk populations. I have been on the PBIS team on campus, coached teachers on how to use positive supports within their students and their classes.

SPEAKER_25 0:42:56

I love my job. I love my kids. Please consider what other districts are doing and allow teachers, staff, and students to choose what is best for their health. Other districts are defying the governor's mandate. I urge you all to do the same. I do not want to lose my job. I do not want to be fired. I do not want to be here today telling you all of these things. I've taught freedom in my history classes to thousands of children of this district. It would be a shame not to talk about medical freedom with you today, my bosses, by which is far the most important freedom of all, medical freedom. Thank you for your time, and thank you for listening to us.

SPEAKER_54 0:43:49

Hi, thank you for allowing me to speak. My name is Cesar Tran. I've been a teacher.

SPEAKER_11 0:43:54

I have a Jessica Brazenitz.

SPEAKER_18 0:43:58

This is the, they're using the all three minutes. Everybody's speaking within the three minutes.

SPEAKER_34 0:44:05

Okay, who put the speaker card in?

SPEAKER_53 0:44:07

I'm right here.

SPEAKER_34 0:44:08

Okay, it's your time then, ma'am.

SPEAKER_53 0:44:11

I'm gonna give this to us, go.

SPEAKER_54 0:44:14

Thank you for allowing me to speak. This is my 27th year serving at the Junior Unified School District, and I see some of my colleagues here in front of me. I serve as a coach and as a teacher. I coached high school track and field. I've been a faithful servant of this district. And I just come here to urge you to make the right decisions, to allow our students, our parents, our teachers to be able to work in freedom, I BELIEVE THAT IT IS. and overreached by the government to force me to put a medicine inside me that I don't need, and that taken away my liberty. And I just want to say that 47 years ago, me and my family escaped from a communist country to come here and to be allowed the liberty and the freedom to serve. And I just feel like it is all over again. So I urge you to make the right call, and that is it.

SPEAKER_48 0:45:19

hi good evening my name is roberta koloka and i am currently working at wickman elementary i've been in the school district for 16 years and i was a special education teacher and i chose to go back into the general education classroom i have two children one of them actually was a student member here and for the district and also um The other one, they're both grown up. They both have their jobs. They're both a product of the Chino Valley Unified School District. So I'm very proud of them. And I strongly agree with a person's right to choose to get vaccinated or not. Thank you.

SPEAKER_05 0:46:00

My name is Christy Hayes. I've been a teacher for 12 years. This is my eighth year in Chino Valley Unified School District. I have served for three years on the PBIS Tier 1 team. I am the PBIS Tier 2 coach at this time. I am a special ed teacher. I've served six summers in CVUSD.

SPEAKER_53 0:46:25

Hi, my name is Jessica Braznitz. I graduated from this district. I am now a teacher for six years. I was a substitute teacher for three years prior to that. I have my master's in education. I have my GATE certificate. I'm an independent study coordinator at my school. I've done after-skate GATE program. I've done the enrichment summer program. I'm a school set council member, and 200 students have gone through my classroom. Hi, my name is Joy Holliday.

SPEAKER_11 0:46:54

CHRISTIE WOODARD. CHRISTINA, FOLLOWED BY JULIE VAN DEL, FOLLOWED BY TANYA MACIAS. CHRISTINA. ARE YOU CHRISTINA? YES.

SPEAKER_53 0:47:05

HI. MY NAME IS JOY HOLIDAY. I'VE BEEN WORKING WITH THE DISTRICT OR INSIDE THE DISTRICT FOR 10 YEARS. I WORK WITH SPECIAL ED. I'M A ONE-ON-ONE AID, AND I'VE ALSO HAD KIDS THAT HAVE GONE THROUGH ALL THE SCHOOLS HERE FOR 19 YEARS, AND I'M TOTALLY AGAINST THIS MANDATE. THANK YOU.

SPEAKER_59 0:47:24

My name is Christina. I've been with the district for 14 years. I've served in the roles of a one-on-one aide with special education, collaborative aide, attendance clerk, and registrar. I was also involved with the Safe School Ambassadors. Prior to employment, I have served nine years as an elementary classroom volunteer and chaperone. I also taught for six years release time Christian education. For four years, I served as a band booster, chaperone, and board member in the junior high level, and seven years as a swim booster, high school band booster, chaperone, and co-chair. It's been a pleasure working for the CVUSD. I'm also speaking on behalf of Albert, who has worked for the district for 13 years as a custodian at Chino High School and Aborba Elementary and Ayala High School. It's been a pleasure working for CBUSD. My name is Verna Franco. I'm an instructional aide, and I've worked for the district for 16 years. And it's been an honor and a pleasure to work with the students and with this fabulous team from the Chino Valley School District. So thank you for having us here today.

SPEAKER_53 0:48:36

My name is Nicole Vacario. I have worked for the district for a total of 14 years. I've served as a noon ground substitute at many elementary schools, nutrition services at Chino High School, and nine years as AP secretary at Ayala High School. I've served on school site council, safe school ambassadors. I am also a parent in the district. I have eight children, and I cannot lose my job to this nonsense. I do not agree with this mandate. I'm Jill Anderson. I am a Don Lugo alumni. My husband is Ayala alumni. I've been an employee for 10 years. I currently am a part of the PBIS team, safe school ambassador, school site council. I am on the board, the booster board of Ayala cheer, two of those teams, competitive cheer. I'm not prepared to lose my job. Please help us with freedom of choice. Thank you very much. Oh, I'm also speaking for Devin Rocha, who can't be here tonight. She has served for six years as an employee, five years on the PFA as a board member, as well as I was for seven years at the Liberty Elementary PFA Board. I'm speaking on behalf of Ivana Mora, who can't be here today. She served as a health tech for Ayala High School for a total of 15 years.

SPEAKER_06 0:49:50

I'm Jacqueline Braznitz, I'm in Liberty Elementary School. I've been there for 27 years. I have a master's of education. I am an independent study coordinator, PAR coordinator, grade level chair, leadership intervention teacher, homework club, PFA president, school site council, summer school intervention, summer school enrichment, and I've educated thousands of students. And I love my job.

SPEAKER_38 0:50:12

Julie Benn.

SPEAKER_34 0:50:12

Pat, Pat. Julie Benn. We've reached the 30 minute time.

SPEAKER_11 0:50:17

Okay.

SPEAKER_01 0:50:22

Let's please extend it further. Do we have a motion? Yes.

SPEAKER_29 0:50:27

Do we have consensus?

SPEAKER_52 0:50:28

I have consensus. I give my consensus.

SPEAKER_34 0:50:35

Okay. We don't have consensus, so we will be happy to wait and listen to everybody at the end of the meeting for non-agenda items, but we are going to move on to our action items. Changes and deletions. Pat, are there any changes and deletions?

SPEAKER_38 0:50:46

There are none.

SPEAKER_29 0:50:51

Okay, without objection, I'm going to move action item 2B1 up and take that first.

SPEAKER_34 0:51:01

Public hearing to receive 50 teachers out there. 50 teachers out there.

SPEAKER_14 0:51:08

That's a dirty shame, isn't it?

SPEAKER_34 0:51:11

That's fine. We also have people that are here for other action items.

SPEAKER_53 0:51:15

We don't have this meeting without teachers. Thank you. Thank you. We are now moving on to action item 2B1.

SPEAKER_15 0:51:24

We're going to get pretty close to that.

SPEAKER_29 0:51:50

We're now moving on to item 2B1, public hearing to receive community input on the request to name or dedicate a facility at Chino High School after Mark Hargrove. Recommend the Board of Education conduct a public hearing to receive community input on the request to name or dedicate a facility at Chino High School after Mark Hargrove. We now open the public hearing at 6.51.

SPEAKER_34 0:52:18

Are there any requests to speak?

SPEAKER_38 0:52:20

Jennifer Hargrove, followed by Scott Rosen. Let us speak! Let us speak! Let us speak!

UNKNOWN 0:52:25

Let us speak! Let us speak! Let us speak! Let us speak! Let us speak! Let us speak! Let us speak!

SPEAKER_01 0:52:33

Let us speak!

UNKNOWN 0:52:34

Let us speak!

SPEAKER_01 0:52:35

Let us speak!

UNKNOWN 0:52:36

Let us speak!

SPEAKER_34 0:52:37

Let us speak! Let us speak! Terry, I'm sorry. We're going to take five minutes. We're going to take a five minute recess.

UNKNOWN 0:52:57

Thank you.

SPEAKER_59 0:57:08

What are they telling us?

SPEAKER_34 0:57:35

Okay, it is 6.57. We are going to return back to our agenda items.

SPEAKER_29 0:57:40

Because of the current climate, the family of Mr. Hartgrove has asked if we pull item 2B1 and place it on a meeting at a future date. So the public hearing is closed with no speakers, and it has been pulled. Pat, will you make sure that the record indicates that? Yes.

SPEAKER_11 0:58:02

Yes, I will note that in the record.

SPEAKER_29 0:58:04

Thank you. My apologies to Terry and the family. OK, moving back up now to item 2A1, a revision of administrative regulation 5145.3, students, nondiscrimination, harassment of students. Board member James Naugh recommends approval of the revision to administrative regulation 5145.3, students, nondiscrimination, harassment of students.

SPEAKER_34 0:58:40

Are there any speakers? We have 28 speakers. Speakers, please remember that the names will be called in the order in which they were received, and all the time limits and lights also apply as earlier.

SPEAKER_00 0:58:55

Point of order. Please. Point of order. We're moving on to an action item, and we have students inside the room and outside of the room. I would just request decorum.

SPEAKER_29 0:59:06

Pat, go ahead with the speakers, please.

SPEAKER_11 0:59:08

America Aguyo.

SPEAKER_38 0:59:11

Did I say that wrong? Followed by Camilla Salas, followed by Carolyn Salas. Jeez.

SPEAKER_49 0:59:36

My name is Marian Arguello. And yes, I am a senior citizen, but I did help put my grandchildren through this school district. I tutored in both of their classes. I was room mother for each. And my daughter taught them softball for their recreation at time. So it's not like we don't have a little bit of investment in this school district. But once again, Mr. Na is trying to remove rights of anybody, but now especially the LBGQT plus children in our school district, only because of his religious beliefs. There was no time for this. When he was in the majority of the school board, he passed a resolution to ignore a law. about the same people. And not until we got a new regime where he was not in the majority did we finally get things straightened out in that era, area, pardon me. Now, Mr. Na is only wasting the board's time. It is time just to stop this insanity and focus on our children and our needs in the schools instead of wasting all of your time with this crap. Thank you.

SPEAKER_38 1:01:11

Camila Salas. Camila Salas, Carolyn Salas, Jasmine Rivera. Who is the next person? Camilla Salas.

SPEAKER_28 1:01:36

Hello, board members.

SPEAKER_21 1:01:39

Adjust the mic.

SPEAKER_34 1:01:42

There you go. Thank you.

SPEAKER_13 1:01:43

Good evening, I am Camilla Aguero Salas and I'm here from Don Lugo High School. I am a senior and today I'm speaking as part of the LGBTQ community and as an ally to transgender and gender nonconforming students in our district. What the district is proposing, the school board is proposing is an attack against our trans and gender nonconforming students. It will isolate them and make them targets for more backlash. It can have deteriorating effects on their mental health. We've already spent much time struggling through the pandemic. Even since before the pandemic, students have had distrust in our district from the lack of transparency and lack of communication, especially for minority families such as myself. The pandemic has made this relationship between the district and the people that they represent even more strained and distant. And it will become even more distant if this proposal is passed because our students will feel that their district does not respect them and does not value them. Although I cannot speak about discriminatory experiences towards trans or gender nonconforming students, as I am cisgender, I have heard their experience. I've heard from my friends, from my peers, and I've heard their rude comments in the back of the room. And unfortunately, I never had the courage to speak up, but here I am speaking because if this proposal is passed, this will affect all trans and gender nonconforming students, and not just them, but all the students in our schools.

SPEAKER_13 1:03:29

It will make them feel that the district does not value them, and they will feel more attacked by the district and more distant from them. Some students are not accepted as they are in their homes and school is where they go to feel safe. However, how can they feel safe if even their school is against them? And there is no denying that students will be prone to more bullying, more unnecessary proceedings when their school can easily allow them to live freely and as they are. The policy that the district enacts are supposed to be for the purpose of making students feel safe and respected. And that means all students. What this revision will do is only let students know the district does not care for them. I should not have to explain to you why trans and gender nonconforming students deserve your respect and your understanding. Since in this current time in history, it is no secret how much trans and gender nonconforming folks and activists have fought for generations just for human decency. They have risked their safety and their lives. There is no reason why our trans and gender nonconforming students don't deserve that same respect that people have fought for.

SPEAKER_04 1:04:42

Time.

SPEAKER_13 1:04:45

Thank you.

SPEAKER_38 1:04:49

Carolina Salas, followed by Jasmine Rivera, followed by River Han.

SPEAKER_51 1:05:00

Good evening, board. My name is Carolina Salas, and today I will be speaking on behalf of my friend Max. Hello. My name is Maxwell Arambula. My pronouns are he, him, and I am a transgender student at Don Lugo High School. Speaking from personal experience, my school is one of the only places I can feel safe and comfortable with myself. And I know I'm not the only one in the entire district who also feels this way. For some of us, home is not a place where we can express ourselves and feel comfortable in our bodies. We are at school nearly half of our waking days, so why can't we make school a safe haven from our home lives? While the case in Virginia is unfortunate, it is irresponsible and ignorant to make the accusation that all transgender students are a threat to cisgender students at school. We want a chance to fit in just like everyone else. We want a comfortable environment to change for gym classes. We want to choose the restrooms we feel comfortable using. And we want the ability to be called by the names we chose to fit ourselves. School is supposed to be a safe place for all students to be themselves and have equal opportunities, whether it be learning in their facility or just having to be there because they just aren't old enough to leave. If we're going to be there anyways, why can't we just be left alone and respected?

SPEAKER_51 1:06:27

While I do agree that it is okay to have concerns for needing to enforce a sex assigned at birth policy, I strongly believe that these policies will have a predominantly negative impact on students in the long run. I believe that separating facilities by sex assigned at birth is not getting to the root of the problems when it comes to sexual assault cases. I believe this is an act of blunt transphobia hidden behind a greater issue. This is a great disrespect to me, sexual assault victims, and other transgender students. Thank you for your time.

SPEAKER_11 1:07:06

Jasmine Rivera, followed by River Hahn, followed by Cheyenne Fernandez. Thank you.

SPEAKER_27 1:07:19

Hello attendees and board members. I'm a student at Chino Hills high school, and I'm in opposition to the proposed policy revision of administrative regulation, 51 45.3 students, non-discrimination slash harassment of students. In 2016, board member James Na and board member Andrew Cruz ran their campaigns with the slogan, Strong Family Value Candidates. I ask you the question now, what are those strong family values? Protection? Well, stripping away the rights of transgender and gender non-conforming students who, might I add, are already an extremely marginalized group, doesn't seem like a very strong adherence to the value of protection. How about love? In the Bible, which I've heard you, Mr. Na, say, so value, it's said that thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself, Matthew 22, 39. It makes me unsettled that this policy deliberately excludes transgender students under the guise of safety, protection, equality, and love. It goes against what you stand for. Furthermore, I find this an ample opportunity to ask the people in this room, especially those in positions of power, to educate themselves on what exactly the words transgender, gender, sex, and intersex mean. This is because if you were to pass these policies or speak against the queer community, I would hope that you've done enough research to back your claims. The policy revision in question is not worded well. It sounds as though little research and little effort was put into this. effort and care that your students desperately need. We are in a time of progress where compassion is desperately needed.

SPEAKER_27 1:08:57

I recently come across an anonymous quote that states, when you're accustomed to privilege, equality feels like oppression. The privilege you have to identify as the gender you were assigned to at birth is one you should use to help trans youth not ostracize, belittle or oppress them. Thank you.

SPEAKER_11 1:09:22

That was you, sorry. River Hahn, followed by Cheyenne Fernandez, followed by Lilia Heredia.

SPEAKER_10 1:09:37

Hello, I am volunteering to read an anonymous response on behalf of a CVUSD student. When asked, what are your thoughts about the policy and its proposed changes? They responded, this is a direct attack on the rights of our fellow gender nonconforming and transgender students on campus. It is a basic right that they deserve and yet it is being taken away. It is not their fault that they were born in the wrong body and this is not the lifestyle they chose. This is who they are. It is mind boggling that their rights are still even being debated by people who will never experience how they will ever feel and are being treated the same as some other political topic. This is not and will never just be some political topic. These are their rights and should be treated as such. Give transgender and gender nonconforming students their rights they deserve as human beings. When asked, how will this proposed policy change your experience on campus? How do you feel about this? They responded, I personally do not identify as transgender or gender non-confirming. However, I know many who do, and I know how important their rights are. By implementing this policy, it will only make the lives of these students more difficult than they already are. The suicide rate within transgender and non-conforming people is astronomical enough as it is and something that you may deem not important, such as what the policy is going directly against.

SPEAKER_10 1:10:52

It is in fact something big and important to a transgender or gender non-conforming student. As a friend of many transgender and gender non-conforming students on campus, it breaks my heart already to watch the struggles they already face every day on campus for being the person that they are and the policy will only make things worse for them. When asked, how do you feel this proposed policy will affect others around you? They responded, I said earlier, the policy will affect my close transgender and gender nonconforming friends who do not identify with the gender that they were assigned with at birth. This policy will make school life all that much harder for them and it will prevent them from being their true selves. Do they not deserve their rights just because they were born in the wrong body? These students will struggle and suffer because of the policy. When asked, is there anything else you want us to know? They responded, transgender and gender non-conforming students are still students and deserve their rights. Is this policy really trying to protect us or is it an attempt to let the true colors of the board shine through, give students the rights they deserve regardless of how they identify? Thank you.

SPEAKER_11 1:11:56

Cheyenne Fernandez, followed by Leila Heredia, followed by Adri Rodriguez.

SPEAKER_20 1:12:10

Good evening, District Board members, Chino community, and other supporting parties. My name is Cheyenne Fernandez, and I'm a senior at Don Legault High School. And I'm here to address item 2A1 proposed by Mr. James Na in a revision of student non-discrimination. I'm outraged with the discrimination that our students are being faced with through this revision to district policy, not only because I identify as a student of LGBTQIA plus and a queer person, but because this is an outright restriction of civil rights for our students. To start, biological sex cannot be equivocated to gender. The sex you were assigned with at birth is not reflective of gender identification. Therefore, the revision of policy is incorrect. This is a discriminatory policy change enforcing the transphobic environment on our Chino Valley campuses, which is not protecting the student's best interests or their safety. Under titles seven and nine, it is illegal to prohibit gender identification in schools for the protection of all transgender, gender nonconforming, gender fluid, and gender queer students. Students deserve to live, grow, and learn in a non-discriminatory environment where they feel safe, protected, seen, and heard. In addition, in the state of California, restricting students to bathrooms on the basis of their sex they were assigned with at birth is legal. Therefore, students should have the freedom to go by their own gender identification. Regardless of your political and religious views, as educators, your number one priority should be the lives and safety of your students.

SPEAKER_20 1:13:30

Now I would like to pose the question, as a board of education, would you rather contribute to the statistics of transgender and non-binary annual suicide rates? Or are you too worried about the small likelihood that a strong cis male student would identify as female for athletic achievement? The Human Rights Campaign reports that more than half of trans male teens reported have attempted suicide, among the 29.9% of trans females and 41.8% of non-binary youth. This statistic should be dropping and not increasing. And the only way to prevent higher statistics is to have a safe, loving, and inclusive environment for trans and gender non-conforming students. to prosper. If this policy were to change, there are going to be a group of students who are now forced to conform to an identity that they are not, creating an unsafe, uncomfortable and extremely dysphoric situation for them, increasing their depression, anxiety, gender dysphoria and the suicide rates. Queer, trans, and non-binary students should not have to go through the extreme hardships that they already do in addition to the component of not being able to use the facility that they seem best fit for their gender identification and to express their true selves on campus. Passing this policy would be inequitable to them. In addition, there is a separation of church and state for a reason, especially within our school system. Enforcing this policy is influenced by religious motivations and ideals and should not and cannot be pushed upon our students.

SPEAKER_20 1:14:50

All of our students deserve love, equality, and support in their lives and on our campuses, giving them the best opportunity to be their true selves and succeed. I hope you take into true consideration what this policy change could do to the students' lives and their well-being, knowing to protect them by not going through with this transphobic revision. Everyone, please remember to protect trans youth and trans lives. Thank you for your time.

SPEAKER_11 1:15:14

Leila Heredia, followed by Adri Rodriguez, followed by Morgan Burton.

SPEAKER_36 1:15:20

Hello, I'm volunteering to read an anonymous testimony on behalf of a CVUSD student. One asked, what are your thoughts, what are your thoughts about the policy and its proposed changes? They responded, it's harmful and oppressive towards the already marginalized groups. The fact that it is, the fact that it is, The fact that it is even being considered is ridiculous. I believe that transphobes aren't ready to realize that they're actually enabling more sexual assault sexual assault cases with this policy change. One asked, How will this proposed policy change your experience on the campus? How do you feel about this? They responded, I feel that this would discourage more people from coming out and remain closeted, which goes against supposed principal values of the school district. and this policy change will only increase the amount of abuse and trauma faced by those who identify as LGBTQ+. One asked, how do you feel about this proposed policy and how do you think others around you, how do you feel this proposed policy will affect you and others around you? They responded, I think it would make more people I know uncomfortable in the school environment. Thank you for your time.

SPEAKER_11 1:16:48

Audrey Rodriguez, followed by Morgan Burton, followed by Andrew Asbedo. Audrey Rodriguez.

SPEAKER_38 1:17:05

Audrey Rodriguez. Audrey, A-D-R-I Rodriguez. Morgan Burton. Oh, she's gone.

SPEAKER_09 1:17:25

Hello, I am so sorry about that. Thank you. Hello, I'm Audrey. My pronouns are they, them, and that will not be discussed. As a student, I am really disappointed at the fact that we are here arguing over basic human rights, the right to use the restroom. I'm setting that in this day and age, students who are part of the LGBT community have to live with their reality, that they're not being protected or cared for by the school districts. Changing this policy to segregate students by biological sex and not students' gender identity is primitive. Forcing trans youths to reveal their sex to participate in school activities that does not align with their gender identity is harmful. Being able to participate in extracurricular activities elevates one's learning experience and even improves academic participation. by a huge margin. Having a safe social environment creates a place where youth can find others who reflect their insurance, improve social skills, and improve their mental and physical well-being. This policy will lower participation in school's activities, thus creating a drop in attendance in a harmful environment that can lead to thoughts of self-harm, depression, and even suicide. 39% of LGBT youth and more than 50% of trans and non-binary youth commit suicide, mainly because they don't feel safe in their learning environments. You can make a change and protect the students and give them an education without barriers, make them feel safe, but instead you're hindering the rights of these students.

SPEAKER_09 1:18:49

These attacks on transgender and gender non-confirming individuals is a clear violation of the First Amendment and Title IX. The First Amendment hinders unlicensed systems to censor young person's speech or expression, protects the rights of youths to be out, display symbols of pride, and wear clothing consistent with their gender. The First Amendment also gives you the right to be free from religious indoctrination. If this policy is passed, it will be a violation of Title IX, a federal law which bans discrimination based on sex, protects students at schools and receive federal funds. Title IX is not only include discrimination from being a girl or boy, but also includes sexual harassment and discrimination for failing to conform to gender stereotypes. Forcing trans youth to participate in school extracurricular activities based on biological sex creates a dangerous environment for these students. This can also lead to harassment such as misgendering and dead naming, which is considered harassment and a violation of one's civil rights within California law. These students look to you to support them. They look to you to create an educational system that will be safe and that will create equity within the educational system. They look up to you to feel safe in the school environments. And if you pass this new policy, you are failing us all, as adults, as community members, and as educators. The year of being silent and not standing up for our education are over. I will not be silent, nor will I be afraid.

SPEAKER_09 1:20:10

We deserve to have safe educational environments. And I want to tell all the members of our community who attend CBUSD, you are heard and you are not alone. Thank you for your time.

SPEAKER_11 1:20:21

Morgan Burton, followed by Andrew Ezebedo, followed by Alex Padilla.

SPEAKER_45 1:20:37

Remember my name. I'm about to be speaking on the behalf of the LGBTQ policies. If you're willing to lose lives because of your lack of acceptance in the schools and community, I'd look over these policies again because those are checks that you guys are depending on and those seats are going to be taken. And the only time a school can legally restrict a student's speech is when it causes significant disruption in classes. I'm pretty sure someone trying to respectfully be called something else is not really disturbing a class. It's actually disturbing any of you guys' homophobia. A student does not have to go above and beyond as the extent of getting a legalized document and notarized document stating their gender or pronouns that are violent. Title IX is a federal civil rights law in the United States of America that was passed as a part of the Education Amendment of 1972. It prohibits sex-based discrimination in any school or education program that receives federal money, aka all of you. California Education Code 220 prohibits discrimination on the basis of gender identity and gender expression in addition to sexual orientation and other characteristics. If you're still having a little bit of trouble understanding your power and my rights, then I would go to csva.org, final guidance, AB 1266, March 2014. and that's something all of you guys as bosses meet. This is my first week of school at your district. Is this really the characteristics you guys want to project?

SPEAKER_45 1:22:17

My name is Morgan Burton, and if you want to silence my voice, remember my name. Thank you.

SPEAKER_11 1:22:27

Andrea Acevedo, followed by Alex Padilla. Followed by Maya Ma. Andrew Acevedo

SPEAKER_55 1:23:02

Good evening. My name is Andrew. I am non-binary and my pronouns are he, they. I am here today to speak on behalf of myself and my community. As members of the school board, it is your duty to ensure that schools are a safe and inclusive environment. With this proposed revision, you are not only creating a space that is exclusive to queer individuals as myself, but simply intolerant of our existence. It should not be my job to stand here today to speak on the importance of respecting basic human rights. Since the start of this pandemic, the rate of mental illness among students has been on the rise, especially LGBTQ students. And while extracurriculars are supposed to benefit the education and social and emotional development of students, By forcing trans and gender non-conforming students to use restrooms and partake in extracurriculars that are only in line with their biological sex, you are doing nothing more than harming your students. The comfortability of cisgender students has been prioritized for too long at the expense of our community. Now is the time to educate our students to practice kindness, tolerance, and equity. Teach them to be active members in our evolving society and not concern themselves on what is involved in someone's pants. Thank you.

SPEAKER_11 1:24:14

Alex Padilla, followed by Maya Ma, followed by Ryan Sheng.

SPEAKER_19 1:24:31

Good evening, Dr. Enfield, board members, and community. My name is Chloe Padilla, but I prefer to be recognized as Alex and my pronouns are they, them. As someone who is part of the LGBTQ plus community, I would like to talk about the issues that the others and I face at school. A senior at Don Lago said, every time I go into the boys locker room, I feel uncomfortable because I identify as female and not male. Another Don Lugo student who is part of the LGBTQ community said, needing to go to the restroom is hard. I must go to the nurse's office to use the restroom because there are no gender-neutral bathrooms. I understand the narrative by the CVUSD board members may be focused on the idea that perhaps transgender bathrooms mean opening a row of bathrooms to anyone who claims to be a particular gender, but that narrative is all wrong. The solution here is not a new or radical concept. All schools should have private gender neutral bathrooms for any students to use in the same normal way that homes have bathrooms for guests to use, and many restaurants have bathrooms that are not labeled for the sexes. Barnes & Noble, Starbucks, American Airlines, Wells Fargo, Whole Foods, and Bank of America follow suit. These companies have laid the groundwork as a model for the successful implementation of having transgender bathrooms. As a community, we still shop and engage with these companies and consumers, and rarely do we question our safety.

SPEAKER_19 1:26:25

The reality for students is this. If I go into the boys' restroom, I put myself at risk of any transphobic person in these restrooms every day. It negatively affects my mental health, and it makes me not want to come to school. As a person who is non-binary, I find it difficult and uncomfortable to go to the restrooms. Please change your narrative to focus on securing private gender neutral bathrooms on all four high school campuses. Thank you.

SPEAKER_11 1:27:08

Maya Ma, followed by Ryan Shang, followed by Michaela Hernandez.

SPEAKER_35 1:27:21

Hello, everyone. I'm Minji Maya Ma from Chino Hills High School, and I'm volunteering to read someone's response from the Google form. So when we asked, what are the thoughts about the policy and its purpose changes? They responded, this affects people I care about. This is just more stress and more confusing for them at a time in their life when they still may not be fully comfortable in themselves, and this is just adding fuel to the fire. Another one is when asked, how will the purpose policy changes your experience on campuses? How do you feel about this? They responded, I personally will be able to keep and use the girl bathroom when I identify us. But my friend will now have to use another bathroom. They may not be fully comfortable in all of the time, meaning they could feel completely unsupported by the school. Thank you.

SPEAKER_11 1:28:20

Ryan Sheng, followed by Michaela Hernandez.

SPEAKER_42 1:28:29

Hi, I'm Ryan Sheng, and I'm a junior from Chinook Hills High School. I'm here to read a response from an online forum. One asked, how do you feel this proposed policy will affect others around you? They responded, as I said before, a close friend is non-binary and this means they may not be able to use bathroom they are comfortable with. I take for granted being comfortable doing basic human daily functions, bodily functions, in an area where I feel decently comfortable when they may not. Thank you.

SPEAKER_38 1:29:16

Michaela Hernandez.

UNKNOWN 1:29:27

How many more speakers?

SPEAKER_29 1:29:40

Please, ma'am. Board members, we are at 30 minutes. This is an action item that we will be taking action on this evening. Is there consensus to hear the rest of the speakers since we will be taking action? Yes.

SPEAKER_34 1:29:51

Okay. Please continue, ma'am.

SPEAKER_44 1:29:54

Hello to everyone here this evening. My name is Michaela Hernandez from Chena Hills High School, and I'm a part of our associated student body as a commissioner of school culture. And to be in that position, it's my job to defend every student at our school, no matter what race, gender, and especially ethnicity and gender. When asked, how will this proposed policy change your experience on campus? How do you feel about this? A student within this district responded, I feel very uncomfortable. As a non-binary student who already refuses to enter single sex bathrooms, this just makes the problem worse than it was before. This policy makes me feel worse, more invalidated, and makes it feel like they're trying to reinforce cisgender only I should not be seen as less than just because I'm myself. When asked, what are your thoughts about the policy and its proposed changes? Another student responded, this policy is incredibly discriminatory towards me and other trans and or gender nonconforming students attending these schools. I can understand where the board is coming from, but one incident from one student should not mean that they should punish our entire community of people. This, in my opinion, makes the problem even worse than it already is. This is only feeding into the harmful stereotypes surrounding transgender people, which will lead to more assault. This policy is a very poor choice led by the student board and is not a solution to the problem whatsoever.

SPEAKER_44 1:31:19

The problem is not transgender students, it's the assaulters. teach men not to harm or touch women without their consent, not to scare, discriminate, or harm towards the actual transgender people. Thank you.

SPEAKER_11 1:31:37

Reese Ely, followed by Madison Knapp, followed by Anshu Joshi. Yoshi? Hello.

SPEAKER_39 1:31:53

Hi. My name is Reece Healy, and I'm the ASB president of Chino Hills High School. You want to hear the students' best interests, so I can definitely help with that. As a result of my position, I'm able to speak on the behalf of the students, something that not necessarily adults can't. So today, I present you with the voice of the students. Part of my constitution and part of the reason why I was voted to be president and a leader by majority of the students on campus is the promise to make every student comfortable. And this is exactly what the students have in their best benefit. Students who are transgender are already part of the minority. They're already discriminated against at home, in their outside lives, and quite frankly, the majority of society, evident in the fact that this is a conversation in the first place. Therefore, the very least we can do is create a safe environment for these students because you are A, all leaders given your positions, and B, because they're just as deserving of the basic human right than any of us here today. Now, you can refute my statement in the fact that you are proposing gender-neutral bathrooms and other accommodations, but there's no need to accommodate a basic human right. You are given it plain and full. In addition, it's essentially still a form of segregation. I heard civil rights brought up earlier, so I would also like to use that as an argument point.

SPEAKER_39 1:33:03

If I were placed in the 50s as a person of color, I would have to use my own bathroom. Now, after the civil rights movement, we can all conclude that that's wrong. It's plain and simple. So where is that same energy in this situation, especially if we are in a constantly evolving society? You can also refute me by saying that the presence of transgender students and their choice of bathroom could make others uncomfortable. But I propose and conclude with this. We promote a culture of making people comfortable in their very own skin. And if someone is uncomfortable because of someone else's skin, body, race, or let alone choice of bathroom, then that is exactly where the problem derives from. Thank you.

SPEAKER_11 1:33:42

Madison Knapp, followed by Anshul Joshi, followed by America Nguyo.

SPEAKER_30 1:33:54

Thank you. My name is Madison Knapp. I am a transgender student at High School. I don't represent much. I am merely another student. while I can't claim to be of great import like you people are, you are still here. You have quite a lot of power, which I cannot claim to have. After all, we have the president, the vice president, we have our superintendent here. The thing is, As a transgender student, I cannot claim to actually be discriminated against at home, but at school is where I can claim to be discriminated against. Students pass comments behind my back without even my scant knowing, and that's a problem in of its entirety. But the thing is, another thing is just using a restroom should not be such a hot button, as one would say, Just to be allowed to use these restaurants shouldn't be some talking point for debate. It should just be allowed, period, full stop. I thank you for your time.

SPEAKER_11 1:35:11

Anshul Joshi, followed by America Aguayo, followed by Madeline De La Torre.

SPEAKER_54 1:35:26

Hello, my name is Anshul Joshi, the ASB secretary representing some of the many unheard voices from Chino Hills High School. I am volunteering to read some of the teacher-given responses from an online forum. When they were asked, what are your thoughts about the policy and its proposed changes, they responded with, an unnecessary change that will make our campuses feel less welcoming and potentially harm the emotional well-being of a group of students who are already at high risk. Also, when asked, how will this proposed policy change your experience on campus? How do you feel about this? They responded with, my job is to make students feel like they have a place on campus. I oversee all activities on campus and provide guidance to those who want to create an environment that welcomes and cultivates diversity. This proposed change will make students feel excused and unwelcome on our campus. If you care about our students, you want them to feel welcome in every part of campus, which they go to every single day. Thank you.

SPEAKER_46 1:36:37

Good evening, my name is America Aguayo and I'm an eighth grader at Ramona Junior High School and I also have the title of ASB Vice President. I've come here to speak about the new revision on the diversity policy. This revision makes me and my peers absolutely disgusted. Students should not have to feel like they can't express themselves at a place that they should feel accepted and comfortable at. Students should be able to be respected as we are expected to give our respect to teachers. Although the tragedy that happened in a Virginia school bathroom is disgusting, it doesn't relate at all to the young children who identify as transgender and gender non-conforming. The logic behind this whole revision is not very smart. On one hand, gender is not the same as sex. Sex is biological, meaning X and Y chromosomes, female, male, and intersex. Gender is not biological. This is the way someone chooses to identify as. Bi-gender, transgender, cisgender, gender fluid, gender queer, non-binary, I can go on and on, but you get the point. I really hope you reconsider your decision for the sake of all the students. Thank you.

SPEAKER_11 1:37:39

Madeline De La Torre, followed by Maxie Barra, followed by Kaylee Couch.

SPEAKER_53 1:37:52

Hello, my name is Madeline De La Torre and I'm the Senior Class Vice President at Chino's High School. As a representative of my high school, it is vital for me to voice the opinions for those who feel like they can't. I'm volunteering to read two teacher responses from an online forum. When asked, how do you feel this proposed policy will affect others around you? They responded with, it will affect the students I work with and make them feel like they aren't welcome to our campus. On another form, when questioned, is there anything else you want us to know? They responded with, all students should feel welcome and accepted on campus. The actions of one individual cannot shape our opinions of the rest of the group. In this instance, that individual was not truly a part of the group. As seen for this, not only will the students be negatively affected by this proposed policy, but our teachers will too. Thank you.

SPEAKER_11 1:38:42

Max Ibarra, followed by Kaylie Couch, followed by Jim Gallagher.

SPEAKER_56 1:38:49

Good evening board. I am a student at a CVUSD high school, and I am proud to say that I am transgender and non-binary. Mr. Na, you requested the policy revision in order to protect the safety of female students as a result of a recent sexual assault case by a male student. But these changes do not achieve that safety. First of all, saying this is solely to protect female students after this sexual assault completely ignores one, male victims of sexual assault, and two, that sexual assault can happen between two people of the same gender. These changes shouldn't be made in response to a sexual assault case because you cannot punish an entire group of marginalized people for one bad person. You cannot say that you support trans kids and respect their gender identity and then force them to use the bathroom of the opposite gender. This is inhumane. How would you even plan to execute this? Are you gonna place guards outside of the restrooms that memorize every trans kid on campus? Are you gonna make us show our school IDs to see our assigned sex at birth to just use the restroom? The fact of the matter is that there's no humane way to execute these changes because the very changes themselves are inhumane. If these changes do pass, trans girls will be forced to go to the boys' bathroom and trans boys will be forced to go to the girls' bathrooms. This will force people to out themselves to their peers.

SPEAKER_56 1:40:03

Trans girls will be made fun of by the boys in the restrooms and girls will feel unsafe when trans boys walk into the girls' restroom because they don't know they're trans. They'll just think a boy is sneaking into the girls' restroom to cause them harm. This will put trans kids in danger of being bullied, assaulted, a group of kids that already has higher rates of self-harm and suicide. These changes will put tons of trans kids through unnecessary harm and avoidable harm. Let me repeat, unnecessary and avoidable harm. If you allow these changes to go through, you are telling every trans kid that their pain is worth it to keep the bigoted transphobic people quiet and happy. Instead of these transphobic policy changes, we should be focusing on sexual assault prevention measures, preferably starting in middle school, educating our students. This can include lessons of teaching what enthusiastic consent looks like, teaching kids not to view other people as objects and keeping a close eye on people that have multiple reports of verbal abuse and getting them help before anything worse happens. I am not going to ask or beg the board to make sure these changes don't pass. Every member should know by now how much harm they'll cause. If you pass it, you are not doing your job, which is to keep kids safe. I don't ask, I expect that every board member works to make sure these changes don't pass. Thank you.

SPEAKER_11 1:41:30

Followed by Jim Gallagher, followed by Terry Marzell.

SPEAKER_31 1:41:38

Good evening board and cabinet. I'm not sure I can speak as well as the students did before me, but I'm going to share my thoughts with you tonight. My name is Kaylee couch. I'm here to speak to as a community member and a parent of this district. I am also a network technician of the Tino Valley unified school district. I have been here for 15 years. I'm also part of the LGBTQ community and my pronouns are. She and her. I'm here tonight to tell you how disappointed I am at each and every one of you. You are elected and hired to protect and serve all students, regardless of their differences that make us special. All students should have, should, should be and feel safe. What Mr. Na is doing with the agenda item to change board policy is another discriminatory play because some people don't fit into his idea or beliefs of what a human should be. Mr. Na, you are the reason I stopped working board meetings. I sat behind cameras and sound equipment listening to you and other board members tear people down for their differences or who don't follow your beliefs, do not pass this agenda either. Thank you very much for your time.

SPEAKER_11 1:43:07

Jim Gallagher, followed by Terry Marzell, followed by Marion Arguello.

SPEAKER_28 1:43:13

Good evening. Chair, board members, staff, and fellow residents, I come here tonight to tell you to vote no on this resolution. As you know, this has been in effect since 2014. AB 1266 came in. It was called the School Success and Opportunity Act. It was guaranteed to protect the rights of transgender and all students in the LGBT community. As a result, we have the administrative regulation 5145.3, as the students have mentioned. And I might add that I'm really inspired tonight by what I'm hearing. You always talk, Mr. Nau, about the students and how much you care about them. I think there's a lot of them that came tonight that are showing the courage to speak out and to address this issue directly with you. As you know, State Superintendent Tony Thurmond just sent a letter yesterday to the whole board telling you that if this passes, This is going to be a violation of the law, AB 1266, and also Section 221-5 of the California Education Code, which states a pupil shall be permitted to participate in sex-segregated school programs and activities, including athletic teams and competitions, and use facilities that are consistent with his or her gender identity, irrespective of the gender listed on the pupil's records. That's something that I don't think you should go up against. We consistently keep getting ourselves in trouble on this board where we are threatened with possible lawsuits. And again, Superintendent Thurmond offered that the state will take action if this is passed.

SPEAKER_28 1:45:01

So I encourage a no vote on this revision. Thank you.

SPEAKER_11 1:45:10

Terry Marzell, followed by Marion Arguello, followed by Connie Leyva.

SPEAKER_06 1:45:18

Dear members of the school board, I come to you today as an individual who lives within the boundaries of the Chino Valley Unified School District and as a retired educator with 36 years of classroom experience. Most importantly, I'm here as an advocate for students, except they don't really need me to advocate for them because they have spoken very eloquently for themselves this evening. I'm here because I'm deeply concerned about the language changes proposed by the revision of administrative regulation 5145.3. First, I feel certain we would all agree that we all want two things for our kids. One, we want them to be safe at school. Two, we want them to have an access to a quality educational program. Regulation 514.5.3 was originally written to address both of these priorities. The existing language protects all students, including our LGBTQ students, from unlawful discrimination. The regulation was designed to, quote, prevent unlawful discrimination, including discriminatory harassment, intimidation, retaliation, and bullying of students at district schools or in school activities, and to ensure equal access of all students to the educational program, unquote. The proposed changes would remove essential protections for an entire group of kids. Why would anyone who professes to care about kids want to remove language that protects any of them from discrimination and harassment? The proposed changes also deny equal access to LGBTQ students to a quality education. Statistical studies which support brain-based learning theory have proven that learning decreases when the student perceives threat.

SPEAKER_06 1:47:09

Removing protections for students is a definable threat. Therefore, if you remove these protections, you have not ensured equal access to all students to the educational program. Freedom from discrimination is a right that the LGBTQ community has already battled for and won at the federal state and local levels. To alter the existing language could potentially bring the district out of compliance and result in expensive lawsuits for the district. No reasonable person would risk that. I've already declared myself an advocate for students. If you, as members of the school board, are also truly advocates for students, all of the students, then you must reject these inequitable and discriminating changes. Thank you.

SPEAKER_38 1:48:05

Connie Leyva, followed by Amanda Swagger, followed by Christopher Negri.

SPEAKER_08 1:48:17

Good evening, Mr. Superintendent, President, board members. I'm Connie Leyva, proud to be your Senator representing the 20th Senate District, a proud resident of Chino who went to Newman Elementary, Ramona Junior High and graduated from Don Lugo. My daughters went to school here as well. I just, before I begin my remarks that I prepared, I just want to say thank you to these board members People who are not elected don't know how difficult it is, and they don't always play by the rules. And some of the things that have been said to you this evening, I'm just truly sorry about. I've had it said to me too. I've had people pick at my office and whatnot. It's part of being an elected official, but it shouldn't be. So thank you for having the courage to run. Thank you for being here for our kids. All right, I rise to speak against the resolution presented by you, Mr. Councilman Na. Transgender youth may be different than you are Mr. Na, but they are still entitled to respect and acceptance. Just like I'm sure you would like respect and acceptance. Acceptance is ability to see that others have a right to be their own unique persons. That means having a right to their own feelings, thoughts, and opinions. When you accept people for who they are, you let go of your desire to change them. You let them feel the way they want to feel. You let them be different.

SPEAKER_08 1:49:39

and think differently from you. Everyone is different in one way or another. Once you understand this truth, you can stop trying to change people into the people you want them to be and start accepting them for who they are. Being transgender is not a phase, it's a journey. And trying to dismiss it can be harmful during a time when a child most needs support and validation. This resolution would do nothing but harm the transgender students here in the Chino Valley Unified School District. Trying to change a child's gender identity, either by denial, punishment, reparative therapy, or any other tactic is not only ineffective, it is dangerous and can do permanent damage to a child's mental health. So-called reparative or conversion therapies which are typically faith-based, have been uniformly condemned as psychologically harmful by the American Psychological Association, American Medical Association, the American Psychiatric Association, and numerous similar professional organizations. Not only is this resolution disrespectful to our transgender students, it's against the law. So if this board passes this resolution, you've already heard from other speakers that it will violate the School Success and Opportunity Act. You will open the school district for a lawsuit. Mr. Na, you have opened the school district to many lawsuits. The school district has had to spend money that could have been spent on our children. So I would ask all of you to vote against this resolution. Thank you. Have a good evening.

SPEAKER_11 1:51:30

Amanda Swagger, followed by Christopher Negri, followed by Mike Ai.

SPEAKER_17 1:51:43

Good evening board members, Dr. Schaffer, Dr. Enfield, President Schaffer, board members. My name is Amanda Swagger, teacher at Chino High School. member of the associated chain of teachers, and a proud supporter of every student who has ever felt oppressed or otherwise felt different in their lives. I'd like to share my story here that was plastered over 14 plus newspapers over six years ago. In 2012, a law was passed that allowed intersex individuals to claim intersex status on their birth certificates. This was the spiel to take care of something that had been done 20 years ago. For those of you who know, I was born with a rare set of genetic conditions, so rare that I've been the topic of over eight research papers in the field of medicine. I was born with a condition called partial antigen insensitivity syndrome. Essentially, my body does not have the ability to process testosterone, the male hormone. In addition, I was born with a condition called Coleman syndrome, the inability to produce GNHRB, the precursor for making sex hormones, either estrogen, testosterone, or testosterone. My body was born in a way where at that time when I was born, most doctors would have just changed my external self to be female. But my parents said no. God brought this person into the world the way they are, and that's the way they're going to remain. Over many, many years, I struggled with gender identity. I'm neither technically male nor female.

SPEAKER_17 1:53:29

While I present female, I prefer a single thing swagger. The problem with being this way is when you go to school, people don't understand the way you are. In seventh grade, I was attacked in a restroom. Not wanting to be a victim, I stood up to the attacker and earned a five-day vacation at home. No one else actually touched me at that point. They were too afraid of the big giant person sitting on them in the bathroom. That said, every one of our students faces the same problems. When they go into a restroom, they face the chance of being assaulted or worse. Within the lifetime of a student, over 40% of students will be sexually assaulted in a restroom. Gender-neutral facilities, binaries, et cetera, are fine, but they don't solve the problem. By forcing a student to use a gender-neutral bathroom, you are violating the HIPAA laws. You are telling them they are transgender, intersex, et cetera, and that is illegal. Please do the right thing and vote no on this resolution. Save us a lawsuit and show that you support our students. Thank you.

SPEAKER_15 1:54:59

Good evening. My name is Chris Negri. I'm a program manager with Equality California Institute, which is a LGBTQ civil rights organization. I had remarks prepared, and all of them have been delivered more eloquently by the students. And I have to say, listening to the testimonies that have been delivered tonight, if this is the caliber of students that you are producing in this district, you should feel immensely proud of that. The eloquence and courage of folks to show up here in their teenage years, it's really wonderful to behold. What I will say though, the reason that we have laws like AB 1266, laws from anti-bullying policies to the state law that protects students' rights to use facilities that align with their gender identity is because of the significant evidence that we have that discrimination in school has repercussions for kids throughout their lives. bullying, harassment, and exclusion. These are things that impact kids in the moment, yes. But researchers have also found that those things make a difference for decades on things like whether they experience clinical depression, whether they become dependent on drugs and alcohol, their education, and employment and wages. And so, in other words, what we as adults, parents, students, teachers, sow in childhood, our kids reap later on in adulthood. This proposal then is obviously wrong-headed morally. It is also plainly illegal as it has been pointed out numerous times already. If passed, it would violate sections 220 and 221 of the California Education Code, which specifies that each student has a right to use facilities consistent

SPEAKER_15 1:56:45

with his or her gender identity irrespective of the gender listed on the pupil's records. This has been state law for eight years now, and if Chino Valley Unified violated that law, it would needless to say expose itself to significant legal risk. In any event, please vote no on this proposal. It's a distraction from the significant other problems that the district is facing, from learning loss to student social-emotional needs. It is also illegal and would expose you to legal risk. So thank you very much.

SPEAKER_22 1:57:26

The next speaker is Mike Ai, or Ai.

SPEAKER_33 1:57:35

Hello, board members. My name is Mike Ai. I'm a resident here in Chino. I'm also representing Equality California, the nation's largest statewide LGBTQ organization in the country. I'm here to testify because the proposal you're considering, which would require students to use bathrooms according to their assigned sex at birth, is not only discriminatory, it is illegal. If adopted, the rule would clearly violate state law AB 1266, which you've heard before, Education Code 221.5, which clearly specifies that each student has the right to use facilities consistent with his or her gender identity, irrespective of gender listed on their pupil's records. Furthermore, given the U.S. Supreme Court's ruling in Bostock that discrimination on the basis of gender identity is inherently discrimination on the basis of sex, it would likely violate Title IX as well. By adopting this discriminatory rule, the district may expose itself to litigation and or risk losing state or federal funding. Beyond that, the district would almost certainly face media scrutiny and community backlash without any defense that you're merely following state and or federal law because in fact you'll be in violation of the law. It would be a shame for the for chino valley unified school district to be known as a discriminatory district against kids especially at a time when parents want districts to focus on helping students make up for learning lost due to the pandemic and not attacking already marginalized students thank you gma villalobos followed by carol rao followed by damon brown

SPEAKER_48 1:59:24

Good evening, board members. It has come to my attention that a policy promoting discrimination and prohibiting of LGBTQ plus students expression. As a student, I understand that it is important to be in an environment that is accepting and can allow us to be comfortable. By accepting the proposed changes, you not only cause discomfort, but you also add to a list of obstacles that LGBTQ plus students already face, thus making these goals harder to achieve on these students. Statistics show that suicide and death rates in this community are high when students face lack of acceptance from peers and discrimination in the classroom. It is so, so important to create a safe space for all of our students. It is not only your job, but it is also our teacher's job, and it is the job of a school to keep our students safe. Even in the California labor law, it prohibits workplace discrimination and harassment. Gender identity and gender expression are included in that protection. You can easily find this stated on your labor law workplace poster. As an employee of the Chino Valley Unified School District, you would be participating in outright discrimination in the workplace. in a legal practice that would set us up for a lawsuit. We are upset with your personal ideals, wasting our schools, not only money, but also time. As I conclude, I would like to leave you with this. If you pass this policy, are you ready to be held responsible for not only financially, but legally and also mentally?

SPEAKER_48 2:00:53

Thank you.

SPEAKER_11 2:00:57

Carol Wall, followed by Damon Brown, followed by Annie Oh.

SPEAKER_35 2:01:08

Hello, everyone. My name is Carol Rao, and I'm a student from Chino Hills High School. Today, I will be reading a teacher response from the online forum. When asked, what are your thoughts about the policy and its proposed changes? They responded, I write in opposition to board member Na's proposed changes to the discrimination policy of CVUSD. Reasons for my opposition are twofold. By implementing the suggested changes, CVUSD risks creating an unsafe learning environment for all students. Despite fears expressed by some members of the community, transgender and non-binary students do not present an increased risk for sexual assault on campus. while board member Na's proposed changes focus on a hypothetical threat to students that has not been supported by any data. Trans students and other members of the LGBTQ plus community face real harassment and harm to their mental health on a regular basis. The proposed changes will only further marginalize trans and non-binary students and create a less safe learning environment for all. My second concern is on how the proposed changes will be enforced on campus if approved by the board. What will enforcement of this policy change look like? Thank you.

SPEAKER_11 2:02:46

Damon Brown, followed by Annie O, followed by Mae S.

SPEAKER_24 2:02:57

Good evening, everyone, members of the board and the cabinet. My name is Damon Brown. I am the Special Assistant Attorney General for the State of California. I'm here on behalf of Attorney General Rob Bonta. You all should have received a letter from me this afternoon expressing the Attorney General's discontent with this proposed resolution. I want to start by commending all of the students here tonight. You are as eloquent and courageous as ever. And you do have an Attorney General who stands with you on these issues. I'd like to briefly read a portion of the letter that I submitted earlier today for the benefit of those in attendance tonight. The proposed revisions to this regulation, if adopted, would appear to place the district in direct violation of state law. Moreover, the district's development and consideration of the proposal alone is of significant concern to Attorney General Bonta and the Bureau of Children's Justice in the California Department of Justice, which is actively engaged in education equity enforcement. The Attorney General has a substantial interest in ensuring California schools are free from discrimination and harassment on the basis of protected characteristics, including gender identity, and will take such action as necessary to vigorously protect these rights, including but not limited to the initiation of litigation to protect students from gender identity discrimination.

SPEAKER_11 2:04:30

Annie O followed by Mae S followed by Jennifer Flores. Annie O. I don't think there's anyone else. There are no other students. Oh, Jennifer Flores, excuse me.

SPEAKER_38 2:04:56

Jennifer Flores.

SPEAKER_40 2:05:03

Hello, board members. I am Jennifer Flores, a student at Chino Hills High School. I am volunteering to read a student response from the online forum. When asked, what are your thoughts about the policy and its proposed changes, they responded, I honestly think that this policy being changed is irresponsible, ridiculous, and inhumane. People should not be forced to be recognized as someone they are not. Gender is a social construct, and students should not be forced to identify with their sex assigned at birth. When asked, how will this proposed policy change your experience on campus? How do you feel about this? They responded, I feel awful about this. My own experience will not be affected, but I have many friends who will be. To me, my friends are who they say they are, who they identify, and who they feel comfortable as. If I had to watch my friend, who is a guy, be forced into a women's restroom because of the gender assigned to him at birth, I would feel awful. I would never want him or anyone else to have to be put through that. My other friend is gender nonconforming. I have to watch them be misgendered as a girl far too often. I feel awful that they have to experience this sort of oppression every day. This policy would affect them in every way, every single day. It wouldn't just be one or two people who wouldn't accept them. It would be the whole school district.

SPEAKER_40 2:06:14

that they would be the whole school district that chose not to accept them, that doesn't let them simply be them. When asked, how do you feel this proposed policy will affect others around you? They responded, others around me will be scrutinized for their identity and outed. My friend who is a guy passes very well. If I wasn't told, I would have never known. If he was forced to use the girls' restrooms, be opposed as a girl in the yearbook, or have everyone find out that he was trans, he would be in serious danger. This is a serious issue. Not every person is accepting of transgender or gender non-conforming people. Members of this community are killed or simply assaulted because they are transgender or gender non-conforming. They should be able to keep their identity and their peace if they please. When asked, is there anything else you want us to know, they responded, I find this policy dehumanizing and irresponsible and I think it should not be changed. Thank you.

SPEAKER_11 2:07:08

Annie O followed by the final speaker, Mae S. Annie O. Mae S. Neither.

SPEAKER_38 2:07:40

Is that it? That's it.

SPEAKER_34 2:07:48

First of all, I'd like to thank everyone that came out and spoke on this issue, especially all of our students. It doesn't just take courage, but it takes confidence to get up here and speak, share your story, or share the stories of others. So thank you very much for doing that this evening. We're gonna go ahead now, and may I have a motion?

SPEAKER_47 2:08:12

Motion.

SPEAKER_29 2:08:14

I have a second.

SPEAKER_12 2:08:15

Second.

SPEAKER_29 2:08:17

motion by mr cruz second by mr knopf open it up for comments questions and discussion i do not know who was on first esther go ahead please

SPEAKER_10 2:08:38

Thank you.

SPEAKER_58 2:08:38

So first of all, I just want to say I am so sorry that you have to speak up for such a fundamental human right that you deserve. This should have never been on the table. But I'm also so amazed by each and every one of you who showed up and who spoke and who also supported us from by sending in a remote testimony. You guys, the energy in the room today was amazing. There was so much passion and eloquence in all of your voices. And I just want to thank you all for having the courage to just show up at this board meeting in a place where you might have been faced by adversity and just confidently projecting yourself out to your audience. I also want to address that there were some students who were not able to speak today due to time constraints or just disruptive behavior happening outside in this board meeting. And I want to recognize their presence and their voice that has not been heard today. truly deserves to be recognized, so thank you all. I personally, even as someone without a degree in law or education, I can see that this should never have been on the table. Like I said before, there was quite a few legal precedents. I mean, I could just so plainly see that we are setting ourselves up for a lawsuit. This is fiscally irresponsible and most foundationally a violation of human rights. I don't think that this is a question of this passing or not passing because this should not and will not be passed.

SPEAKER_58 2:10:24

So I want to carry this energy to propose another revision to this policy. I've noticed that in our discrimination policy, although we address freedom of gender expression and gender identity, the pronouns we use in the policy are she or he, she. Why can't we use they, them pronouns, which are more inclusive of all of our genders that we're trying to protect? So I would request that to be, if I may, be placed as an agenda item on the next board meeting. Thank you.

SPEAKER_29 2:11:08

We'll start with Mr. Bridge, Mr. Na, and Mrs. Gagnon.

SPEAKER_04 2:11:21

I'll be brief, because the students that spoke tonight were just eloquent, and there's no way that I, as a longtime educator, could come close to topping that.

SPEAKER_22 2:11:33

When I saw this policy, the first thing I thought of was it was a clear violation of AB 1266. So those of us sitting up here, are you, for all the students, all, capital, A-L-L, or just some of the students in this district, I was a longtime teacher in this district. I cared about all of my classes, all of my students. I cared about all the high schools, the junior highs, and the elementary students in this district because that's what we as teachers and employees of this district do. I will not let you throw any students under the proverbial bus, school or otherwise, and I will not allow this district to have to defend potential and very costly lawsuit. Therefore, I will not be in support of this change in our administrative regulation 5145.3. That concludes my comment.

SPEAKER_12 2:12:34

First place, I'd really like to thank people who spoke tonight on this issue, especially the students. I could agree with you everything what you have said. I have gone through all that in my life. as you look at me, who I was when I have arrived here in this country. So I understand it. And your passion for fighting for underdogs. And that's how I am and I was. But here's the thing. Here's the thing. Let me tell you why this revision was brought about. Yes, it was about a high school student

SPEAKER_52 2:13:21

not from our district, who had assaulted, sexually assaulted a high school girl in a high school facility. It happened to be a bathroom, but it could have been a locker room. And the district had placed that student to another school because of the school policies that they had, like ours. So again, that student, not you guys, because I know were good kids. You guys are really great kids. I have no fear that one of you guys that had spoken here would ever commit crime like that. I have great confidence. It's not about you guys. So after the student was moved to another school, he did it again. So the district went chaotic. The father came in crying at the board meeting. And then guess what? He was arrested. It was good unless it was your own dad. It was good if you haven't been sexually assaulted or raped. It's good. But it happened. The MADD, M-A-D-D, Mothers Against Drunk Drivers, started with one person being hurt in an auto accident because of a drunk driver. Yes, I have never been drinking and driving. Matter of fact, I don't even drink, okay? It's not about me, me, me. But something, it really happens to somebody. What about the other flip side of coin? When you grow up and have children, And then you allow a boy, yes, there's no ID for transgender students. Unfortunately, there is not. Self-identifying person going to a shower or a locker room, how would you feel as a parent?

SPEAKER_52 2:15:18

Yes, students could take care of themselves. That's what they said at the school dances. The parents assumed the school dances are safe, not only in our district, but throughout the district. But one year when I went there, because I got a phone call from a mother crying at 11 p.m. that there was a big problem with the dance at one high school. And the mother was... just broken down and I couldn't talk to her much. But I assured her I'll be there for her daughter on following year. I don't know who the daughter was, but then we had adults watching the dance. So instead of grinding, the kids could have opportunity to have a safe dance like normal students. Now.

SPEAKER_21 2:16:17

Now, here.

SPEAKER_34 2:16:19

Please, this is the board's time. Please continue, Mr. Nunn.

SPEAKER_52 2:16:23

When you go to school, you learn to listen until you become a teacher in the classroom. When this thing happened in news media, the parents and grandparents got hold of me, really worried. What is going on with our school district? I said, I don't know, probably similar policies. They wanted to see what could be done to make campus safe. It's not about hurting one student, the good students like you guys, but what about the rest of the population, other good students? And since there's no ID, just self-identifying. So if I had some crazy friends in my high school years who wanted to sneak into girls' rooms or watch them, okay, what about those kids? So that's what they have in their mindset, like me and other parents. So the resolution, I mean, the industry change tells you that the kids would still be offered gender-neutral private facilities. It's not only the restroom, but it's the locker room and things like that. So it takes lots of work.

SPEAKER_21 2:17:55

But here's the deal. When you go watch a movie, and if you're under 18, and if it's rated R, you're not able to buy the ticket. That's still a rule. Okay? Because if you have brothers and sisters, or even your parents, and it really happened. Matter of fact, less than six months ago, one man jumped into a family woman's spa on purpose, whether the guy was crazy, but he was on purpose and there was a big riot. Yes, those are the criminals. Our kids are nice. I wanted to protect all of you guys plus the rest of the population. The girls who could be traumatized looking at men in a nudity where you could only see it in rated R. So whether you understand or not right now, As life goes on, you will see it more. But I really appreciate you, because I feel that you guys really care, not only for yourself, but others, people with smaller voices. So I'd like to find the answers. One student talked about having a private gender-neutral bathroom and facilities. That's one good idea. but to protect our students and others. But moreover, one high school student boy had shared with me, he said, he will beat up any boy entering into his girlfriend's locker room at school or even at after school. This was his real feeling. And then you cannot blame, The student, that's how they feel. If you had a mom and was intervened by a man, and having no ID, or he says he's transgender, you're not going to be comfortable.

SPEAKER_21 2:20:14

You're not going to be happy. So this is common sense things. And that's why this resolution has come about. It's not about against anybody. It's finding, trying to find a solution to it. That's all. That's all.

SPEAKER_52 2:20:33

Now, let me talk about the state people coming down and say this and that. And you know what? I don't have too much respect for the state people as I do for you guys. folks look at the homeless problems look at the homeless problems you go to la my friend said last week he had seen four dead people on street okay and that's your state policy working matter of fact they had such a all the rights they were camping canting and everywhere and I think LA City banned them in one street or something, another.

SPEAKER_21 2:21:19

But the root of the problem was, it's their behavioral problem, the mental, the addiction, they're not fixing it. They're moving around the box and the hurt is still there and growing.

SPEAKER_52 2:21:35

That's why I don't have so much respect for the state people Look at criminals. You know what they told me, our law enforcement people? If you commit a crime, the best thing you do today is say, plead guilty.

SPEAKER_21 2:21:55

And then judge would say, okay, you got six months in prison. Oops, our prison is full, and by the state mandate, we have to release you.

SPEAKER_52 2:22:05

So that person goes out and do more crime. and then goes back. That's why we have crime issues. In Oakland, in a stop sign, if you get old enough to drive, be careful on a stop sign. That's when you get robbed. This is what states are doing. And what else they're doing?

SPEAKER_21 2:22:31

They're passing laws that has nothing to do with our education, but They're receiving our tax money. I'm just telling you. And as you grow, you'll know more. But again, I'd just like to thank you. There's no other, for me, there was no other common sense solution to prevent this problem. until we could find something mutually and protect all the students, especially the girl population on campus. This is the resolution I have placed. It's not about one people with another people. It's not that. Find sexual assault, not harassment. Man, please. The training. Yes, about drugs and sexual assaults and drinking. We have that in place. But problems, it's right now. What could we do? Meantime, this takes in place and it's working. One state in Florida, superintendent had taken out doors in the bathrooms. The reason was superintendent wasn't able to prevent drug trade, drug use in bathrooms. So people went wild. But there are lots of situations without no clear answers. So it is our duty to come up with some solution that's workable. and you guys are start. Whatever these old people have done to brought up more chaotic, they're not causing the love, bring the love, compassion, they're causing more divisions. So when you look at back when this country was more with pride, and you look at today, it is your job. to see what was great in the past, what was lacking, and make it better. Okay? And I would say what I feel from the bottom of my heart, it's nothing, it's not about making issues.

SPEAKER_21 2:25:21

I'm just trying to come up with the solutions. And this was the only solution that our parents and people that I spoke to came up with. That's all. Thank you.

SPEAKER_34 2:25:34

Mrs. Gagne, please.

SPEAKER_00 2:25:38

You are heard, you are seen, and you're going to be responded to. And don't you ever let anybody on this dais lecture you about who you are. That is absolutely fundamentally wrong. This resolution is supposed to tackle sexual assaults in this school district or this solution would tackle it anywhere else. That is fundamentally one of the most misguided things I have ever heard on this dais. If you want to prevent sexual assault, provide training, provide supports. Do not discriminate against transgender students on our campuses. There are a variety of things that this district could do to support students. and make sure that students are safe on campus. This does not accomplish that. And talking about being divisive, this is divisive. All that is happening now in this country on school boards is divisive topics are being brought up just to tear us apart. The reason that we are here is to support students. We are here to protect all of our students. We've been having conversations for 20 months about how we protect students and keep them safe in school. And now we have a resolution before us that is attacking one group of students on our campuses and saying, you don't get to be safe. That is fundamentally wrong. It is an absence and a moral failing, and this district cannot stand for it. Those state people, the people that have come in today from the state are lawyers. They are consumer protection lawyers.

SPEAKER_00 2:27:04

The whole goal of the Attorney General's Office of the State of California is to protect people. That's why the State Attorney General's Office is here today. If you don't want to listen to partisan elected officials, that's fine. But this is plainly against the law. So aside from being immoral, it is also illegal. It is our responsibility as a board, whether on this resolution or any other, to protect our students, to protect each and every one of our students, to protect all of our students. If there is truly a concern about sexual assault, if there's truly a concern about verbal abuse or other types of abuse on our campuses, then we need to sit back and potentially start a working group or some other initiative to figure out what's actually happening on our campuses and come up with solutions that meet what's actually happening. You just mentioned somebody, a student, that had told you about if someone had gone into their bathroom that they would assault them. I mean, we're promoting somebody saying that. We're promoting a student saying that that would be their response to a transgender student coming into a restroom. All students' opinions are valid, but that is an opinion that basically is propagating assault. And that's what we're trying to avoid with this resolution. I mean, this just is boggling my mind. this resolution is wrong this resolution is divisive and it truly hurts the individuals that we're trying to protect in the school district our children uh you know james i really respectfully have to ask you to withdraw this resolution thank you well i i just have to tell you something um

SPEAKER_21 2:28:48

I have not said transgender student who enter his girlfriend's locker room.

SPEAKER_12 2:28:55

I said a boy, okay? So let me make it that clear.

SPEAKER_52 2:28:59

And number two, if we want to become a calculus professor, I think we all could become a calculus professor. Do I like calculus? I don't. But this is what's been done today. You have questions, and all your job as a professor is mark it wrong, wrong, wrong. And we have no answers to it. I don't have to explain what is the right step, what is the right answer. That's what's been happening. That's why there are people who are not happy what is going on with today's education. You can stop anybody on the street. Why California is last, what, 49th in the state education-wise? Ask people why. People are saying no, no, no, but no solutions. Thank you.

SPEAKER_29 2:30:07

This is Gagne, and then we'll get to you, Esther.

SPEAKER_00 2:30:09

I'm all Esther Gagne.

SPEAKER_29 2:30:10

Okay, Esther, please.

SPEAKER_08 2:30:10

I was going to say, I want you to say something.

SPEAKER_00 2:30:18

You know, I'm not often a loss for words, but I truly don't know why we are foisting the problems of society and the state on our transgender students. That's exactly what I'm hearing here today. I don't think that that is appropriate. I don't think it's kind, and I don't think it's supportive of our students. We have been hearing the phrase positive school climate for Months in response to different things that have been happening before our board and throughout our school district I don't think this supports positive school climate and again, you know, I respectfully request Mr. Dog will you withdraw this resolution?

SPEAKER_34 2:31:05

Pastor please

SPEAKER_58 2:31:11

I don't think I have to explain why the reasoning behind this resolution is completely immoral and complete nonsense. I mean, you already know that. But I just want to address all of you. When you're talking about flip sides and when you're talking about human rights, please consider Please consider all sides of the issue when you're talking about deaths on streets, when you're talking about assault cases, why aren't we talking about transgender suicide rates? Why aren't we talking about the discrimination that this community faces on a daily basis? So please take that into consideration when you are reasoning with us. I also want to take this chance to really speak on how effective our state education department has been. The state education department recently passed a bill that would allow menstrual products, that would require menstrual products to be conveniently placed in school bathrooms. And they have also very recently formed a Black Student Achievement Task Force to promote equity across the state. And I would just like all of you guys to know how much our state works for our diverse population of students and that we can definitely put trust in a state to have our best interests at their core of their policies. And I will move on to my presentation. I'm a little bit unfamiliar with the technology here. So I'm just going to present a very special series of testimonies. I'm presenting this on behalf of a group of incredible student leaders from throughout CBUSD, Jasmine Rivera from Chino Hills High, Max Ibarra from Ayala High, Camila Aguadizales from Don Lugo High, and Chloe Wong from Ayala High.

SPEAKER_58 2:33:36

Sorry, could we turn this on?

UNKNOWN 2:34:02

I have something down. It was. It's on. Just the keyboard. Can you just flip to it?

SPEAKER_06 2:34:32

Yeah, but I'll have to do it from up there, so I'll listen.

SPEAKER_17 2:34:35

Yeah, just flip.

UNKNOWN 2:34:50

I'll start when you flip the slides.

SPEAKER_34 2:35:19

Thanks for hanging in there with us, folks. We're going to try to get this to work. If not, Esther, maybe we could...

SPEAKER_58 2:35:27

I can just present it verbally. It doesn't work.

UNKNOWN 2:35:34

Let's give them a second to try to get it to work. Put some time and effort into it, and we'd like to see it. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, folks, looks like we have the slides up.

SPEAKER_58 2:36:30

All right, thank you so much. So moving on, the purpose of these testimonials, the following testimonials stand for the CVUSD community's opinions on the proposed revision to the CVUSD policy, administrative regulation 5145.3, students, non-discrimination, harassment of students. This also stands for raising awareness of transgender and non-binary experiences within CVUSD and empowering voices of the LGBTQ community. And lastly, this stands for inspiring conversation on discrimination and student rights across the district, not just in this boardroom, but after this meeting as well. So this is our timeline for the planning process. On November 14th, we had a first meeting between myself and the student leaders that helped plan this. From the 15th to 18th, we circulated informational content and a testimony form through social media and personal outreach methods such as email. And from the 17th to the 18th, we organized 140 plus testimonies into public comment cards and presentations, some of which you heard presented today. Next slide, thank you. This is the form we use to gather our testimonies. So just to go over the questions we asked, we first requested our constituents to identify their role and we asked them to express their opinions on policy change with a variety of questions. And lastly, we asked a question regarding confidentiality. Next slide, please. In total, we had 141 testimonials from students, teachers, parents, alumni, outside students, family, and friends. And we narrowed, we generalized all of our comments to five core causes that I will be presenting in a little bit.

SPEAKER_58 2:38:25

But first, I want to go over some terminology that we must know before we move on. The first one is transgender, or trans, means identifying as a different gender than the gender assigned at birth. cisgender, or cis in short, identifying as the gender you were assigned at birth, gender nonconforming, someone who doesn't conform to stereotypical views of gender, and lastly nonbinary, not identifying as strictly male or female, which can be both or neither, and all of these are adjectives. Next slide. So our first cause was endangerment of marginalized communities. And I will read out some of our testimonies. I feel as if I and others like me will be put at risk of harassment, hate crimes, and terrible breaks in mental health. I'm very much frightened at the idea of this passing as I will be in danger and my friends will be in danger. It will lead to greater issues on campus for gender diverse students, including greater risk of sexual assault and suicide. Our second cause was absence of proper reasoning. Regarding the addition made to our policy, gender is a social construct and therefore it is wrong to say biological gender. This would make no sense as a policy. Transphobic rules are not needed and what is needed is accountability and repercussions for the sexual harassment that appears widely on campuses and is often overlooked. The proposed changes to the policy are backwards. A district should always strive to make their students feel safest at school, and this policy will do just the opposite.

SPEAKER_58 2:39:57

And the case that this is based on had no correlation to transgender youth, and this resolution seems like it is using the case as an excuse to put transgender students under blame when they are not to blame. Next slide, please. And lastly, there is simply no way to verify one's gender without severely violating personal boundaries, as well as previous sections of the same policy. Aren't these extremely drastic measures for a process that is ultimately useless in the issue that aims to address? Next slide, please. Our third cause was unwarranted targeting of marginalized communities. In what way is gender identity related to sexual harassment and assault? Everyone is fully aware that cisgender people of the same sex are capable of assaulting each other as well. We should hold the students accountable for their behavior and not their gender identity. Also, trans women are much, much, much more likely to experience sexual harassment while using the bathroom, so this resolution does not protect their rights. I urge you, rather than relying on transgender discrimination policy changes, enforce more regulations centering on sexual harassment within campuses as a whole. We must create a culture that allows for diversity and allows for student safety while not targeting particular student groups. Next slide, please. Cause number four, negative impacts on campus culture and general student well-being. One of our constituents stated that, as a cisgender female student, I won't feel comfortable knowing that a transgender male will have to use the girls' bathroom and vice versa.

SPEAKER_58 2:41:39

Acceptance and exposure is vital to creating harmonious conditions within educational institutions. And we as a community have been becoming more and more open to newness and equality. However, this policy will completely backtrack and erase this progress. Lastly, this is going to send an awful message, not just to this community, but also the allied students as well. And it's going to raise a concern or a panic or fear that the school does not allow for diversity or self-expression, and it will raise the question of what will be taken next. I understand that this district has a history of getting in legal trouble for pushing religious agendas to our students, and I think this will further that fear as well, in addition to personal rights and expression. Cause number five, deterioration of district-constituent relationships. A district should always strive to make its students feel their safest at school, and this will do just the opposite again. It is important that staff and teachers, not just their board members, make sure their students are safe and happy and comfortable in going to school. It's really disheartening to hear people of such high status and power who are supposed to protect the livelihoods and safety of the students. to really even think to pass such a discriminatory and intensely harmful change. We represent all of these students, not just certain populations. And for us to be effective representatives, we have to create change that benefits everyone and does not particularly harm one population.

SPEAKER_58 2:43:11

So our request through all these 140 plus testimonies is, the transgender and non-binary community, and allies of CVUSD are requesting that the district prioritize student rights and encourage diversity through increased stakeholder engagement, education, and training of district personnel and constituents, and just decision-making. School boards should be a platform for conversation and collaboration, not for pursuing religious, political, or personal motives. And that will be my presentation. Thank you all for listening.

SPEAKER_34 2:43:59

I'm going to make a couple of comments real quick. Pat, just for the record, all board members received a letter dated yesterday from State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Thurmond.

SPEAKER_29 2:44:11

And dated today, a letter from the State of California Department of Justice Attorney General's Office from Damon Brown on behalf of Rob Bonta, the Attorney General. I provided you with a copy. I'd like to make sure that both of those are included in the record and are attached with the minutes. Okay, seeing no other lights on here, I will make just a few quick comments. Mr. Cruz.

SPEAKER_34 2:44:40

Nobody's light was on, so. Okay, Mr. Na.

SPEAKER_12 2:44:49

I just have to tell the facts. Any parents who has children in our school district that I've spoken to, do not want their daughter to be exposed to a boy in the locker room setting.

SPEAKER_52 2:45:11

And that's plain, easy, common sense. That is what parents are talking about. They do not want their daughters to be exposed to a boy in their locker room settings. and and they have all the rights talk about that because the children belong to them as you belong to your parents thank you mr cruz did you have your light on yes speak you know it's it's really tough your generation

SPEAKER_01 2:45:58

is a tough generation. And honestly, I would not make it in your generation. And I'm a little bit grateful. But there's an agenda going on, and it's a wicked system. But when we get out of this, you will be the greatest generation. I apologize that we did not have the courage to stop this. this gender fluidity, the CRT, the sexualization of our kids that have confused so many. Now, I fully understand that there's always exceptions, but this is getting so overwhelming and it's so sad that we're losing so many kids. You know, my concern is we just didn't have brave adults looking after our kids And that is the consequence that we are lying right now. But you know, I want kids to be safe and I don't want them to regret of the decisions they made when they were kids. And then when they look back in their adulthood, where were the adults giving them advice and so forth and all this media that's just twisting the kid's mind so bad. It is so awful. I would not be able to survive. You know, I don't wanna harp on my lifestyle. I really don't, but I'll just, you know, I'm just gonna say things. You know, I grew up with women. And if I went through the things that you guys went through, I would've became something that I wasn't supposed to. But see, I was left alone to discover my own identity. You know, just discover who I am.

SPEAKER_01 2:47:39

But these times are so, they're so awful. And deep down inside, a lot of you, There's some truth behind what I'm saying. You cannot deny that fact. That honestly, this is a Marxist system that is very Bolshevistic and has a history of repeating itself. Because we've seen this. We've seen this. You could laugh. You could laugh. But out of this, we will be the greatest generation. So safety is my concern. I want to make an amendment to include the following under number four, because I have courage, because it takes courage from this evil system that they're propagating evil stuff with our children. Because you know, someday when they grow up and when they're adults and they look back, they're going to say, where were they? Where were these people? I want to make an amendment to include the following under number four. It's concern about safety, the safety of regret, A student must have psychological counseling for a minimum of six months to ensure the student actually identifies him or herself as the opposite gender. Number two, this is what a brave person does. You can laugh as much as you like. But I want to be safe because some people are bringing up issues about mental illness, mental disorder. The system is causing mental disorder. Please, let's not, please.

SPEAKER_58 2:49:13

Please don't bring hate speech into this room.

SPEAKER_01 2:49:17

A letter of approval from a doctor showing the student is being provided with hormonal therapy. These are the amendments I want to include, and let me tell you why. They provide safety for the student who identifies as an opposite gender, and safety for those students who identify with their biological gender. You know? And that's how I feel. Hey, you know something? I'll stop. Let me give you this. I have deep respect for this.

SPEAKER_29 2:49:55

Mr. Cruz, you were making an amendment to your original motion then? Yeah, I'm going to amend this. Mr. Nau, do you agree since you were the one seconding it?

SPEAKER_31 2:50:03

No.

SPEAKER_29 2:50:06

So Pat, we will have that as an amended motion. That is now on the floor. Are there any comments on the amended motion? Mrs. Gagne.

SPEAKER_00 2:50:19

That is unconscionable. That is unconscionable and that is unconscionable. I don't know how right now this has turned into attacking students who showed up in this room that are representing a larger part of our student community. What I find interesting this evening is usually on issues we get a spectrum of opinions. or feedback from the community. I have received emails and I'm sure these will get public request acted so I apologize if that happens to the individuals that sent them to me. But we usually get a spectrum of responses. As you have noticed, our meetings can be a little lively at times, but people come in with different perspectives. I have not heard one speaker this evening in support of this resolution. I did not receive one email from a parent in support of this resolution. I am not going to pause it as to the genesis of this resolution and maybe a subset of this community that is not in support of transgender students. But I have no idea why, when it's already been very clearly articulated that this is illegal, we have our most important constituents ever, our students in here, saying that this is wrong and immoral, why we would lean in even further to alienate the students we are here to protect and support. I just, it's unconscionable. And I apologize to our students.

SPEAKER_12 2:51:55

Again, I'm going to say one more thing. This is not about the transgender students against other students.

SPEAKER_52 2:52:02

It's about all the students. And we need to come up with some solution. And meantime, right now, there's no absolute solution from the state or federal government to protect all the students. Now, as again, the parents who has their children, especially girls, they do not want their girls in a locker room with boys. That's plain truth in a compromising situation. If you have sisters, you have mothers or aunts, the answer will be the same thing from your heart. That is the only reason, thank you.

SPEAKER_29 2:52:48

Okay, seeing no other lights for comments on the amended motion, we'll take that motion up first, correct Pat?

SPEAKER_38 2:52:54

Correct.

SPEAKER_29 2:52:55

We will do a roll call vote on the amended motion. Mr. Cruz? Yes. Mr. Bridge?

SPEAKER_22 2:53:02

No.

SPEAKER_29 2:53:03

Mrs. Gagne?

SPEAKER_00 2:53:04

No.

SPEAKER_29 2:53:05

Mr. Na?

SPEAKER_12 2:53:06

Aye.

SPEAKER_29 2:53:07

And I'm a no. Preferential?

SPEAKER_58 2:53:10

No.

SPEAKER_29 2:53:11

Amended motion fails two to three with preferential voting no.

UNKNOWN 2:53:22

Please vote.

SPEAKER_29 2:53:23

We will now go back to the original motion. Which was made by Mr. Cruz and seconded by Mr. Na. I see no abides. We will take a roll call vote on the original motion. Mr. Na, did you want to speak? No. OK. We will move on now to a vote on the original motion. Mr. Cruz? Yes. Mr. Bridge?

SPEAKER_04 2:53:49

Resounding no.

SPEAKER_00 2:53:53

Resounding no.

SPEAKER_29 2:53:55

Mr. Na.

SPEAKER_52 2:53:56

Aye.

SPEAKER_29 2:53:57

And I'm a no. Referential?

SPEAKER_58 2:54:01

Absolutely not. And I also say no to having board members on the diets who openly attack their students. OK.

SPEAKER_29 2:54:07

Thank you.

SPEAKER_58 2:54:07

The motion failed.

SPEAKER_34 2:54:17

Pat, for the record, motion failed two to three with a no vote from preferential. Okay, thank you, everyone. We're going to move on now to Item 2C1, a public hearing. I'll give you guys a couple minutes to head out.

UNKNOWN 2:54:44

Thank you all. You're all balanced. Have a great night. Thank you for coming.

SPEAKER_34 2:55:33

Okay, thank you, now moving on.

SPEAKER_29 2:55:49

okay moving on to item 2c1 public notice and hearing regarding the district's initial bargaining proposal to the associated chino teachers for a success successor collective bargaining agreement effective july 1st 2022 recommend the board of education give public notice and conduct a public hearing regarding the district's initial bargaining proposal to the associated chino teachers for a successor collective bargaining agreement effective july 1 20 22. Open the public hearing at 8.55. Are there any requests to speak, Pat?

SPEAKER_38 2:56:19

None.

SPEAKER_34 2:56:21

Close the hearing at 8.56.

SPEAKER_29 2:56:32

Moving on to item 2C2, public notice and hearing regarding the California School Employees Association and its Chino Chapter 102 initial bargaining proposal to the Chino Valley Unified School District for a reopen or collect the bargaining agreement effective July 1, 2021. recommend the board of education give public notice and conduct a public hearing regarding the complement school employees association and its chino chapter 102 initial bargaining proposal to the chino valley unified school district for a reopener collective bargaining agreement effective july 1 2022. Moving on now to item 2C3. Compensation increase for substitute services provided for certificated employees. Recommend the Board of Education approve a compensation increase for substitute services provided for certificated employees.

SPEAKER_34 2:57:37

Are there any requests to speak?

SPEAKER_38 2:57:40

None.

SPEAKER_17 2:57:40

President Schaffer. If there would be no objection to the board, I would like a minute of your time. I know I used my three minutes earlier.

SPEAKER_34 2:57:49

This is a different item. You're free to speak. You have three minutes.

SPEAKER_17 2:57:52

Thank you, sir.

SPEAKER_11 2:57:55

It's three minutes for non-agenda and three minutes for agenda. So if they want to use the three minutes on three different agenda items, they only get three minutes, not three minutes for each different. That's 93-23. 93.

SPEAKER_34 2:58:10

Okay, you spoke for three minutes earlier, correct?

SPEAKER_11 2:58:14

On an agenda item, so she doesn't get another three on something else. She should have used that.

SPEAKER_34 2:58:19

My apologies.

SPEAKER_17 2:58:20

No, we're perfectly fine, thank you.

SPEAKER_29 2:58:26

May I have a motion?

SPEAKER_12 2:58:27

So moved.

SPEAKER_00 2:58:28

Second.

SPEAKER_29 2:58:30

Motion by Mr. Na, second by Mrs. Gagne. Are there any comments, questions, Mrs. Gagne?

SPEAKER_00 2:58:38

Yes, first and foremost, I'm glad to see this on the agenda. I have heard from many of our teachers and parents about this issue. I know that this is something that the district deals with. but it's also something specifically we're dealing with right now. And so I do want to make sure that this is not the last thing that we do to address this problem. I know that, and I know individuals that are in this room have come to speak about this issue before, you know, there's other things that I know we can do. And so I would encourage everyone to continue to communicate with us if there's other solutions that you think will also alleviate this problem, you know, please communicate those. Thank you.

SPEAKER_29 2:59:17

Any other comments or questions from the board? Seeing none.

SPEAKER_12 2:59:21

My button is not working.

SPEAKER_34 2:59:23

Okay. Mr. Knopf, please. Okay.

SPEAKER_12 2:59:26

I'd just like to thank our Chino teacher who had come and spoke to us two meetings ago for your proposal. So thank you so much for bringing the solution to us. And I'm sure the rest of the teachers would appreciate it because hopefully we would have more substitute teachers signing up. Thank you.

SPEAKER_29 2:59:51

And again, my apologies for the confusion. Seeing no other lights, all in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposition? Preferential? Aye. Motion passes 5-0 with preferential voting yes. Moving on now down to consent items. Have any requests speak on consent items?

SPEAKER_38 3:00:14

None.

SPEAKER_29 3:00:16

Board members, any polls? Mr. Cruz?

SPEAKER_47 3:00:18

No polls.

SPEAKER_29 3:00:20

Bridge.

SPEAKER_04 3:00:21

No pulls.

SPEAKER_29 3:00:22

Mr. Na. No pulls. Mrs. Gagne.

SPEAKER_27 3:00:26

No pulls.

SPEAKER_29 3:00:27

I have no pulls. May I have a motion?

SPEAKER_52 3:00:29

So moved. Second.

SPEAKER_29 3:00:33

All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposition? Preferential?

SPEAKER_58 3:00:38

Aye.

SPEAKER_29 3:00:40

The motion passes 5-0 with a motion by Mr. Na and a second by Mrs. Gagne. Moving on now to section... through questions or comments from the board on information items. Seeing none, we'll move down to section five, discussion items. First up is item 5A1, Curriculum, Instruction, Innovation, and Support. Recommend the Board of Education discuss the 2022-2023 school start times. Board member, before we begin our discussion, I believe Mrs. Fell is your Dr. Parker. I'm sorry, Dr. Parker, right in front of me, has some background and maybe a quick presentation.

SPEAKER_03 3:01:31

President Schaffer, members of the board, and Superintendent Enfield. On this agenda this evening, we have a discussion item related to Senate Bill 328. With this passage, we will need to prepare to make some adjustments to our school's bell schedules for next year. Senate Bill 328 was passed into law in October 2019 in response to research that supports that teens benefit from a later school time. Under this new law, by July of 2022, junior highs can begin no earlier than 8 a.m. and high schools cannot begin any earlier than 8.30 a.m. While the bill does not mention anything about elementary schools, due to transportation needs across the districts, there will be adjustments that will need to be made to our elementary bell schedules. To develop viable schedule options, we will be forming a Senate Bill 328 task force that will be made up of parent representatives who have a student currently enrolled in one of our schools and selected by each board member, principal representatives, and ACT and CSEA representatives. To accommodate for staffing and transportation needs, the district will be using the following design principles to develop new start time options for our schools. First bell schedules will need to adhere to the state requirements for instructional minutes. And in order to accommodate for transportation services across the district, we will need to balance the number of schools with different start times and ensure there is a minimum of a 45 minute gap between the staggered start and end times while still ensuring that there is much standardization in start times across the school district.

SPEAKER_03 3:03:46

Let's take a look at our bell schedule from 2021 before the additional 30 minutes was added to the instructional school day. The times reflected on the schedule do not align to the new state law, which again requires for junior high school to begin no earlier than 8 and for high schools to begin no earlier than 8.30. operationally to be able to deliver services across the school district, half of our elementary routes will also need to pick up a secondary route in the morning and also at the end of the day. And again, this is only possible if there is a minimum of a 45 minute time gap between the start and end times for elementary and secondary schools. So in looking at this example, highlighted in yellow is the bus route that drops off at the high school before the 7.30 start time, and then separately picks up and drops off our students at an elementary school that has an 8.15 start time. Another example highlighted in green is another bus route that drops off at the junior high school that has a 7.45 start time, which then separately picks up our elementary school students at a school with an 8.40 start time. Using the requirements of this new state law and the criteria needed in order to provide transportation services, the task force will be developing viable options for the community for feedback. The task force will be meeting up to three times to develop, again, viable start options for community input.

SPEAKER_03 3:05:36

A survey of those options will be presented to our educational partners. And then in February, the results from the survey will be presented to the Board of Education for action. And thereafter, we will continue to communicate all changes to the bell schedules to our community. And this concludes my presentation to the board. Does anyone have any questions?

SPEAKER_29 3:05:57

Thank you very much. Anybody have any questions? Mrs. Gagne?

SPEAKER_00 3:06:02

I don't have a question, but I have a comment. I just want to highlight that each board member has the opportunity to appoint someone to this task force. And so I would just encourage anyone interested to please reach out to me.

SPEAKER_29 3:06:16

Anybody else have questions or comments? OK. Thank you very much, Dr. Park. Next discussion item is Item 82, Educator Effectiveness Block. I recommend the Board of Education discuss the Educator Effectiveness Block. Dr. Enfield, would you like to provide any background information? Okay. Are there any comments or questions from the Board on Item 582? Seeing none, we'll move on now. Before we do final communications,

SPEAKER_34 3:06:55

Donnie, is there anybody left over from non-agenda items that would like to speak now? Okay, we'll go ahead and start calling those cards again, Pat, please.

SPEAKER_11 3:07:05

In the order that they were received? Yes, ma'am, please. Julie Vandell?

SPEAKER_38 3:07:13

Tanya Macias?

SPEAKER_11 3:07:31

Tanya Macias, Nicole Vacario, Karen Kuen, Valerie Walsh.

SPEAKER_49 3:07:46

Valerie Walsh.

SPEAKER_02 3:07:52

I don't have anything prepared because I was part of the larger group. However, I do have something to say. I have worked in this district for 30 years. I've worked at Oak Ridge Elementary my entire career at this district. I have taught over 900 students. I have taught children of students I taught being at the same school. am just amazed at what's going on. That as a teacher in this district that I have served, if I choose to exercise my medical freedoms, I will lose my job. And on top of that, if the students that I teach choose to exercise their medical freedom, they will not be allowed to attend school in person. I taught school online through the pandemic with honestly very little support from the district besides a laptop and there you go, first graders. Online school does not work. I need, we need as teachers, we need our elected officials to stand up and protect us. I just listened to the other part of the board meeting talking all about freedom and rights with the previous thing we spoke about. How does that work? I don't know. I can tell you now, there were many teachers here ready to speak and we had another agenda item and I get it, people have their time. But I'm telling you now, how are you going to operate without all of us? And it was okay for me to do all this, before the vaccine in a classroom with kids, that was all fine.

SPEAKER_02 3:10:35

Why can't I sign a waiver? I ask you this, stand up, have courage, protect us, protect the students. That's all.

SPEAKER_11 3:10:47

Christy Hayes.

SPEAKER_05 3:10:58

Good evening board members. My name is Christy Hayes. I am here to share with you one example of a dedicated educator that you pose to lose if you do not fight for a medical choice. I have been teaching for 12 years. This is my eighth year in Chino Valley. I have served for three years on the tier one PBIS committee and I am the PBIS tier coach for our school. I have taught six summers in CVUSD. I carefully implement IEPs. in my classroom, allowing students to access their curriculum through FAPE in the least restrictive environment to support their needs. I am meticulous in upholding IDEA, the special education law, so that you, Chino Valley Unified, are not sued for lack of implementation and denying FAPE. And I keep you in compliance and out of lawsuits. I am an adjunct professor professor at national university in their school of education. I have been referred to as a powerhouse special special educator by a program coordinator here in this district. I am chosen as a prime example to observe for incoming special educators in the three months of the school year. I have had four incoming or currently practicing special educators observed my classroom. I have built my entire career on parent trust. that reflects you as a board and our district as a whole. I am known for my classroom management and instructional and behavioral strategies in a population that requires strong, consistent structures in place.

SPEAKER_05 3:12:24

I am also an alumnus of Don Wego High School, Townsend Junior High, and Oak Ridge Elementary. My maiden name is Marcos. My mother is Dr. Terry Marcos. Served as a teacher and administrator for 20 years in this district. My father is Dr. Joe Marcos. The baseball field at Don Lugo is Joe Marcos baseball field. The flagpole at Joe Marcos baseball field is dedicated to my grandmother, Helen Marcos. The Marcos family has been dedicated to this district since 1959 as my father is a product of Chino Valley Unified. My brother is an educator and attended Chino Valley Schools. I have two children who are students that attend the school district, one of whom is a daughter. Mr. Na and Mr. Cruz, I appreciate you for standing up for her. I will not stop. This year's theme in our district is lead to an impact, dot, dot, dot. What impact is it that you want us to lead to? What does leading mean to you? Does it mean taking away our choice? Does it mean cowering to tyrannical mandates stripping us of our rights? Or does it mean bringing educators, parents, students, community, and all of their stakeholders alongside and allowing each component to work in unison to maximize the potential and promote CVUSD as a leader and leaving a powerful legacy to its name? This group of educators you pose to lose will lead to an impact with or without your support. with us here or in our absence that this district will not recover from.

SPEAKER_05 3:13:58

I make these remarks with the utmost respect for the positions you hold. Thank you for your thoughtful consideration and respecting the position we hold.

SPEAKER_38 3:14:07

Cindy Boise.

SPEAKER_57 3:14:19

Hi. Have you guys Refresh your memories on the constitution. You should have. There are rights. Our government, the CDC, the NIH, the FDA is in bed with big pharma. We are being coerced and controlled. Ever wonder how we got a vaccination for COVID so fast, 10 months when previous vaccinations took three to 10 years, however many. Could it be the vaccination was already in the works for years? How could lying Fauci predict in February, 2017, Trump was going to face the biggest pandemic in his presidency. What did he know? He is a weasel. He is no longer a doctor. He is an arrogant, corrupt, unelected bureaucrat with death and injury on his hands along with his cohorts. Follow the money and contracts with Moderna. Why are big pharma not liable for the vaccines? When was the contract for no liability signed? Maybe December 12th, 2019? Coincidence? I don't think so. This was just weeks before the pandemic hit us. Check out Glenn Beck's special crime or cover up, which aired last night on Blaze TV. It was a two hour special on YouTube. Guess what? It was taken down one hour and 30 minutes into it. Censorship. We're being coerced into a vaccination for COVID-19. This vaccination has already outsmarted by the Delta variant, hence the spike in cases, but the vaccine is still being forced on us. Now we got boosters. How many? Every six months, every three months, maybe monthly as the variants change and the vaccines become less effective.

SPEAKER_57 3:16:22

This science is for the almighty dollar. Who owns the treatment Remdesivir? Pfizer. Man, we got that treatment awful fast too. How did that happen? How many have been harmed from it? There are and were early treatments available. They just didn't make big pharma and lying Fauci billions. These vaccines are harming people and our children. How many is it going to take for someone to be held accountable? You know these are not just our rights to say no. They're yours too. Wise up. Someday you're going to realize what's going on. It's going to be too late. Be leaders, not sheep. Do your research and use any critical thinking you may have left. I leave you with something to ponder. Only those who have something to hide will work relentlessly to censor those who speak the truth. This is what is going on. Thank you.

SPEAKER_38 3:17:26

Lance Ashbery.

SPEAKER_07 3:17:43

So my name is, my name is Lance. That's where I'm a teacher at hidden trails, elementary special ed teacher. Um, I actually came for a little bit of a different, um, speech here. It's it's a, I want to give a testimony. It's something that God had put on my heart and, um, gives a different narrative too. So when, when the. the spike began to happen about two and a half weeks into the school and just remembering how not fun you know online teaching was and how the students had lost so much i my first thought was lord please not again not not the spike my wife worked at a hospital and and not not a spike not not a spike that we're gonna have to lose again and go backwards and do that And so my first thought was, oh, sorry. My first thought was, okay, Lord, what can be done? How can I pray? What can bring some change to this? My thought was, Jesus, you're the king of this campus at Hidden Trails. What solution can we do? So when I prayed about it, I felt like the Lord told me, pray Psalm 91 over your school. Every day you go in and you walk onto campus, because I normally pray over my school, And you go on, pray Psalm 91 over your school. I said, all right. I started doing that. And I started watching all the emails from Dr. Enfield's office and all the schools.

SPEAKER_07 3:19:05

And about three days later, Hidden Trails wasn't on that. I thought, OK, let me. So every day I walked on campus, kept praying. Every day now, Hidden Trails was not on there. went about 10 weeks 10 weeks without having anything on there and i was telling that to our our prayer group that i meet in the morning that this today was the very first case i heard that we got the very first case we got so i wanted to come up here and just give a different solution that we do our best with masks and mandates and all that i know different opinions everybody has but i wanted to bring encouragement and just remind people that there's, there's a God who has solutions, who has wisdom and who has strategies. And I wanna encourage them to pray. I just simply ask the Lord, what, what can I do? What, what can be done? He gave me a strategy. I just simply obeyed. I, I prayed it and 10 weeks we went without any new COVID cases. This is the first one today. So I just wanna encourage teachers, board members, which I'm very thankful I get to speak here. And parents in the community, ask God. He's got strategies. So thank you very much for letting me speak up here. I just wanted to share some positive news. So God bless. Thank you.

SPEAKER_34 3:20:29

Thank you for those who stuck around to share your thoughts. To those individuals that didn't stick around and for those teachers that weren't able to make comments tonight, I do express our apologies. But as you saw, we had an action item that had quite a few students from the district, over 30, and I felt it was very important that we hear them in a timely manner so that we could move forward with those items. I will put this out, I will contact ACT to see if there's anything that they would like to do as far as setting up a meet and greet or some type of a round table. I would be more than happy to come and hear everybody and talk with everybody.

SPEAKER_29 3:21:11

Moving on now, final comments from the board, Mr. Cruz.

SPEAKER_47 3:21:17

I want to thank you all for coming tonight's board meeting. Thank you for attending our historic past board meetings. Please keep the faith and come to all the board meetings. because you're going to take back your child and change history. The question is, what is going on? The media is a propaganda machine feeding you false information. They make false comments, leave out vital information to steer you into a place of their belief. They said that your child must have a COVID shot. But in reality, the CDC fact states your child has a 99.99995% chance of surviving COVID. So what's up? When it comes to your child, masks don't matter, shots don't matter. Your child's education is all that matters. And how many of you here tonight are asking, what is going on? Let's see this media brainwash, washes, you take drugs.

SPEAKER_50 3:23:05

personal or family history of medullary thyroid cancer, multiple endocrine neoplasia syndrome type 2, or if you are allergic to Ozempic. Stop taking Ozempic and get medical help right away if you get a lump or swelling in your neck, severe stomach pain, itching, rash, or trouble breathing. Serious side effects may happen, including pancreatitis. Tell your doctor if you have diabetic retinopathy or vision changes. Taking Ozempic with a sulfonylurea or insulin may increase the risk for low blood sugar. Common side effects are nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, stomach pain, and constipation. Some side effects can lead to dehydration, which may worsen kidney problems. I discovered the potential with Ozempic. Ask your health care provider if Ozempic is right for you.

SPEAKER_47 3:23:49

A little bit, you couldn't hear it much, but let's talk about the good stuff. It lowers your blood pressure. You may lose weight. That's a good idea. No increased risk of heart attacks and strokes. Thank goodness for that. Not approved for children under age 18. What about K through 12? What is the best stuff? You might get thyroid cancer, allergies. You may get a lump or swelling in your neck, itching, rash, or trouble breathing. It can cause pancreatitis, vision changes, nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, stomach pains, constipation, dehydration, worsening kidney problems. What the world am I doing? All drugs, enough of the talk. All drugs have disclosures. COVID shots have no disclosures. Why would you inject a drug into your body that has zero disclosures? If you do, you may say, oh, the question is, should a school board have the right to shoot possibly fatal non-disclosure drugs into your child? My answer is always no. But, and I'm emphasizing this, Marxists always say yes. Crossing over the bridge, we have all sacrificed to do our part, but we were misled by the government, CDC, and the media to give up our rights for the common good. This is communistic. How can we have 80% of the people over age 12 with a COVID shot wear a mask, social distancing, and have more deaths this year versus last year? How is this possible? Our children's education has been put into the status of failure by our governor, Sergeant

SPEAKER_47 3:26:06

Mark's explored members over false health and safety reasons that don't apply to your children's education. Thus their education is being stolen from them. How is it that we have more deaths again in 2021 versus 2020 when 80% of the people over age 12 have been vaccinated? That is something to think about. I've given you over the last board meetings, all the CDC information where your child has a 99.99995% chance of survival from COVID. Think about that. Your parents should be in charge of your kid's education. It's not Biden's kids. It's not Newsome's kids. It's not Schaefer, Ganger or Bridges kids. It's your kids. I apologize for the misspelling.

SPEAKER_01 3:27:03

Oops. I thought I corrected that.

SPEAKER_47 3:27:09

Join me to take back your kids' education, learning, safety, fun, discovery, and opportunities. This is what school should be about, focusing on those aspects. This is our focus going forward. Thank you.

SPEAKER_12 3:27:34

yes the students were great tonight but also our staff members and teachers and staff members coming to tell us your concern was great and it is very important we have approximately 400 to 500 staff members that who's worried about their jobs i don't think we could allow that i'd like to ask Dr. Enfield, to look what type of waiver and medical exemptions that could protect our teachers' and staff's jobs enough is enough the mandates are there but real people that we're working with are our teachers and our staff members and they're the ones who's touching our our children's lives and and they're teaching them to be a great citizens of this state so if we don't care for our teachers and staff first We don't belong here. So I'd like to see Dr. Enfield really look into this issue. I have heard several times that they felt we're just talking. So I'd like to see Dr. Enfield really looking at other districts and how we can protect our teachers and staff members. And also there was a concern brought up by one parent about her son not being able to get exemption from or somebody from a doctor or letter was not certified or something like that. I'd like to see her being helped.

SPEAKER_43 3:29:36

There is no exemption right now, Mr. Na. So there's nothing to turn in. There's no guidelines for any of it. The governor has said that he's going to do mandates for vaccinations, but we don't know what those are.

SPEAKER_12 3:29:48

So her son is okay right now?

SPEAKER_43 3:29:50

Yeah, there's nothing to turn in.

SPEAKER_12 3:29:52

Okay.

SPEAKER_43 3:29:52

Yeah, because there's no guidelines. That's what we've been sharing.

SPEAKER_12 3:29:55

Okay, great. So maybe we can put that out there.

SPEAKER_43 3:30:00

Yeah, I think health department has a letter going out because there's some confusion with parents.

SPEAKER_12 3:30:04

Yeah, make sure that we feel safe and especially we don't need to have extra worries from our parent part and our teachers and our staff members. And I'd like to thank Joe Marcus. He's my dear friend, but he touched so many students' lives at Don Lugo High School. He's just my brother. I think he did a great job raising daughter here and the whole family. So thank you, Joel. You have done a good job being a good father. Now I'd like to talk about Veterans Day, even though it was passed already. Really thank our veterans who had given not only time, but everything they had, many of them had given their lives. And as our students, young people wouldn't understand what that means. Many of them don't understand how to raise children yet. They have experienced their family experience and might have siblings, but actually having your children changing their diapers and feeding them milk before preparing your own dinner. It's a whole lot of work. And so are your perspectives. Your perspectives will change, change for a greater good. It is good that our students have stood by small group of people that they thought and what's a good character too, but sometimes you need to become an adult to see a bigger picture. There's none of the parents, including everybody who's sitting here, would want to see, would allow their daughters to be in a same facility, especially locker room or shower facility with a boy.

SPEAKER_12 3:32:08

And that's truly coming from, not only from my heart, but from all the parents. Not only from state of California, but throughout this country, and matter of fact, I can bet somebody you could go to other continent and ask their parents if it is okay for their little ones to be with opposite sex, you know, compromising facilities. And I can bet any amount. I don't have lots of money, but I could bet any amount. So when we're having this type of rules or laws mandated, and it's contradicting our common sense and our belief system, there is something wrong. They had a survey done in one of these colleges for all the students.

SPEAKER_52 3:33:11

And professor had asked, if you're in a jungle and you found endangered species or something, organism, an insect, or an animal, but endangered, and a man,

SPEAKER_12 3:33:31

And you get to save one thing at a time. Which one would you go save first? And most of students have raised their hands in dangerous spaces.

SPEAKER_52 3:33:45

That's what's been taught in today's college.

SPEAKER_12 3:33:50

And the kids are consumed. You have to protect these, protect. But what about the bigger picture? What about the rest of the population? What about the, yes, these people are innocent.

SPEAKER_52 3:34:02

So are these. You can't see that yet. So I understand the kids can't see that. That's okay.

SPEAKER_12 3:34:10

Because when they grow up, they have their own daughters and their sons, then they will understand.

SPEAKER_52 3:34:18

I'll do anything for my kids. And I would never, ever, matter of fact, they might be even more strict about going out and coming back what time.

SPEAKER_12 3:34:29

they would never allow their daughter to be in a facility, a locker room or shower with opposite sex, a boy.

SPEAKER_52 3:34:40

Even though your daughter could explain to you whatever. As a parent, as a mother, you would say no. Because you know why? It's a common sense. There are few senses that's given when you were born. taste, touching, smell. That's why we smell flowers a lot, because it smells so good. We touch animals, we pet them. And guess what? We use our eyes to see. But the education today, or the lawmaker says, don't trust your eyes. Don't trust your senses. It's wrong. But we have to tell the truth. They might not understand this year, next year, or 10 years from now. But if we don't say it, it's a negligence.

SPEAKER_12 3:35:45

I would really like to see that we can help our teachers and staff members. And truly, there are many teachers and staff members who has medical conditions, as well as our children who should be exempted from this mandate. And I'll never give that up because they're our family. Everyone's our family. So thank you for all the students who attended tonight's meeting and also all the teachers and staff members. Thank you.

UNKNOWN 3:36:27

Mr. Bridge.

SPEAKER_04 3:36:29

Very, very quickly. Mr. Cruz, I'll excuse you for the misspelling. At least you did not pluralize my name by putting in the apostrophe, which I appreciate because the name, I always have to tell my students the name is singular, not plural. Two quick points. Congratulations to the Chino High School football team for their continued success in the CIF playoffs. They're playing tomorrow night against Valencia. I still haven't found out whether that's Valencia in Orange County or Valencia High School up by Magic Mountain, but good luck to them tomorrow night. also the uh congratulations the chino high girls volleyball team from reaching the finals in the cif southern section southern california playoffs and they are playing on saturday afternoon in orange county nester do you know where they're where the team yeah i did say chino hills high didn't i i'm sorry if i didn't it's good no it's not that late

SPEAKER_34 3:37:27

But yeah, Canyon College.

SPEAKER_04 3:37:29

Yeah.

SPEAKER_34 3:37:31

Orange.

SPEAKER_04 3:37:31

Okay. But yeah, congratulations to Chino Hills High, both their football team and the girls volleyball team on their success. And I just want to wish everyone Happy Thanksgiving next week and wonderful and safe Thanksgiving week off. That concludes my report.

SPEAKER_34 3:37:46

My remote.

SPEAKER_00 3:37:48

Yes, good evening. Thank you to the individuals that are still here. I appreciate you hanging on there. Um, it's been a hard 20 months. Uh, again, I said that probably a couple of times. That's an understatement. Um, these meetings have gotten out of control, regardless of what you feel about any given topic we discuss, they've gotten out of control. People are being disrespectful to each other across the board. People are individually attacking one another. I've seen students get attacked at multiple meetings. I've seen students get jeered at multiple meetings. I sat at the last meeting and watched a member of our community describe the death of a friend's son and get booed. And that's not this community. It just really isn't. I've spent the better part of my 40 years living here, and that's just not who this community is. And we keep having topics brought before this board that are intentionally divisive, and that creates an intentionally divisive environment. And we gotta stop. This is not sustainable. everyone has gone through this pandemic the last 20 months and has had their own struggles. And I don't deign to understand how difficult this has been for some people. I only have my own experience, but This is not tenable. This is not positive. I can't believe anyone comes to these meetings and leaves feeling positive about the experience, regardless of your views on any given issue. We're not sitting here and having a debate that is pleasant.

SPEAKER_00 3:39:33

We're in this basic war. And unfortunately or fortunately, School boards, you know, we touch people very personally. We are dealing with children. And I think we're also one of the more accessible public organizations that exist. And so I understand why in a moment where, you know, the last 20 months have been very confusing, things have shifted, there's a lot of things going on, a lot of unknowns and a lot of known unknowns, why people are here. Um, you know, you can't just sort of walk into the California state legislature and, you know, directly interact in the same way that you're doing here. But I will say though that something unique about us is that we specifically are creating a framework and supporting children. And so, you know, what I would ask and I don't think this is a political ask. I don't think this is. And frankly, you know, everyone is warranted to levy criticisms. We had criticisms levied at multiple members of the dais tonight. We have to be held accountable. So if you don't like something that we do, it's one thing to come in and address us and say that. But I think that we really need to think about what we want these meetings to look like moving forward, because we are We're an organization dedicated to children. And, you know, if you were to step back and just think about that, these meetings are not a reflection of that. I believe one of the reasons why I supported tonight and probably the principal reason I supported committing public comments on items not on the agenda to the end of the agenda was I was aware we had 30 plus high school students here and they had come to speak.

SPEAKER_00 3:41:14

And we've had several meetings where we've had action items and we have sat there and listened to every single speaker who wanted to speak. But we do have a policy in this district of supporting students. And so we wanted to give them an opportunity to speak. It was also a topic where a lot of the students were very courageous to come speak. And I think all of our students that come speak on all topics are being very courageous to do this in a public setting that's being YouTube live and also recorded. But I think I have a simple request. I think it's a request that we can all work together on in a time when things are so divisive, which I truly wish they weren't. um you know let's commit to making these meetings more positive let's commit to you know making an environment where parents on all sides of the spectrum on all issues feel comfortable coming and most importantly let's make these meetings where our students feel comfortable coming as well thank you and have a good evening yeah i just want to wish everybody a safe and happy thanksgiving

SPEAKER_34 3:42:12

Thank you. I do want to thank all of our students that came out and let their voices or lent their voices to other students to be heard. Uh, it's important that we hear from you and that you get engaged in, in the con in the conversation. So thank you. I'd also like to extend a public apology to the Hargrove family. Uh, we did have a action item tonight, uh, to honor the memory of Mark Hargrove. And unfortunately, because of behavior of some, we were required to pull that at the request of the family. So that will be coming back. But again, my apologies to the Hargrove family. With that, I adjourn this regular meeting of the Board of Education at 9.45.