This site is an independent public archive. It is not an official Chino Valley Unified School District site. Not an official Chino Valley USD site
In the Minutes Chino Valley USD
Transcript ← All meetings

Board of Education — November 19, 2026

Match – of – for “6145.2”
Part 1 of 2 · 0:03:21 Watch this part
SPEAKER_02 0:00:35

Education Thursday, November 19th, 2026 at 420 p.m. with Cervantes Cruz, Noshaw, Smith present. Reagan, are there any requests from the public to speak on closed session items prior to the board adjourning into closed session?

SPEAKER_01 0:00:48

Yes, there is one.

SPEAKER_02 0:00:50

Thank you so much. Speakers, you have up to three minutes to address the board on closed session items only. Your name is now on the monitor. And I think that's all I have to read. One moment. One moment.

SPEAKER_00 0:01:06

David Bolag. Good afternoon, I'm David Bolag. It's nice to see you all here today. I want to thank you all for what you've done for the school in regards to legalities of what's happening and what you're going to talk about in closed session. First, I want to commend you for partnering up with Justice Center and Advocates for Faith and Freedom and what that's doing for our students. Education is not just about what's in the classroom, but it's policies that you set forth, policies that the state sets forth, and those that are unjust and are wrong and are harmful to students that you fought against. Now, I don't know which way you're going to go on the lawsuit with AB 955, but I do trust that this current board will make the right decision there. And I want to thank you for standing up against the teachers union. And this is embarrassing me because I am a labor union with the GOP Union Caucus. And many of our members are CTA members. And we do not like the idea that you as a school board cannot ban flags. that are not prevalent to teachers teaching about our civic duties here. As we have American flag and US flag, we don't need anything that talks about a person's personal life. So I do commend you on that. And I want to thank you all for that. And I know you're going to make the right decisions in closed sessions.

SPEAKER_02 0:02:29

Thank you so much. Any more?

SPEAKER_01 0:02:35

There is no more.

SPEAKER_02 0:02:36

We will now adjourn to closed session regarding the following matters, which are all described in detail on the printed agenda, conference with legal counsel, anticipated litigation, one possible case, conference with legal counsel, existing litigation, six cases, student discipline matters, public employee appointment, junior high, high school assistant principal, public employee discipline dismissal release, and public employee performance evaluation. Superintendent, thank you.

Part 2 of 2 · 3:33:16 Watch this part
SPEAKER_40 0:00:54

I now reconvene the regular meeting of Board of Education at 6 p.m. with Cervantes, Cruz, Nahshon, Smith present. Before we begin, please silence all electronic devices and note that these proceedings are being recorded, Reagan.

SPEAKER_44 0:01:06

The board met in closed session from 420 p.m. to 527 p.m. regarding conference with legal counsel anticipated litigation, one possible case, conference with legal counsel existing litigation, six cases, student discipline matters, public employee appointment, junior high school assistant principal, public employee discipline dismissal release, and public employee performance evaluation superintendent. The board took the following action. appointed Patricia Vega Jeter as assistant principal at Cal Aero K-8 school with an effective date of November 20th, 2026 with a vote of 5-0 with Cervantes, Cruz, Naussmith and Shaw voting yes. No further action was taken that requires public disclosure.

SPEAKER_40 0:01:44

Thank you, Reagan. And we have two special guests. We have Olivia and then Matthew Wards leading us in the Pledge of Allegiance.

SPEAKER_54 0:02:04

I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

SPEAKER_40 0:02:23

Thank you. And now time for one of my favorite but last things on my last meeting, our recognitions. Tonight the Board of Education is proud to recognize the outstanding achievements of our girls varsity flag football teams from Ayala, Chino High School, Chino Hills High School, and Don Lugo. Yes, give a round of applause. Throughout the 2026 season, these talented student athletes demonstrated exceptional dedication, teamwork, perseverance, achieving significant milestones and making history within these programs. We are pleased to celebrate their accomplishments and recognize the student athletes and their coaches who work hard and their commitment have contributed to the continued success and growth of girls flag football throughout our district. We begin by recognizing Bulldogs, Ayala High School, varsity, sorry, I was a Bulldog, so it's still in my head. flag football team for an outstanding 2026 season. I have watched you guys on social media, checked up with parents and we are so incredibly proud of you. The team made program history by achieving its first 20 plus win season. Give them a round of applause. finishing with an impressive overall record of 22 wins and eight losses. The Bulldogs earned second place in the Palomares League, were ranked third in CIF Division II, and that is a big accomplishment in itself, and was named the Gridian Glory Tournament, there you go, championship. The team also advanced to the second round of CIF playoffs, demonstrating determination, competitive excellence through the season. In addition to these teams' accomplishments, several student athletes earned all

SPEAKER_40 0:04:28

Polymeris League Honors. First team, League, Chloe Cotter, Eileen Diaz, and Delia, I don't want to say her name wrong, Renaga? There we go, can we give them a round of applause? Second team, Skylar Bergeron, Gaida Marquez, Jada? Sorry. And Marina Ortega. Give them a round of applause. And they had three all-league honorable mentions, which is also very, very huge. We have Mariska Kuspak, Emma Gandara, and Juju Jones. And now I would like to invite the coaches to meet me over there where you see their certificates and also the board.

SPEAKER_21 0:05:48

Hello, everybody. Thank you for coming out to support all of the district's girls flag football teams. I'd first like to thank Dr. Enfield and the district personnel for taking the time to honor girls flag football and giving us the opportunity to start this sport. Four years ago, they made the decision that girls flag football was going to be a major component. We're going to be able to add this sport to the program. And by doing this, it's opened up many opportunities for the girls, not only within our district, but also with future college scholarship opportunities. So thank you, board, and thank you, district. We really appreciate that. OK, my name is Randy Reams. I'm the assistant football coach at Iola High School. Our head coach, Amy Campbell, she had knee surgery, is not able to be here. She really wanted to be here, but was not able to come. Can I please have Marcus Hamilton and Tim Rogers come on up here also? You guys are our coaches. I'll come back over here. OK, now I'm going to take a minute to call the girls up and have them receive the recognition that they deserve. As Ms. Shaw read their accomplishments throughout this year, they had an outstanding season. This is built on three previous CIF seasons in which the girls qualified for CIF each of those three years. So definitely just want to make sure they have their props. OK, first up, Kaylin Age.

SPEAKER_21 0:07:28

Sophia Alvarado. Sarah Avila. Skylar Bergeron. Natalia Cavani. Peyton Chang, not present. Chloe Cotter. Mariska Shupak. Eileen Diaz, not present. Emma Gandara. Gianna Gutierrez. Juju Jones, not present. Nyla Key, not present. Jada Marquez. Aliyah Mitchell. Noel Alano. Marina Ortega. Kayla Marie Pacheco. Cameron Pua. Hailey Reams. Delilah Renaga. Mari Jose Rodriguez. Amron Silva. Ava Trujillo. And last but not least, London Williams. Again, this is your 2026 IELA girls flag football team. Let's give them one more round of applause.

SPEAKER_40 0:09:10

We also want to, again, thank our coaches. Don't go anywhere, coaches. Of course, we have Amy, the head coach, Campbell. Can we give her a round of applause, even though she's not able to be here? Coach, how do you say coach? I'm just going to get Coach Joe. Coach D. Is he not here tonight? You could take the... And then Coach Rogers. Thank you for everything that you do. And we want you guys in the picture, too. OK, Coach Hamilton. Thank you. And last but not least, Coach Reeves. We're gonna have Andy take a picture and then parents, you're more than welcome to come up and take pictures. You're more than welcome to stay for the next high schools, but at this moment, I know you guys have a busy schedule. You're more than welcome to leave as well.

UNKNOWN 0:10:20

Amen.

SPEAKER_40 0:11:20

Let's give them another round of applause. Congratulations again to Ariella High School girls varsity flag football team on a historic and successful season. Okay, now we have our Cowboys. Next, we recognize the Chino High School girls varsity flag football team for an exceptional 2026 season. The team finished with an impressive overall record with 19 wins and four losses, including an undefeated eight to zero league record. Give them a round of applause, that's amazing. As they demonstrated continued excellence, the Cowboys captured, Cowgirls captured their third consecutive Mount Baldy League championship. And the team also qualified for the CIF Division III playoffs, advancing through the first and the second rounds before reaching the quarterfinals. This marked the furthest the Chino High School girls varsity flag football team has advanced in the CIF playoffs in school history. In addition to these outstanding team accomplishments, three student athletes earned individual league honors. We have league's most valuable player, Calise Gibson. Defensive most valuable player, Marissa Martinez. Offensive most valuable player, Jeanne Phillips, or Jean Phillips. These achievements reflect the team's continued commitment to excellence, determination, and teamwork, as well as their dedication and leadership of its coaches. At this time, I call each of the student athletes to line up as you saw Ayala Bulldogs do, and also as well of our staff and any of our coaches that are available tonight, please.

SPEAKER_25 0:13:52

Thank you so much. I want to thank the school board for recognizing our flat football team this year. I'm Coach Munger. We had four coaches this year. Coach Beatty's not here tonight. Coach Caballero and also our JV coach, Coach Black. I want to recognize Ayala High School and Chino Hills and Don Lugo for a great season this year. All get the CIF playoffs. You know, way back when, when I was a football coach at Chino High School, our principal, John Cervantes, was a great baseball player. And our AD, Art Gracia, was my star quarterback. Now they're my bosses right now. You know what I'm saying? But anyway, and our girls, to me, are very special right there. We had 30 varsity girls, and here's the most important thing. They worked hard on the football field, but... 26 girls out of 30 have a 3.5 GPA or better. And three more have a GPA of 3.0 or better. So I'm sure right now a lot of girls are probably studying at home right now. And also I guess there was a field trip today for all the ASB girls. So anyway, so tonight we have three young ladies here tonight. Oh, four, I'm sorry. Okay. Aaliyah Alvarado. She's not here. Okay. Alyssa Alvarez.

SPEAKER_28 0:15:21

She's our quarterback.

SPEAKER_25 0:15:27

Gabriela Alvarez. Gia Amos. Brittany Aviles. Felicity Cannon. Kimberly Castleberry. Catherine Corona. Brianna Cruz Sanchez. Jacqueline Delgado. Inaya Espinosa. Alisa Far. Khalees Gibson, Brianna Gonzalez, Victoria Gonzalez, Alyssa Hampton, Annabel Ybarra, Marissa Martinez, Evelyn Ornelas, Mariah Piaz, Anna Pantel, MVP player of the year on offense, Gianna Rangel-Phillips. Did I miss them all too, this time? Okay, okay. Secret Ramirez, Natalie Ratcliff, Stephanie Reyes, Andrea Romo, Gabby Runlick, Hannah Sanchez, Sofia Palacios, Riley Valenzuela. And one last thing, the icon of Chino flag football is really Rhonda Phillips. She does everything for us. She works so hard for us, fundraising to me. Rhonda, where you at tonight? Rhonda, thank you so much.

SPEAKER_40 0:17:07

Awesome. We'll give him another round of applause. And I know, I thought I saw some Chino staff get up here and celebrate with us. You're part of the team, please. We'd love to have you up here. And Coach Munger, thank you for everything that you continue to do. Your name is legendary in Chino Valley, so thank you. So yes, give him a round of applause. Not present, Coach Beatty, right? There's none of them there. So we can... And coach, how do you say his last name? Antonio Caballero. Yes. And we have also coach Black. Give them all a hand. We would love to have a picture with you guys. Let's give them one more round of applause. Congratulations. Next, we're recognizing Huskies, Chino Hills High School girls varsity flag football team for an outstanding 2026 season. The Huskies demonstrated remarkable growth and determination, improving from a four-win season to an impressive 12-win season. Yes, give them a round of applause. This tremendous progress led the team to qualifying automatically for the CIF playoffs for the first time in the program's history, making an exciting milestone. The team also demonstrated exceptional defensive strength, recording an impressive 53 interceptions throughout the season. Yeah, you can applause that. In addition to these team's accomplishments, four student athletes earned all baseline league honors. First team, Alexa Mendoza, And Giano Larios. Second team, Jasmine Itea. And I have a favorite, Brooke Shaw. Sorry. I love you guys all, but it's Brooke.

SPEAKER_40 0:20:41

These achievements reflect the hard work, perseverance, and dedication of the student athletes and their coaches whose commitment has helped elevate the program to new heights. At this time, I ask the student athletes that came to please line up and coaches and anybody else from staff, please join me.

SPEAKER_38 0:21:28

My name is Scott Kelly. I am the head coach of Chino Hills flag football. Uh, just wanted to thank the school board and everybody here tonight and also congratulate all the other four high schools, three high schools in our district for phenomenal seasons. Uh, keep, keep working hard. I hope that you guys continue to play flag football. There is so much money in this and I think that you guys can all grab your hands on some of that money. Okay. So keep working hard. Okay. Um, we'll go ahead and get started. Uh, Madeline Acevedo not here.

SPEAKER_39 0:21:57

Olivia Denran. Lauren Aguirre, not present. Nayeli Anguiano, not present. Jasmine Atiyah. Jalilah Brown. Laura Casillas, not present. Andrea Davis, not present. Anais Dominguez, not present. Ayanna Edward, not present. Lourdes Escobar. Terry Garcia. Nariah Harrell. Alyssa Hudson, not present. Emery Hughes, not present. Brett Lambrick, not present. Gigi Larios, not present. Mia Lopez, not present. Sasha Liglama, not present. Sophia Maranco. Marcella Martinez, not present. Allison Mejia. Alexa Mendoza, not present. Caitlin Myers, not present. Ashley Montano, not present. Harmony Morair, not present. Kennedy Okamoto. Adia Levis, not present. Ashley Ordenana, not present. Anaya Paseas, not present. Rylan Paldrill, not present. Layla Rice-Brown.

SPEAKER_02 0:23:32

Good job, buddy.

SPEAKER_39 0:23:39

Yazabeth Ruiz Hernandez, not present. Brooke Shaw. Caitlin Strohsider, not present. Taylor Tran, not present.

SPEAKER_38 0:23:50

And we have a JV player, Izzy Morris, present to support the team.

SPEAKER_39 0:23:53

All right, Izzy. Come on up, Izzy.

SPEAKER_40 0:24:06

And we also want to honor our coaches. We have an amazing coach staff. We have Coach Michael. We can give him a round of applause. Coach Danny. Coach Jack. I'm shocked he's not here. And then Coach Jacoa. And of course, last but not least, the one that is in charge of driving these girls to success, we appreciate everything you do, Coach Kelly.

UNKNOWN 0:24:46

Yeah.

SPEAKER_40 0:25:57

Congratulations again, Chino Hills High School. Awesome, now we get to recognize the Don Lugo High School Girls Varsity Flag Football Team for another historic season. In 2025, the Conquistadors became the first girls' flag football team in Chino Valley Unified School District history to qualify for the CIF playoffs, win a playoff game, and advance to the quarterfinals. Bill, yes. Building on that success, the team returned to CIF playoffs in 2026 in an exciting first round matchup against Norwalk. The Conquistadors secured a hard-fought 27-20 overtime victory. With the remarkable win, Don Lugo became the first flag football program in district history to win playoff games in back-to-back seasons. These historic achievements reflect the team's determination, perseverance, and commitment to excellence, as well as the dedication and leadership of its coaches. At this time, I ask that our student athletes line up on the side, and then I would also like to invite our coaches.

SPEAKER_49 0:27:35

Yeah, I'm just gonna go off by who's here. Okay, well, thank you to the Chino Valley School District for your support, not only this year, but the last four years. I've had the the honor to be the head coach, the very first head coach at Don Lugo. And it's just grown to a very massive sport that is just getting bigger. It'll be in the Olympics. And I'm hoping that one of these girls out here in the crowd, we get to go see you play. And I just want to say one thing is that... On the field, yes, we're competitors, but off the field, just continue to empower each other. We're a small community, but a lot of love and support goes a long way. So no matter who you play for, we'll cheer you on.

SPEAKER_08 0:28:54

Thank you.

SPEAKER_49 0:29:05

So first player, Harley Biggs. Next we have Kayla Delgado. Jessica Eggleston. Michelle McLean. Sienna Robles. And Captain Cadence Hsu.

SPEAKER_40 0:29:59

And we also have Coach Esteban. And Coach Daniel Robles. Yes, thank you for everything. And then do we have another? Coach Thompson will get you your certificate. Don't worry, it'll be delivered. Thank you. And then do we have any?

UNKNOWN 0:31:12

Thank you.

SPEAKER_40 0:31:44

Congratulations again to Don Lugo High School girls varsity flag football team on another outstanding season and continuing to make district history. I would like to just close out with saying congratulations to you all and thank you parents for trusting the district with your daughters. We have an amazing coaching staff over all of our four high schools. And we appreciate the dedication, the long hours, the love being put into making sure our girls have success. Continued success to all of you and your seniors. Like you said, let's see you play some awesome games after high school. Congratulations. I know you guys got homework and stuff to do. Staff needs to get some sleep so they can deal with you the next day. So get out of here. Give them another round of applause.

SPEAKER_44 0:33:06

Did you want to invite?

SPEAKER_40 0:33:10

We have some sitting in overflow. Hopefully you can hear me right now. You're more than welcome to head over. We have pretty much half of the boardroom available for you to come get a seat. We'll give just a couple minutes for everybody to exit out. And those of you coming in from overflow, you're more than welcome to come over here. Okay, looks like it's quiet, door's closed. Now onto our last recognition, certainly not least. The Board of Education is proud to celebrate 10 of our schools for their outstanding achievements and commitment to collaboration, continuous improvement, and student success. Six of our schools have earned the Promising Practice recognition, which celebrates their success in implementing the Professional Learning Community, PLC, at work process. Through strong collaboration, innovative instructional practices, and shared commitment to student learning, these schools have demonstrated measurable improvements in student achievement. This accomplishment marks an exciting milestone in their journey towards becoming Model PLC at Work schools. Four of our schools have earned the prestigious Model PLC at Work recognition, an exceptional achievement that reflects years of dedication, collaboration, and sustained success in improving student learning. These schools have established a culture of excellence where educators work together to strengthen instruction, respond to student needs, and ensure high levels of learning for all students. Their accomplishments serve as an inspiring example of what can be achieved through teamwork and a shared commitment to excellence. We are incredibly proud of these schools and the dedicated educators and school leaders who hard work and commitment continue to make a meaningful difference in the lives of our students.

SPEAKER_40 0:35:39

At this time, I would like to invite Jessica Rogers, State Office Executive Director of Solution Tree to share a few words about the significance of the wonderful achievements, present these well-deserved awards and recognize our outstanding schools. As each school is recognized, we ask that the principal and their team remain at the front for a group photo with the Board of Education.

SPEAKER_53 0:36:10

red oh there we go thank you president shaw board of trustees district leadership members of the community i'm jessica rogers i'm the executive director for solution trees california state office and i have to say it's so great to be back to continue to celebrate academic and instructional success in chino valley unified school district I want to share to everybody in the room a few key components and really significant things about getting this award. Just for some perspective, within the entire state of California, there's over 10,000 schools. And there are only 112 schools in the state of California that have either the Promising Practices or the Model PLC award. And Chino Valley represents about 10% of those awards. So can we pause and celebrate that? So regardless if you are a promising practice PLC or a model PLC, both of those awards represent hard work from the staff, the teachers and the administrators on all of our school campuses. And obviously Chino Valley Unified School District is a model PLC district. There are only five model PLC districts in the state of California. So this is part of our culture here. Our priorities are about kids. Are our kids learning what we need them to learn to prepare them to be successful for the next grade, but then eventually when they leave us and they go on to college and to their adult life? How are we helping kids who aren't where we need them to be or where we would like them to be?

SPEAKER_53 0:37:46

And the PLC process intentionally creates systems so that if a student is struggling, we have systems in place to make sure that we catch them up and we help spend some more time with them so they learn those skills without disrupting their regular learning, without pulling them from the instruction that they're receiving from their amazing teachers. We have systems of interventions for that continued support that's needed and also opportunities for students who already have learned it to learn even more and to continue their learning. So I always joke that this process, this system feels like common sense and it is common sense but our school system is not designed to support a process like this. It is really hard for teachers to step out of their classroom and work with their peers in a collaborative culture. Naturally, we want to just stay in our own classroom and just do our thing. But the PLC process intentionally forces teachers to work together. And in the end, they actually benefit. They learn from their peers. They steal ideas from each other. They help other teachers, students, if they're struggling in areas. And they just get better in their profession. And they truly are professionals. But every professional deserves to continually improve. And our system has so many standards that students are required to learn. So this process helps schools narrow down what exactly what skills we want kids to learn. And that really helps ensure that we're setting them up for success and not failure.

SPEAKER_53 0:39:26

So enough about that. But I'm talking a lot, but I'm just very passionate about this process. And again, so excited to be here. So I would love to start by recognizing our promising practice schools. So I'm going to call the school up. And if anybody is here from that school, please come up board if you wouldn't mind coming to the front. And we'll just have all the promising practices stay up here for a photo. And then we'll move on to Model PLC. Thank you.

SPEAKER_09 0:39:50

How are you? Good, how are you?

SPEAKER_53 0:39:52

Good to see you. All right, we're going to start with Marshall Elementary. Eagle Canyon. Yeah, everybody come up, please. The more the merrier.

SPEAKER_56 0:40:45

Congratulations. Thank you so much. Congratulations.

SPEAKER_53 0:40:48

Rhodes Elementary. Magnolia. Dickey Elementary. And last but not least, Lytle Elementary. There you are.

SPEAKER_52 0:41:49

Congratulations.

SPEAKER_53 0:42:08

And every school that is a Promising Practice school gets to represent that award with this amazing flag. So if it's OK for our photo op, I'd love to have you all, somebody in the middle holding the flag, One last final thing to note about receiving this award is to get this award, you not only have to demonstrate that you've implemented the systems of a PLC, you actually have to show that that stuff is working and students are learning, more students are learning. So for a promising practices school, there is at least two consecutive years of growth in all categories, grade level, low socioeconomic, English learners, all of the student groups that we represent, they're all learning more, which I think is just a really extra little punch. So I'm gonna get this flag up and then we're gonna take some photos. Congratulations again. We're gonna move on to our model PLC schools. And I'm gonna start with Liberty Elementary. Calero. Chino High School. And Ayala High School. And we're going to use Ayala's flag, so we'll make sure you take this home for our picture. Congratulations.

UNKNOWN 0:46:44

Oh.

SPEAKER_40 0:47:48

Let's give them one more round of applause. And I hope they already exited. Okay, we're now on to presentation. I would like, board member presentation, I'd like to invite the board members to join me at the mic, please. It's an ambush. Our next presentation is kind of an ambush of one of our board members who has been faithful in serving Chino Valley Unified School board children here. And as the board, as an entirety, we want to recognize you, Sean, for stepping up when our board needed someone to step in. So yes. Personally, as a mom who is in a group with other moms, I know you were approached because we thought you were the best fit. You came, you applied, and you got the position, and you literally served our students. You stood on the right side of history. I appreciate you from the bottom of my heart for doing all that you have, and I know your work isn't done. Your advocacy will continue because Your wife is my best friend, and we're going to continue to fight the good fight here. So I would like to invite the other board members to say something. But from the bottom of my heart, thank you for stepping up and stepping in and being bold and courageous in a time such as this.

SPEAKER_43 0:49:51

Yeah, Brother Sean, you've been a warrior. You know, you stepped up when John Monroe, our board member who was elected, had to leave for family reasons and different reasons, had to move out of state. That's always tough. Those things are unpredictable. So we had this gentleman step up to be that warrior, to jump in there and fill that gap. He did a tremendous job, always ready to be in the fight, to do what's right, to stand up for what is right, always regardless of Anything else? And so with that, brother, we appreciate you. Wish you the best. We know you're going to keep busy. And we thank you for your service, sir.

SPEAKER_48 0:50:33

You know, thank you for your service. And you're always there for the underdog. I've always sensed that in you. And you've made a big difference. So thank you.

SPEAKER_42 0:50:52

I hope Mr. Smith will have a great Christmas break, and he'll be back next year, January, and working with us, continually serving our school district because our children are his children. Thank you.

SPEAKER_29 0:51:16

Mr. Smith, again, I want to thank you, too, for the service that you did over the last year. I don't think people realize the commitment, the time and energy that goes into doing this position. And so again, I thank you for representing our students, our parents, and our community. Thank you, sir.

SPEAKER_47 0:51:39

Well, I have to say that it has truly been an honor and a privilege and a pleasure to serve this district. that this whole, the board, the cabinet, when you come in here, you really don't know what to expect, but then you really see the degree of professionalism that goes into running the school district and that the layers of this onion, when you peel it back and you see the commitment made by everyone involved here, the staff, all the, even the security guards, you guys are fantastic. We really appreciate the hard work you do protecting this board. A lot of familiar faces. So I just wanted to say, again, thank you. It has been an honor and a privilege to serve this board. Thank you.

SPEAKER_40 0:52:39

Reagan, get in.

SPEAKER_43 0:53:30

All right, everybody, not so fast, not so fast. If I can get everybody back here for a moment, please. We got one more thing. All right here. This one's huge. Mrs. Sonia Shah, the... You could sit or remain standing, totally up to you, but I got a couple of things I gots to say. There has absolutely been no one like her in this role as a president, and I guarantee there'll be no one after her that'll be this type of president no matter what, so let's just face it, that's just the way it is. The sacrifice that goes into what anybody has to do, no one knows what we do until you're actually hearing you do it. But honestly, to do what Sonia Shaw has done for the last seven, eight years, and it started before that. You could say her public scene maybe took place as far as you might think seven, eight years ago, but the prayers, the commitment, what it took to be called and led to do what she stepped up to do where nobody else would, or maybe this just wasn't their time. I don't know, but regardless, this woman stepped up. Sacrifice family has to... to sacrifice, they have to be just like if you serve in the military or any other type of deployment. If anybody's served in any type of special operations, military, law enforcement, where you're away and you don't know what's going to happen, it's the same type of warrior that Sonia Shah is.

SPEAKER_43 0:55:49

That's just the way it is. When you don any type of uniform and you stood up for battle, it takes that special warrior to know exactly what they're gonna do and every good warrior count the cost before they step into that battle. At no point whatsoever was there any type of hesitation or any type of delay in what she had to do or what she was called to do. She was faithful to service and faithful to what she had to do to honor God, to do what she had to do because there's a bigger picture and there's more at stake than just her personal safety because Everybody that knows her knows that there was a lot of things that she had to deal with that nobody should have to deal with because you want to serve your school district or children. Her husband's a warrior that stood up, stood by her, knew exactly what she had to do. Her kids are warriors because they stood in the gap for her, prayed for her, watched over her, took care of her, made sure her dad, their dad, her husband was taken care of to make sure the business could be taken care of because it takes a lot. Unless you've been in a situation where you're put in danger, you don't know what that's like, so don't pretend you do, because it's just different. this woman had to do that put up with it she's been faithful to her calling and we want to recognize her for everything she stood for stands for will continue to fight for and do until the day she is called home so sonia shaw regardless of what happens after this

SPEAKER_43 0:57:33

One thing I know for certain, we're always in the fight. We're never out of the fight. There's always a fight to have, because guess what? When we stand up for what's right, it's always in front of us. We have to do what we gots to do. So Sonia Shah, we love you. This might be a little unusual, but I'm just going with it. I would like to have family come up and please first be the first ones to say anything to your wife, your mom, please take the mic.

SPEAKER_56 0:58:12

Hi, I'm Madison Shaw and this is my lovely mother. I just want to say that I'm so deeply proud of her and everything that she does for us. And one thing that I know that she is like, standing up for is women's sports and girls' sports. And as a woman athlete, I just deeply appreciate her. And I know that everybody does that from girls' sports. And I just want to say I love you very much. And God has bigger plans for you. And I love you with all my heart.

SPEAKER_54 0:58:53

Hi, I'm Brooke Shaw. My mom is Sonya Shaw. I just wanted to say that I love you so much and thank you for everything you do for me and the family. God has just really given you my mother because she knows that you're the only one that can deal with my shopping addictions. Thank you so much for everything you do for me and the family. And I just wanted to say that you're the best thing in this whole world. And God has really blessed me with a mother like you. And I just thank God for you every single day. I love you.

SPEAKER_16 0:59:34

Oh, man. Well, it's... I was gonna say this for later, but this is like walking into the lion's den tonight. Thank you all for coming out, supporting my wife. She sacrificed a lot for everybody. She really, really cares about children, and she cares about their sports, and she cares about their education, and she wants parent notification, because you know what? All the parents should be notified about what's going on with their kids in school. She's been on the road for the last year. She's missed a lot of soccer. She's missed some flag football, some other stuff, family functions, but her heart's really into it. And she really, really supports this community. She loves all of you. Thank you so much for everybody coming out tonight and supporting her because it means a lot to her. Because like I said, her whole heart is into this. So this isn't the end for her. We already know what she's going to be doing next. So to everybody else out there that isn't supporting her, be ready because we've only started. All right? That's it.

SPEAKER_43 1:01:05

Yeah, don't stop. That's fine. I'd like to have board members come up at any time, whatever term you want to. Please come and say something.

SPEAKER_47 1:01:13

I believe in the Constitution and the separation of church and state. God bless you. I have to say, over these many years at this point in time, I've gotten to know Sonia quite well, not just as a board member, through my wife. And I have to say that she is an honorable woman. Her heart is in the good place. And she comes very sincere. Some people might think it's too strong, but guess what? It's the right thing. So she digs her heels in, and she's always going to fight the good fight. Sonia, it's been awesome. Love you.

SPEAKER_48 1:02:07

You know, the first time I saw you, I told Pat, this was COVID time, I told Pat, man, those big muscles. And you were the one. You were the one. And look what the changes you've made. You have made a difference in people's lives, and you have impacted. And that is so critical, what you have done. unique person such as you could have done that and at that moment it was really rare and you came in and you really have changed a lot of people's perspective you made a lot of differences in people's lives and it just keeps on going and in these situations it is expected and God does remarkable things and so and so in the future It just keeps on going. And it's so exciting what you have done and what will happen in the future. It really doesn't matter because it's such a fantastic time of life that we're living. So what you've done is amazing. And let's not forget that in Townsend, you were the president as well, two times. So a total of six times as president. You are a remarkable person, Sonia. Amazing. Thank you.

SPEAKER_43 1:03:40

Excuse me real quick. Hold on. Hey, let's have some decorum. We're doing something here. Let's have some honor and dignity and respect. Can we do that? Let's do what's right here. Let's continue.

SPEAKER_40 1:04:04

Let them expose themselves. I've let them do that from day one.

SPEAKER_42 1:04:13

Yeah, not only I like Sonia being a mother and also being on this school board serving our children, But she represented a mother in our school district. A one mother. And look at what she has done. And can you raise your hand if you're a mother? Could you? Yes. This is what we have. This is what makes our Chino Valley Unified unique and strong. We said, no, we will not be LA Unified or Pomona Unified. And with common sense, we have our faith, our family, our friends are not for sale. not even for $10 million they have spent against Sonia Shah. Just a beginning. This is just a beginning. This was one mother from crowd of many. And while she was serving, she raised her two beautiful daughters well. And oh boy, her husband, he's a keeper. This is how we're going to live, the Chino way, and hopefully, will bring back whole California back to order again. Thank you.

SPEAKER_29 1:06:41

Mrs. Shaw, four years we've been together. Four years. Sorry about that, Chris. Four years, and every Wednesday we were together. And I don't think people know that, that we met constantly on Wednesdays. And we spent a lot of time together. And we've had a lot of conversations, a lot of conversations. I won't go into all of it but a lot of battles together and going back and forth with one another. And I appreciate the passion that you bring to this position. You served four years as a president of the board and I don't think people understand the commitment that it takes to be the board president. There is a lot of work that goes into that and you did you put a tremendous amount of work into this position as the board president and I saw that day in and day out and we were on the phone continuously through the four years. And again, I saw that dedication and that commitment that you have to this district and to your causes and everything that you work for. Extremely impressed with that. I will miss our time together because, again, when you spend that much time together and you work that close with one another, you see the passion, and I will miss that. The other part, when I look at Ms. Shaw, I look at... what you've done for me as a superintendent. You allowed me to do the work that I need to do as a superintendent, and I appreciate that.

SPEAKER_29 1:08:08

And so, again, I want to thank you for everything you did, and congratulations. Thank you.

SPEAKER_57 1:08:20

Am I supposed to say something? Yes, you are.

SPEAKER_40 1:08:23

I just want to thank first and foremost God and my family. I brought a picture tonight to show my reason, but they're standing right here. This is my reason. This is why I do what I do. I'm not giving up or giving in. This was my assignment for four years. I know everybody's asking where I'm going and only God knows because I give them my yes and I beg them every day throw me back in the fire Lord because I am ready to continue to serve not only Chino Valley but California in some sense to protect his most precious children. To you Dr. Enfield, I give you credit. I don't think you ever saw someone like me coming your way. And we did have a lot of fun, a lot of tears, a lot of friction, but that's where I wanted to see your passion. As a mother, when I stood over here, I only knew you as somebody who I thought was bad like the rest of the ones that we were trying to get rid of. And I sat with you, and while everybody was pressuring us to get rid of you, I saw a heart that served students when you first spoke to my daughter. And I said, To Brooke, we had these back and forth. Brooke said, Mom, he's not a bad man. He's really not a bad man. He has a big heart. And I listened to my own child, and I sat with you, and I said, show me your heart.

SPEAKER_40 1:09:44

When you would get mad at certain things, I loved it because I saw the fire in you that I needed to make sure that went all throughout our district without any roadblocks. And that's why our district is shining compared to other districts, because you have an amazing staff. We have a leader. It's not perfect, but no family is perfect. I will. I told you guys, if you're on the right side of history, I will stand in front of every single sling and arrow that comes any of your way. But if you're on the wrong side of history, you already know where I'm going to be and it's not going to be pretty. But with that said, I'm grateful. I don't regret a day. My family has been my rock. When I missed a game, these most beautiful, precious daughters were sending me Bible verses and telling me, mom, go save kids that don't have the ability to have somebody to protect them. And that meant the world to me. My husband. When the first death threat came in, there have been multiple. We have the best police department and the greatest security here, by the way. But when the first one came in, I'm telling you right now, he said, woman, who do you serve? And I said, God. And he said, where's your armor? Put it on and let's get fighting. Fighting the good fight every day. To our moms, the great teachers in our district that we united when you were...

SPEAKER_40 1:11:06

ditched by your own union back seven years ago. It's because of you that we made the difference. It's because of you, not because of me. I just was the one willing to say you're not gonna touch the people that are on the right side of history on my watch. But it's because of you that we were able to make history. We have people all throughout the nation watching what the step is in Chino Valley and thank you all, including those of you who have stepped up in other positions and supported people in other positions. If you're on the right side of history, we've already won. So I want to tell you, keep putting on that armor. Keep serving Almighty God. I cannot wait to get in front of him kneeling, begging him, don't be mad at me because I am hoping and praying every day he sends me in to wherever he has to send me because I am not done. That fire in my heart, when I asked him to break my heart for what breaks his, it is burning like you have no clue. And I'm going to make sure that he's able to use it in any way. I love you guys and thank you. And we got business to complete, so let's get to it. Thank you so much. Okay, Dr. Enfield broke his deal with me. We always said no surprises, and that wasn't on the agenda. I'm just kidding, I'm not gonna get you in trouble.

SPEAKER_40 1:13:02

Okay, our student board member, Malia, is unable to join us this evening as she is attending her annual ASB field trip, which is also her final one, so we wish her a wonderful experience, and can we give her a round of applause? And then we're now up to comments from employee representatives. From my understanding, do we have anybody from ACT? No. And Danny Hernandez already called me. He wishes you well. I'm not sure if he was able to get in through you, but he's not here because he has a home emergency. And then do we have, from CHAMP, Dr. Annette Hatch? No? OK. We're now on to public comments. Reagan, how many requests to speak?

SPEAKER_44 1:13:54

65. OK.

SPEAKER_40 1:13:59

Okay, so because we have 65, we will hear them all, unless obviously it gets rowdy or crazy and then we have to shut the meeting down. Each person will get one minute, so just prepare if you need to while I go through all the formal stuff. Board By-law 9323, meeting conduct establishes public comment guidelines and the following process applies. SPEAKERS WILL BE CALLED IN THE ORDER YOU REGISTERED ON THE ELECTRONIC REQUEST TO SPEAK DEVICE. NAMES ARE DISPLAYED ON MONITORS. PLEASE WATCH FOR YOUR NAME TO APPEAR AND LINE UP AT THE DESIGNATED NUMBERS ONE THROUGH TWO BEHIND THE MIC. IF YOU SEE ON THE FLOOR THERE'S ACTUALLY NUMBERS ON THE FLOOR. SO PLEASE LINE UP IN ORDER TO HEAR EVERYBODY. WE JUST NEED TO MAKE IT EFFICIENT. AND I SAID ONCE THE RECORDING SECRETARY ANNOUNCES THE FIRST NAME REQUEST TO SPEAK WILL NO LONGER BE ACCEPTED. ADDITIONALLY GOVERNMENT CODE 54957.9 authorizes removal of an individual or group when a meeting is willfully interrupted and order cannot be restored. Further, Penal Code 403 states, in part, every person who without authority of law willfully disturbs or breaks up any lawful assembly or meeting not unlawful in its character is guilty of a misdemeanor. Please make record of that. Mr. Cruz.

SPEAKER_48 1:15:20

Speakers, you have up to one minute to address the board. You cannot donate your time. One person at the mic at a time. If you read on behalf on an absent person, that will be considered your time. Begin comments when the clock starts. The clock begins when the secretary announces your name. Please refer to board policy 1312.1 for the procedure regarding complaints against an employee. And lastly, speakers may not approach the dais any time the board is in session. Please give any materials you wish distributed to the board to the recording secretary.

SPEAKER_46 1:15:54

Heather Poundstone on a non-agenda item.

SPEAKER_57 1:15:58

I'm so excited to be first. I'm so proud of you, Sonia. More importantly, God is so proud of you. What you have accomplished these last six years is truly remarkable. Nothing you've done has been wasted. The seeds you've planted will continue to grow in the years to come. As someone who's worked in education reform for 27 years, you're truly an answer to prayer. I'm grateful we've become friends to fight to save our children. Your best days are ahead. God has great things in store for you, and he truly works all things for good for those who love him. Keep seeking him and never back down. There are more. for you than there are against you. I love you so much and will continually pray for you.

SPEAKER_46 1:16:48

Chris Dalyer on a non-agenda item. Chris Dalyer on a non-agenda item. Sarah Stevens on a non-agenda item.

SPEAKER_13 1:17:07

Hi, everyone. My name is Sarah Stevens. I'm the wife of a veteran, and my husband's also a pastor. And I'm a mom of six kids. Their names are Joshua, Liberty, Justice, Glory, Honor, and America. And the reason why I'm here today is because, number one, I love Sonia Shah. I love everything that your school board has done. And I am asking you guys today, I know that Sonia has something proposed. so that you guys could vote so that we can keep boys out of girls sports. And as you heard me as a mother of six, my oldest son is 17 years old, six foot four and a half, plays basketball and is also on an adult league. I can't even imagine him playing against a girl. So my request for you is to as you have already led the fight for the children here in California for you guys to continue.

SPEAKER_46 1:18:08

Ebi Uluri on a non-agenda item. Ebi Uluri on a non-agenda item. Krista Zay Payne on a non-agenda item. Maria Carrillo on the non-agenda item.

SPEAKER_30 1:18:50

Hello? No? OK. Sonia, Sonia, today a chapter is closed of the exposure of everything that was going on in California and all over our lovely country. Sonia, you understood the assignment and this board, this beautiful board as well. You didn't lose, but you won. Thank you for everything you've done. You've been one of the warriors that I've followed and that has empowered me to stand against everything. And I wanna end with this verse. The wrath of God is revealed from heaven for all godlessness and wickedness. Those people know now what's going on. However, God gave them over to their sinful desires. Like you said, this is only the beginning. The reflection of the blue was only the hearts that were away from people here in California. But the remnant, just like you, Sonia, we're going to keep pushing and we're going to keep standing.

SPEAKER_40 1:20:01

Before we continue, one second. Before we continue, he starts the clock as the next person comes in so we can hear everybody. And we just ask that you please line up. We have Grateful Parent right now. Maria and Manu, can you please line up on one and two? That way you're getting your full minute. I just want you to understand that's the way that it works. And we don't want you to miss out. So please, please, it's really simple. Just line up.

SPEAKER_55 1:20:31

Hello, I'm a grateful parent. I just came up because I wanted to thank the board for everything they do. I appreciate the common sense and common decency of protecting our children. I want to congratulate the changing of the guard. I know that there's going to be some new board members and I hope that they can do as great as you guys have done. I never know what I'm going to say, but I know that I came here about a year ago as a result of some blasphemy that was going on online and when I showed up, I fell in love and I realized what a need there is and just the statement that you guys have made and the movement that it's caused and it's to my understanding that Chino Valley Unified School District is like 21st in the nation and that's behind all the rich districts and I think you guys kick butt and I appreciate you guys and everything

SPEAKER_46 1:21:36

Maria, you have an action item.

SPEAKER_30 1:21:39

This is for the action item. Thank you for going out with a bang. You are a warrior. Some people give up because we think of earthly things that, you know, we want to win here in this earth but our treasures are in heaven i am looking forward for those jewels in your crown like my shirt says well done warrior and so i um asked the board that we pass this today and we walk out of here shining jesus light look on an action item followed by sean k

SPEAKER_06 1:22:22

Hello, Board, President Shaw, thank you very much for all you have done. I met you in 2023. You were shining, glowing then. You stopped Tony Thurmond dead in his tracks when you said, not in this house. God bless you. I know he said this is not LAUSD. Please, please, please, please come to LAUSD. We need you. The biggest demon is LAUSD. If you cut the head, everybody will follow. Please come save LAUSD. God bless you. God bless your family, the beautiful daughters you have. And you are an inspiration to all our children. They look up to you. They have to be strong and as devoted to God as you are. And God bless you. Thank you very much.

SPEAKER_46 1:23:10

Shantae on an action item, followed by Victor.

SPEAKER_20 1:23:14

Well, since this is a school board, let's have a civics lesson. One of the original purposes of separating church and state was to protect religious freedom. First Amendment, 1791. Board, thank you for your leadership in protecting female athletes' safety and federal Title IX rights to fair competition and opportunities. May all school districts follow suit. Sonia, I deeply admire your willingness to stand firm, always at the forefront. Your determination, despite tremendous opposition, is something I'm profoundly grateful for. Your strength inspires me, your conviction commands my deepest respect, and your devotion to protecting California's children has left an indelible mark on this state and in my heart. Your faithfulness is not measured by the approval of this world, but in the eyes of the one you serve, Jesus Christ. Well done, good and faithful servant. We love you.

SPEAKER_46 1:24:04

Victor, on an action item, followed by Jose Carrillo.

SPEAKER_05 1:24:13

I would like to express my support of Board President Sonia Shah's new policy and administrative regulation, 5145.72, fairness in girls' athletics and privacy in sex-based facilities, along with the consequential alignment of existing district policies and regulations. This policy places biological sex as paramount The accommodations for open and co-ed team availability places rest to those desiring such. Plain and simple, thank you school board for taking the time to return Title IX to who it is intended to serve, the interests of the female athlete. I look forward to your affirmative vote for this new policy and regulation. Lastly, and certainly not least, I would like to thank Board President Sonia Shah and her family for the sacrifice made to bring the- Jose Carrillo on a non-agenda item and an action item.

SPEAKER_46 1:25:16

Wow. Manu Gregorian.

SPEAKER_08 1:25:20

So non-agenda, so I just want to take this opportunity to personally thank Sonia Shaw on behalf of myself and my entire family for your bravery, Your husband, Chris, your lovely daughters, we thank you. We thank you from the bottom of our hearts for the extreme sacrifice you guys have endured throughout these years, these months, these days. Romans 12, 1 says, I beseech you, therefore, brethren, by the mercy of God, that you present yourself a living sacrifice, holy and acceptable to God, which is your reasonable service. And you have done that. Every word, Sonia, it's been an extreme sacrifice. Us regular Joe Schmoes have no idea what their family has gone through, but I just wanna thank you from the bottom of my heart. Thank you for everything you're doing for our daughters, for our girls, to protect them from these evil, evil laws that are being passed here in California. Thank you very much.

SPEAKER_46 1:26:18

Jose Carrillo on an action item.

SPEAKER_08 1:26:24

Okay, agenda item. So thank you board, we love you guys, we love your bravery, your tenacity, and despite the arrows and everything that's been brought in your guys' direction, you guys have stood firm, you guys have held the line, and we thank you for that. To anybody who thinks it's okay for a biological boy to enter a woman's locker room, restroom, or competitive sports, something is really wrong with your thought process. Anybody who thinks that, you should be ashamed of yourself. My name is Jose Carrillo, and I'll tell you that you guys are cowards. Fathers, stand up on the sidelines. When you see a boy enter the girl's... Field, stand up and say something. Stop it. You don't have to be physical. You can be verbal. Stop this. We need to stop this, guys. Everybody thinks this is over. This is not over. This is not a win for the bad side. This is a win for the good side. So God bless everybody.

SPEAKER_46 1:27:25

Manouk will go in on the non-objected item, followed by Price Henson.

SPEAKER_06 1:27:32

Good evening, my name is Manu Gregorian. I'm the co-founder for Leave Our Kids Alone organization. Honestly, anybody thinks that boys and men should be in women's spaces just because they think like that, they feel like that. something's wrong with their head okay left or right it doesn't matter if you believe that you shouldn't be taking any one of these seats you know this is not for you Sonya a lot of people might say a lot of bad or don't like you whatever just know that your name forever will be marked in the history as the greatest president of any school board passing all kinds of school notifications, protecting our children. There is a young lady I met outside. She's a brave young lady, she's gonna be here speaking today. I want all the girls to know, it's up to you to stop this madness. Take a stand, you're not alone. Men like me, real men, know what's in right and wrong.

SPEAKER_46 1:28:32

Bryce Henson on an action item followed by Virginia Lenteria.

SPEAKER_28 1:28:39

Good evening, everyone. I'm Bryce Henson. I am a retired US Marine and Navy seal, and in 2021, I came back from my eighth deployment to a country I did not recognize, and I found activist parents, teachers and administrators who wanted to talk to children about sex in the schools and input pornographic books. That's how I met all these great patriots behind me, and we formed the greatest parental rights movement in the country's history, the SoCal Parent Coalition. We were black, white, Asian, Latino, Muslim, Christian, gay, straight, all coming together saying unanimously, anyone who wants to hide things from us about our little children, they are no friends of ours. I will never forget the rest of my life, July 20th, 2023, Sonia Shaw, Andrew Cruz, James Na, and Jonathan Monroe voted in affirmative the parental notification that went national for nine school districts across the state for 175,000 children. Thank you for your service. I am happy to stand with you in this spiritual warfare. Thank you very much.

SPEAKER_46 1:29:38

Virginia Renteria on a non-agenda item, followed by Rose Hensel.

SPEAKER_24 1:29:45

Sonia, first of all, I want to thank you from the bottom of my heart. I know the fight that you've had, Lord. The Lord knows too, Lord. I pray for you every single day that I've met, since I met you. You're a brave warrior. People don't know exactly how bad you had it, how tough you had it. Here you are, a beautiful young woman. We got a man back here saying, oh, he threatened me. I mean, really, okay, if anyone knew the threats you got, they would wet their pants. They really would. You know, you have what a lot of men do not have is cajones.

SPEAKER_29 1:30:27

Cajones.

SPEAKER_24 1:30:31

Like the gentleman before me said, if you see a man, fathers, if you see a boy going out there to play with your daughters, step up, be the man. Of course, no violence, but you call them out.

SPEAKER_46 1:30:44

Bryce Henson on a non-agenda item followed by Brenda Lebsack.

SPEAKER_28 1:30:51

This is for the action item. I support this resolution. Men cannot be women. Coming from the military and combat arms, people like me and athletes should also know that women are born with different anatomical features, bone densities, lung capacity, wingspan, et cetera, et cetera. I want you guys to pass this resolution because we know it will be challenged. We know Gavin Newsom and the Democrats are going to try to come down on you. But we need you to once again demonstrate the courage, the tenacity, and the drive to lead with courage so that other leaders follow your example and that these state laws that are wrong are hopefully challenged in the Supreme Court. Thank you, Board, for your service. And thank you for that agenda item.

SPEAKER_46 1:31:47

Brenda Lebsack on a non-agenda item followed by Virginia Lenteria.

SPEAKER_35 1:31:52

I'm Brenda Lebsack, a school board member in Santa Ana Unified and a retired PE teacher who coached girls soccer and field hockey. Thank you President Sonia Shah and Chino Hills board members for your brave leadership. The policies you passed to honor Title IX in spite of state opposition should be applauded. Thank you for protecting girls sports spaces and for doing what's right rather than what's politically correct. The California Department of Education is forcing us to normalize 10 gender identities. The CDE defines non-binary as transgender, intersex, agender, genderqueer, genderfluid, two-spirit, bigender, pangender, gender non-conforming, or gender variant. The document is on my website, brenda4kids.com. The state normalizes all these gender choices in kindergarten books. No wonder we have a mental health crisis. President Shaw, you're my hero. Thank you for being the voice of sanity. Many school board members, such as myself and others, follow your lead. Thank you.

SPEAKER_46 1:32:51

Regent Eugenia, an action item followed by Ms. Strange.

SPEAKER_24 1:32:57

Hi. Regarding the agenda item, that is true, like I said earlier. Man, fathers, you need to step up. Mothers, you need to step up. Boys do not belong in girls' sports. It's mighty funny that nobody's fighting for a girl to go onto the boys' team. No girls are fighting to go inside the boys' restroom, but yet these men that have testicles are wanting to go into the girls' restrooms, the girls' locker rooms. What is wrong with that? That is purely demonic. We have a battle of good and evil. It's very evident. Chino Valley Unified School District got on the board. You were on Fox News, R. I can't even tell you how many people have said, wow, you got a good school board president. Yes, we do. And I know that God has something else better for you. And I feel that we are going to have a little battle this next year, but that's okay. Like you said, we're in the fight. God bless you.

SPEAKER_46 1:33:59

Ms. Strange, on an agenda item, followed by Sahara Madrona.

SPEAKER_37 1:34:04

My pronouns are save girls. And you've done that. You've done that time and time again. Thank you. Thank you, Sonia Shah, for all your energy, your time, your resources, and your wonderful, amazing family that put up with you. That's amazing. I'm so impressed. The words that you have helped, you've spoken, have convinced other school boards and gone nationally. I mean, look at Nebraska, Arizona, Colorado, and Washington. They're all banning boys in girls sports, and you are brave and giving so much of that insight and that energy, and we just love you to pieces. Thank you, thank you, thank you.

SPEAKER_46 1:34:54

Sahara Pujano on a non-agenda item, followed by Ms. Strange.

SPEAKER_00 1:35:00

Como ex-delegada de la Unión de Maestros de California, madre, inmigrante de México y maestra, estoy aquí para apoyar a la señora Shaw y a esta mesa directiva por tener la valentía de defender la verdad y por respetar los valores de las comunidades a las que sirven. Gracias por proponer pólizas que respetan los derechos de los padres, que protegen a los niños de contenido vulgar e inapropiado bajo la excusa de la inclusión, y por defender los deportes femeninos. Estamos con ustedes y esperamos que más distritos escolares en todo el país se sientan inspirados por su valiente postura en favor de la integridad. As a former CTA state delegate, parent, immigrant from Mexico, and public school teacher, I am here tonight to applaud Ms. Sonia Shah and this board for having the courage.

SPEAKER_46 1:36:02

Ms. Strange on an action item followed by Ernie Harari.

SPEAKER_37 1:36:12

A vote for this resolution will help prevent bullying, harassment, and keeps all kids safer. Chino Valley Unified and all school districts must truly prioritize every single student's safety while they also work with Title IX federal laws for girls, to protect girls. Your resolution will keep competition fair, creates more safety, and offers a privacy option for anyone who chooses it, no questions asked. And as a former spokesperson for Gays Against Groomers and chair of Taxpayers Oversight for Parents and Students, we cheer this board on to keep girls safe and all of your students safe. Thank you.

SPEAKER_46 1:37:03

Eleni Morales on the non-adjective item followed by Patty Steen.

SPEAKER_31 1:37:12

Good evening to all. I am a high school student athlete from the Santa Ana Unified School District, and I am honored here today to recognize and show my appreciation for the remarkable community leader, Sonia Shaw. I had a script, but it's coming from the heart. I didn't... I met you when times were hard and I was facing the challenges, starting as a speaker for us in women's sports. And I asked God, give me a sign to tell me and show me that what I'm doing is right and I'm where I'm supposed to be. Give me an example. and you came up. Miss Sonia Shaw, you were there for the beginning and I can't wait to look up to you and see where you've gotten with God's paths and for helping us young women athletes. And I'm proud to say that I look up to you and I'm thankful for all you've done for us females and for us young girls fighting the battle. So thank you.

SPEAKER_46 1:38:09

Patty C on an action item followed by Pandy Olson.

SPEAKER_26 1:38:18

Les quiero dar las gracias por pensando de las niñas. Mucha gente dice que ustedes son racistas, pero en realidad ustedes están protegiendo a las niñas que vienen llorando. Ellas les vienen llorando diciéndole que les dejen sus espacios para que los niños no se entren con ellas. Y eso es la realidad que mucha gente no quiere, todavía no quiere decir que es verdad. Pero ustedes se han parado atrás de las niñas. disculpe por lo que estan haciendo ustedes aqui otras escuelas por todo el estado de california y por todo el país de los estados unidos la gente esta oyendo y ojala ellos van a hacer lo que estan haciendo ustedes hoy para pasar reglas que las niñas van a estar protegidas que ellas no van a tener que venir aqui a llorar les a ustedes que no se quieren

SPEAKER_46 1:39:19

Candy Olson on an action item followed by Oscar.

SPEAKER_03 1:39:28

Hello my name is Candy Olson I'm a board member in Redlands Unified and I am here to with my Redlands crew and we support I support this policy very much because I think that we all should be following Title 9 protecting our girls and their spaces, their privacy, and their sports. And I want to commend not just Sonia Shaw, but all of you board, because it takes an entire board with strength. And you guys have done remarkable things that I could only wish and dream to do of with a board. All of you are to be commended. And I appreciate each and every one of you, and especially my dear friend Sonia Shaw. You are a local legend. Thank you.

SPEAKER_46 1:40:11

Oscar, on an action item, followed by Darlene Herb.

SPEAKER_07 1:40:19

Hello, Board President, Board. I'm a yes, I'm a yes with action item 2A1, because boys are different. You know, growing up, we never had these issues. We never had boys in the girls' locker rooms. If they caught them in there, they'd get arrested, and then they'd be arrested and suspended for life. So we've got grown boys who are almost adults, and they're going into the girls' restrooms, and they're peeping Toms and doing all this weird stuff, and they're getting away with it. It's not normal. So we've got to get back to being a normal society. And for the men here that are not supporting your women, this movement started by women. and I'll get into it in the next one, but we need men to stand up and protect their daughters. I'm a father of seven girls, seven daughters, right? So I learned a long time ago, very long time ago, that I had to be that strong person for my daughters. God bless you.

SPEAKER_33 1:41:14

Darlene Berg on an action item, followed by Patty C. I'm here to protect the young people that you forgot that you're here to protect as well. In the policy fairness in girls athletics under eligibility for girls letter B, You're dangerously close, everybody should read this, to forcing girls to prove during their pre-participation physical that they are cis girls. Be very careful with that. But I would like to say thank you, Sonia, thank you. Students organized, they rejected attacks on LGBTQ plus students, whitewashing history, and this board silence on ICE. You mobilized an entire generation of students who helped vote you out. You wanted to silence educators and said you empowered students. You muted our microphones, but you could not mute an entire community. All children deserve love, compassion, and protection. Thank you.

SPEAKER_46 1:42:13

Party C on a non-agenda item, followed by Oscar.

SPEAKER_26 1:42:23

I want to thank Ms. Shaw for being a woman who It is because women, thank you, Sonia, for being such a good person.

SPEAKER_27 1:42:49

Thank you for being a leader and having so many parents standing at these board meetings. It has been because of your leadership that California has started standing up for their children. It has been through your example that the United States started standing up for their children because of a person like you, a mother that they thought they could silence because you are a mother. Thank you for standing up for biological women. Because you know the difference.

SPEAKER_46 1:43:24

Oscar, on a non-agenda item, followed by Tom Smith.

SPEAKER_07 1:43:32

all right um remember when i first met you sonia i was during the lockdowns during the pandemic right and i was watching youtube and i seen all these ladies and one white guy he's somewhere back here right speaking to the board and the board was ignoring them we had a bunch of male a bunch of leftist cowards that were on the board and they were ignoring you making fun of you and i said you know what i got daughters i go i'm gonna so i showed up the next time and the next minute i showed up one of the girls said you want to join our club or a team i said I don't want to join no damn club, you know? But I started showing up, and I said, you know what? I go, these women are doing something. Like I said, the women are the ones that woke up. You woke up the mama bears. And guess what? Mama bears, when you mess with their cubs, they'll never give up. They'll never give up, right? So this is not over. This is just the beginning. God bless you. I love you. Keep on doing it.

SPEAKER_46 1:44:20

Tom Smith on an action item, followed by Greg Abduk.

SPEAKER_02 1:44:26

Good evening. My name is Tom Smith. I've lived in the district for 13 years. I have three grandchildren also in the district, 18, 16, and 12. They've all grown up in the school district. And I feel like they've had a very good education through the various schools that they've attended in the district. My issue tonight is more one of procedure. I really feel that this important policy that is going to guide the district in the future needs to be deliberated upon by the incoming board members as well as the continuing board members of this board. So I would urge you to, in your discussions tonight, seriously consider continuing this item until the new board members are seated in January and there can be a full discussion of the new board about this important policy going forward. Thank you.

SPEAKER_46 1:45:19

Greg Abdoche on an action item followed by Sophia Curry.

SPEAKER_17 1:45:26

Hello board, my name is Greg Abdoche. I'm formerly a candidate of the 45th Assembly District in the state of California, and proudly I'm your brother. Sonya, I've been thinking about this moment for five days now, and who else on their last night would bring a policy like this forward? I commend you, and not just you, but the entire board, because it's taken some serious backbone to stand up to the state of California and Gavin Newsom and all of his cronies in Sacramento. There's nothing more we can say, Sonia, than thank you. And I will always stand by your side. God bless you. God bless this board.

SPEAKER_46 1:46:13

Sophia Lurie on an action item followed by Greg Abduke.

SPEAKER_18 1:46:19

Hello board and hello President Shaw. I just want to say I'm so thankful and grateful for this action item. My name is Sophia Laurie. I was a former collegiate athlete and a four year varsity CIF athlete. I know what it means for girls to have the ability to play fair and safe sports, for them to be able to live out their dreams, get college scholarships because of sports. California is ruining that. Boys do not belong in girls' sports. Boys and girls are different. That's incredibly clear. This whole idea that trans girls are girls is not true. Trans girls are boys. And it's actually harmful to tell the boys that they can be girls and girls that they can be boys. That is the most harmful thing you can do to children. So, Sonia, thank you for, again, on your last night, you could just have gone out, but you're going out with a bang. And thank you for standing up for girls' sports endlessly, standing up for the children, and doing the most loving thing you can do by telling boys that they were not made in the wrong body and girls that they were not made in the wrong body. We must protect girls' sports, and I'm grateful that it started here.

SPEAKER_46 1:47:17

Rope of Dutch and non-Jet item, followed by Christine Hurst.

SPEAKER_17 1:47:27

Seven years ago, I started a parent organization. I sat here in Chino Valley School Board right behind you the first night, looked at your amazing husband, and said, don't worry, I'll walk her out to her car. He goes, I'm not worried about her. I'm worried about everybody else around. You've handled this position with poise. You've never backed down, no matter who came against you. You've always stood for right. You've glorified our father more than any board member I've ever seen. You've paved the way. You should be proud. This is your fruit. And I can't wait to see what's next. We all love you, Sonia. Thank you so much.

SPEAKER_46 1:48:08

Christy Hurst on an action item followed by Sophia Lurie.

SPEAKER_36 1:48:13

Board members Cervantes, Non, Cruz, Dr. Enfield, and Dr. Park, I want to remind you again, it is outside of your power to set policies such as this. Your job is to follow all laws and ed codes. The state's job is to enforce. This policy is illegal and will result in more of our tax dollars being wasted. Today, Attorney General Rob Bonta sent you a letter stating this policy is in direct violation of California law. The letter also explained that your interpretation of SCOTUS decisions are misapplied here. This policy will harm queer kids and cis girls and result in the policing of the femininity of girls. Currently, our district has no known transgender athletes, meaning the sports policy will only be applied to cis girls. The policy allows for anyone to file a complaint regarding You'd kick me out for that. Sports facility usage. It says any concern and doesn't limit to who can raise one. And what are these complaints based on then? Appearance and ability, which, as I have seen in other states, leads to policing of girls.

SPEAKER_46 1:49:15

Sophia, Lori, and followed by Lisa.

SPEAKER_40 1:49:30

Please follow the list on the board. Sophia was up next, but it disappeared. I don't know where the names are going. Can we have it? You good?

SPEAKER_37 1:49:40

I don't know where they're going.

SPEAKER_18 1:49:47

Hello? OK. Just to clarify something real quick, this policy is not illegal. A little history lesson. Title IX is federal law that supersedes state law. What the state of California is doing is actually illegal. So I'm glad we got that history lesson in as well as separation of church and state was to protect the church from the state. Anyways, Sonia, my sister in Christ, I love you so much. You have not just changed this community, you've changed the nation from your parental notification policy to what you're doing for girls sports to then getting death threats. Most people would have backed out and said, you know what, no, I gotta stop. And you said, you know what, I'm gonna stand up for every single child in my community, in my state and across this nation. If every school board did what you did, this state would be a better state. And because of you, dozens upon dozens of people have now ran for school board across California.

SPEAKER_46 1:50:45

Lisa G, on a non-agent item, followed by Christy Hurst.

SPEAKER_10 1:50:51

Next month, two new board members will take their seats and swear an oath to uphold our state and US constitutions. The three remaining members might want to listen closely, because all five of you have repeatedly violated that oath. And tonight, it looks like you'll do it again by adopting a policy that violates state law and conflicts with a recent Supreme Court decision. That means another costly lawsuit for taxpayers, adding to the $4 million in legal fees you've already cost this district in four years. And this comes just two weeks after voters rejected your use of district resources to advance political agendas, spread misinformation, target marginalized students, and attack the teachers who support them. Imagine what you could have accomplished if even a fraction of that time, energy, and money had gone toward real problems, like fixing our broken special education program. You could have made a meaningful difference in hundreds of students' lives.

SPEAKER_46 1:51:52

Christy Hurst on consent item, non-agenda item, followed by Yee, students.

SPEAKER_40 1:52:00

I just have one moment. Hold on, Christy. I've been letting the claps and the applause, the positive stuff. The negative stuff, please just hold it to yourself. I know people have emotions, but I just ask that you be respectful on both sides. And then when you leave the room, I'm not in charge of you anymore.

SPEAKER_36 1:52:21

Tonight, you are approving $45,000 more in legal fees, bringing the total for two to three months to $205,000. You are tonight voting on another policy that will result in even more legal fees. Board members Cervantes, Nas, and Cruz, this community has very clearly sent a message we are tired of our tax dollars being wasted on lawsuits, lawsuits that are a result of you breaking laws. Sonia lost her race by 2 million votes, not even coming close to Richard Barrera. Sean Smith and Chris Shaw experienced similar losses. All three of them ran on this issue, and they still lost by wide margins. Almost all of the people cheering for you in this room tonight do not live here. They are not your voters. This community does not support your agenda. we want our tax dollars to be spent in our classrooms we want the focus on learning and student outcomes this is not your money it is ours again these people telling you to break the law do not live here it is not their money it doesn't matter what they're saying this community does not want this and that is clear 2028 is coming and i can promise you you will have all the blame for the wasted tax dollars and legal fees starting now

SPEAKER_46 1:53:29

Christy Hurst on a non-agenda item, followed by Lee Eubanks.

SPEAKER_40 1:53:35

Reagan, Reagan, Reagan, one second. Wasn't somebody else before? Is that the right order? Names keep disappearing. But before, I'm going to actually do a point of information. I love point of information. It used to be used all the time. But I'm going to tell you something. The teachers union is the problem. They're the ones that sued us over and over. And for all of those that want to rub in our face the cost of these lawsuits, stop suing us for being on the right side of history. I'll give you a little bit of how much it costs. This is the best part. The union has sued us in perv. Kangaroo courts with dishonorable, if you wanna disrupt, go outside, scream. We know the rules.

SPEAKER_27 1:54:17

I already read the code.

SPEAKER_40 1:54:19

You will get arrested. You think you're gonna overpower me being the board president? Get out. That's a warning right there, number one. I know how to run meetings and I know how to handle the circus clearly. So this isn't my first rodeo, thank you. Now let's go back to this. Cost of attorney fees just on PERB cases from the union that sues us in PERB. Go look it up. Administrative law, judges. Guess what? Some of those judges are actually husbands and wives of CTA members. Wow, guys. Let me just tell you, they unleashed something that they've never seen because I was once a free, not a free agent, and now I'm a free agent. Oh, you better believe. You ask me what I'm doing next, I'm gonna expose the unions and it starts here in Chino Valley. And I'm gonna make sure every single teacher knows that if they're giving dues, They are responsible for the harm being done on these kids because PIRB, here's the numbers, just with the PIRB cases suing us on parental notification, flag policy, and now we just got another one that's going to continue the lawsuits with our boys and girls sports one, $627,439. Thank you, union, for spending the money that could have been used on our students. I'm going to continue to expose what you've done to our children while rubbing it in our faces that we wasted the money, you wasted the money. You did it.

SPEAKER_40 1:55:44

You took it away from our children, and you're going to wear it. And on top of that, the state of California, you need to be quiet. That's your second warning. You've actually done four, so leave. You're going to leave now. Go. Go. Blue hat, you're done. You've done four. I've been super nice tonight. Go leave. I've read the ed code. I have the police here. You're more than welcome to leave now or I'll shut down the meeting and escort everybody out. I read the codes. I know my rights. I know how to protect our district. Leave now. And the rest of the audience, let him deal with it. Let security. You're going to leave now.

SPEAKER_43 1:56:23

The one with the blue hat. Yep.

SPEAKER_40 1:56:28

We're not continuing until you leave. The rest will have to leave and then there's no comments. You wouldn't want the rest to not give their comments on abuse. Bye. You're out of order. I don't think what you realize you're going to do, you're not going to let the others that want to come say bad stuff about me to say it. I want to hear them. So let them speak. You're actually going to shut them down because I'll escort the whole meeting. So back to the other fees. The other fees, because our district is responsible and we are grateful that Liberty Justice and other pro bono attorneys had given us the opportunity to protect us, those fees came from the state of California. Can you stop clapping now? That's all of your guys' warning. I see it right here, red shirt. That's the second warning. Now escort yourself out. That one, escort yourself out. You can leave now. It's time to go. And the guy in the glasses right there. Nope. The guy in the glove, right there, leaving. He needs to go. That one, he's going.

UNKNOWN 1:58:21

Yeah.

SPEAKER_40 1:58:39

OK, do you guys all want to go outside in the cold? Can we just bring it back to order? Or I will get rid of everybody in the room now. So let's just bring it back. I said what I said. The union sued us. The state sued us. They wasted your taxpayer dollars. I will continue to expose them and stand on the right side. And I'm praying these guys do too. So let's continue that. But you're not going to get to be telling all these lies without a point of information. So there you go.

SPEAKER_36 1:59:11

Okay, well, clearly I triggered you bringing up how bad you lost, so... Clearly, clearly. I want to congratulate Frank and Megan and this community. Chino Valley has turned a corner. We are taking this district back. And also, thank you for the circus you just caused, because it was an exact reminder of exactly why you and your husband and Sean lost. We are tired of this chaos, and you are turning this district into a circus. Almost every supporter you have speaking tonight does not live here. i counted three three who live here speaking in support during these board comment time and i think i want to end by like just celebrating for a second and cheering that this is the last time we have to have this woman up on our dais

SPEAKER_34 2:00:10

Hi, my name is Ceu banks. I'm a civilian handicap students in this district and I want to thank you guys for helping me to resolve the issues about the community-based instruction and I want to also tell you that this board has done an outstanding job because we this I've been working here for over 20 years and this is the smoothest negotiation I have ever seen since you guys took over there's been a lot of them Also another thing is that I'm very grateful that the SH teachers will get both either prep and conference or be compensated. I have been fighting for that for many many years since I've been in this district and it took you guys to make it happen. So I want to thank you very much. Lastly as an army veteran as a second generation immigrant and as a daughter of a mushroom farmer as a special ed teacher and as a parent whose kids went through this district. Thank you for fighting the good fight for parents rights for girls fights and for and to continue to good

SPEAKER_46 2:01:13

Matthew Ward on a non-agenda item followed by Raida Hernandez.

SPEAKER_04 2:01:17

Good evening. Good evening. My name is Matthew Ward, and I'm a Gault Elementary School District trustee. And actually, I drove seven hours down here to be here tonight on this historic night because I wanted to be part of history. And I wanted to let you guys know that I actually super respect this board so much that I actually nominated you for, guys, the CSBA Golden Gavel Award back in June. So I hope you guys get it in December, because you guys earned it, because you guys have a backbone. In fact, Greg used the word backbone earlier. That's what I was going to say. When I look at this board, I see people that have a backbone that know right from wrong and are willing to stand up and do the right things, even when you know you're going to get scrutiny for doing it. So I appreciate what you guys have done. You guys are awesome. I'm glad to be here with you guys. And Sonia Shaw, man, you have just motivated so many people. What you've done is awesome. And there's people that will be on the school board for 20 years and their name will never be remembered. You've been on the school board for four years. The world knows your name. And you know what? You've made, there's so many people here that ran for school board. There's so many people that have been motivated by you. You guys are a big, or the reason I ran for school board is because of a PragerU episode that she was.

SPEAKER_46 2:02:19

Loretta Fernandez on an action item followed by Annette Hibner.

SPEAKER_11 2:02:27

Hi good evening. I am Nereida Hernandez and unlike the people you invited that are outsiders to perform for you I'm here to talk about real life people's experiences. As you attend your final board meeting as the president of the Chino Valley District it is deeply disappointing that one of your final policy initiatives is once again directed at excluding transgender students. Following your unsuccessful campaign for California State Superintendent of Public Instruction, the timing of this proposed policy raises legitimate concerns as to whether it serves as educational purpose or represents an act of political retaliation against a vulnerable student population. You have devoted considerable time, attention, and public resources to targeting a population that represents a very small percentage of California students. Being elected to public office does not authorize an individual to disregard applicable laws or substitute personal, political, or religious beliefs for the legal obligations of a public institution.

SPEAKER_46 2:03:29

Annette Agnew on an action item followed by Nerida Hernandez.

SPEAKER_22 2:03:35

Hi good evening and thank you for allowing us to speak on both sides. It really is important that we all get a chance to speak with dignity and to just stand up for what we believe in. So first and foremost I want to say thank you to this board because I have not seen such a courageous board and I've been to several school district meetings so you guys are amazing. Secondly Sonia for even what you have said here tonight I want to point out that you are a modern day Deborah.

SPEAKER_11 2:04:07

My time should start over.

SPEAKER_15 2:04:10

Yes, we are in kindergarten.

SPEAKER_40 2:04:32

Guys, do we really want to take a 10-minute break and go out in the cold? I called. She's speaking, and now we're going to have to restart her time. Okay. She said she didn't touch you. You're saying you touched. There's police officers. File a report if you need to. You can have another seat. This is a public meeting. Let's go.

SPEAKER_22 2:05:05

That's okay, I only need what I have left anyway. We're good. Okay, we on? Okay, so what is a modern day Deborah? It's a woman who courageously steps into leadership in spaces where she's not expected. Someone who speaks with truth and authority, including directing men what to do and saying what is right. A protector and advocate for her community standing in the gap for the vulnerable. A decision maker who is decisive, who doesn't defer when action is needed.

SPEAKER_46 2:05:39

Norita Hernandez followed by Chris Shaw.

SPEAKER_11 2:05:47

Non-agenda item. Leadership is not measured by how successfully you exclude a minority population. It is measured how effectively you serve everyone including those who live experiences that are different from yours. When you attempted to strip my daughter of the athletic placements she rightfully earned through the years of hard work dedication discipline and sacrifice you underestimated the mother who refused to remain silent. I made a promise to my baby. I promised her that I would stand beside her, that I would hold elected officials accountable, that your position on this board would come to an end, and that your campaign would not succeed. I walked out this meeting with my head held high because unlike you, we won.

SPEAKER_46 2:06:27

This shot is a non-agenda item followed by Crystal.

SPEAKER_56 2:06:47

Hi, Mom. I just want to say that I'm so deeply proud of you and everything that you do. Just seeing you always on the sideline and cheering me on is just like a blessing. And me running to you every single game and just hugging you because of how much support you give me. And as a woman athlete, Your haters don't even know what a difference between a boy and a girl is. So you don't need to listen to them. So you can just scoop on them, honestly. And I love you so much. And I just want to say, if you want to see the difference, you can come see. I'm a women college athlete. And you can literally see the difference between a men's game and a women's game. It's completely different. Come and support us if you want, honestly. And I love you so much. And thank you for everything that you do for me. Love you.

SPEAKER_46 2:07:37

Crystal on an honor item followed by Daisy Gardner.

SPEAKER_32 2:07:43

All right, tonight I just want to say, take a moment to tell you thank you, Sonia. Thank you for the last four years for everything you've poured into this community. You have impacted not only our community, but so many others all over the world. Thank you for being a voice for us parents, for standing up for our girls, protecting our children, and having the courage to fight when so many were trying to bring you down. Thank you for bringing common sense into conversations that seem to be missing it. And thank you for being brave enough to stand your ground, even when it meant standing against some big giants. I know this hasn't been easy, and I hope you know that your courage has not gone unnoticed. You may be wrapping up your time here on this board, but the impact you've made does not end tonight. And I know you're just getting started, and I cannot wait to see and support what you do next. And I live in the community and take my tax dollars to fight for our daughters. Thank you.

SPEAKER_46 2:08:31

Daisy Gardner on a non-agenda item, followed by Karen.

SPEAKER_51 2:08:36

I am here because three and a half years ago, an anti-LGBTQ hate group beat a man almost to death in front of an elementary school in my neighborhood in LA. A few weeks later, Sonia Shaw welcomed this group, called Leave Our Kids Alone, to Chino. Sonia then hit the road, organized with and traveled with the group as they hit school boards all over Southern California with the DOJ's bill assailee to promote a version of assailee's bill to forcibly out trans children. When forced outing was outlawed by the state, they switched to stalking and harassing individual trans athletes. The group includes and included Proud Boys, G-Sixers, ex-felons, gang members, and neo-Nazis. Sonya posed with that neo-Nazi and refused to apologize for doing so at an anti-abortion rally that called for the execution of pregnant women who have abortions. A documentary chronicling her extremist ties, as well as her ties to the dark money groups who back her, Mom's Club film airs this Sunday. I don't make any money.

SPEAKER_46 2:09:40

Karen on an action item followed by Crystal.

SPEAKER_52 2:09:47

On November 3rd, members of this community, including parents like me, handed this board a very clear directive. Stop with the culture war nonsense or lose your jobs. You claim that this privacy policy protects girls, despite the fact that there is no evidence that trans girls are a threat to any of their fellow classmates. But actually, last year, a school resource officer at my children's school in this district was arrested for lewd and lascivious acts with a minor on school property, and this board was silent. No one is claiming that we should ban officers from schools because we understand that the actions of one or two people cannot be extrapolated to an entire community. It is obvious to anyone paying attention that none of you actually care about protecting children. You care about stepping on their backs to further your own political ambitions. Mr. Cruz, Mr. Cervantes, and Mr. Na, take note. You have two choices. Change your course now, or come 2028, we'll replace you too.

SPEAKER_46 2:11:02

Pistol and our action item, followed by Daisy Gardner.

SPEAKER_32 2:11:10

All right. Well, I want to thank you for bringing this policy forward and ending your night here with a bang. Thank you for being willing to stand up for girls when so many people would want to stay silent. Protecting girls' sports, locker rooms, bathrooms, private spaces, this should not be a controversial issue. It's common sense. Our daughters deserve privacy, dignity, and the opportunity to compete in spaces designated for them. And it really blows my mind that this is something we are fighting for over and over again. And I want to tell you something else. Thank you, because bringing this forward, you also have brought to light something I think everybody needs to pay attention to. The cease and desist letter from our teachers union is very concerning, and I think parents need to be asking some serious questions about whose interests our union representatives are actually advocating for. We have incredible teachers here in this district, and they do deserve respect, but we also need to pay attention to which candidates the teachers unions choose to endorse.

SPEAKER_51 2:12:03

because these um this just shows us even more that the act and their can daisy gardner on an action item colored by lenny martin morales save girls sports is a national campaign it is co-led by focus on the family slash california family council These groups partner with, their partners are the Heritage Foundation, who are trying to overturn and dismantle girls' sports and undo Title IX in order to give the money to boys because girls' sports are, quote, unfeminine and ungodly. Look it up on their website. I hope that when the AG's office brings a lawsuit, they note the documented instances of animus towards the LGBT community by this board and Sonia. i urge them to check the sub stack this week in school board which will be updated so cal extremism watch skew um our school's inland valley instagram charty b kelly stewart sky spiders many videos of shaw cruz and nah speaking against the transgender community i hope they also note that sony eleni morales on an action item followed by brenda ledson

SPEAKER_31 2:13:21

Primero quiero agradecer a nuestro Señor y Salvador Jesucristo. First I want to thank our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ. Padre Santo, pido que los perdones a los confundidos y que les des amor. God, I ask for you to forgive those confused here and that you bless their hearts and that you show them your true path. I'm here not just on behalf of me and my sister, but on behalf of all women's sports. And they... I'm sorry, it's a little frustrating being here with round two over here, but I just like to make it clear that male, female, completely different. Biological differences are clear, and it's certain, in God's word, we're not one or the other. We're one or the other, I'm sorry, a little frustrated. But God.

SPEAKER_46 2:14:20

Brenda Levesack on an action item, followed by Bridget Antuna.

SPEAKER_35 2:14:28

I've been a public school teacher for 25 years. This kindergarten book in our school says you might feel like your gender changes from day to day or year to year. This kindergarten book says my pronouns can change like the weather, depending on how I feel. As a former state delegate of the teachers union, I am asking you to vote yes on the board policy to protect girls sports. This policy prevents the pseudoscience normalization of unlimited gender choices. Non-binary goes way beyond transgenderism. What if students identify as gender fluid? Does that mean they can fluctuate between boys and girls sports depending on how they feel that day? What if students identify as both genders? How will that work? It won't. That's why it's time to say enough is enough to Attorney General Rob Bonta and to CTA President David Goldberg. Enough is enough. We love you, Sonia Shah.

SPEAKER_19 2:15:23

Hi, Sonia Shah. It's good to see you again. Thank you. You're one of my heroes next to Karen England and many others that are up there. Rebecca Friedrich, you're awesome. Thank you. And you're speaking up for the next generation as well. My granddaughters, my three granddaughters. So thank you. it's good to see you john cervantes thank you board for all that you're doing and working together everybody's looking at chino valley i've been following you guys this is my first time here and i'm glad to be here to welcome you sonia shaw to whatever god has in store for you because it's a detour these people think that you're done that is this is your last night but it isn't it's a new beginning and only the called can see that is my time up God bless you, I love you. God bless your family.

SPEAKER_46 2:16:12

Mr. Wales, on the action item followed by Christine Collinsworth.

SPEAKER_41 2:16:17

Hey, strangers. Been a while. I don't think you need to figure out where I stand on this issue. For you mothers that decided to be bears, you became grizzly bears. For you dads that are standing behind me that I cannot turn around and address, if you wanna be grizzly bears, be Kodiaks. If somebody stands between you and your daughter, do something about it. Don't let her be harassed, don't let her be assaulted, don't let her be hurt. You've been sitting on your ass for years, letting your wives, letting their mothers fight for them. So lob this frag grenade as you leave, and let's see what happens. Keep boys out of girls' sports, or they're going to run into somebody.

SPEAKER_46 2:17:20

Christine Hollingsworth on a non-agenda item, followed by Chadwick.

SPEAKER_15 2:17:28

I just want to say thank you so much to Sonia Shaw and the rest of the board. Sonia, the first time I ever saw a video of you on social media, I just was blown away by that fire and that fire that we share. And I'm so glad I don't have to beg you to keep that fire because you've even said it tonight. It's burning. It's burning inside of you. And that's just you. And you are... you are someone that across the nation mothers like me you give us our vote you are our voice and i'm so proud of you and i just want to say thank you so much for everything you've done and that's all thank you jen jen an action item followed by dawn

SPEAKER_09 2:18:14

As a mother of a transgender daughter who just started her transition, I have to worry each and every day how the world is going to receive her. What I didn't think I would have to worry about is her own school district excluding her and villainizing her. Protect our daughters? My daughter is the one who needs protecting. All this talk about God and my daughter is a devout Catholic. And using religion in this form is nothing but a blatant, manipulative, and hypocritical tactic being used to push a hateful agenda. I ask you respectfully, be mindful. Do better.

SPEAKER_46 2:18:46

Don't have an action item? Will it by hand? You.

SPEAKER_01 2:18:53

$4 million in the last four years spent on legal fees, and all this policy does is expose our district to more costly legal fees. Public education isn't a matter for personal political agendas, because while you all may leave office and use this to make a message to the state, the ones who bear the true cost are the students, the taxpayers, and everyone within our district. The constituents have clearly spoken by the election turnouts on this board and in the nation that we're entering a new era of politics. One focused on putting money back into our politics, ensuring the safety of all students, and making education the central focus. I have love for everyone here, and thank you all.

SPEAKER_46 2:19:40

And a youth and an honor agenda item, followed by Tae-Win Yoo.

SPEAKER_12 2:19:47

Good evening, board. I think it's quite clear that Chino Valley has had enough of their tax dollars being wasted on harmful policies disguised as putting students first, while the district turns a blind eye to the many instances where students' safety has actually been risked. And yet, instead of just accepting this fact, you have proven for the last time that villainizing queer students for simply existing and censoring our curriculum is still your priority rather than our education. Cruz, Na, and Cervantes, I hope you all realize what these results mean for the remainder of your term as board members. These are the voices of community members who reject compliance with your hateful policies and have shown up to prove that the tides have changed for the future of CVUSD. Politics have no place in our academics, and neither does hatred. So you can choose to either listen to the students you're meant to represent, or face the consequences of ignoring us like you've all done for years. Because clearly, CVUC is ready for change. I hope this is the last time I have to be up here advocating the voices of my fellow students to grown adults who have failed us time and time again. Thank you.

SPEAKER_46 2:20:44

SPEAKER 1. On a non-agenda item, .

SPEAKER_50 2:20:52

I'm here tonight grateful that after today, two of the board members are not going to be here anymore. I want to thank the children that rose up. I guess the only positive thing about having you guys here is that you guys lit a fire under our students. And a lot of these students next year, they will be age available in order to continue to vote. And some of you are coming up for re-election. So I hope that as you go through this and you try to decide what vote you're going to be, I hope that you do realize that there's more of us than there is of you. And the results showed it. So I'm glad to have made it to the circus, too.

SPEAKER_46 2:21:32

We'll see you on an action item followed by Hannah Yu.

SPEAKER_12 2:21:36

I will be sharing concerns for this action item on behalf of a transgender student in the district. Quote, as a transgender student that attends school in the CVSD, I am constantly seeing the direct impact of Sonia's prioritization of her own political agenda instead of helping students. As an hourly transgender person who attends school, I am directly impacted by the hateful language from the students and school board. Using the restroom becomes scary in a debate when no one is being harmed. My pronouns and gender being constantly discussed when me being who I am is not the issue. Not funding our sports, arts, and education programs is the issue." Transgender youth already face so many obstacles in their day-to-day life. Therefore, implementing another anti-transgender policy that reduces them down to their biology and genetics at birth forces them into unsafe and inhumane environments rather than ensuring safety and privacy. You can't just pick and choose which students you want to include in your whole putting students first claim, Sonia, because transgender students deserve just as much respect as everyone else. Thank you.

SPEAKER_46 2:22:33

Please turn on a consent item.

SPEAKER_14 2:22:39

I want to address the proposed changes to the CVUSD's library book removal policy, particularly the removal of the public hearing requirement. Let's look at the actual books that are being affected by these decisions. Books like The Bluest Eyes by Tori Morrison explore the devastating effects of racism and the societal standards imposed on black girls. Books like The Poet X and Juliet Takes a Breath explores identity, culture, and LGBTQ plus experiences. Have you read any of these books? And I want to make something clear. I'm not talking exclusively about sexually explicit content. We are talking about books addressing racism, historical realities, cultural identities, discrimination, and the experiences of marginalized communities. You cannot reduce every book removal to an argument about explicit material when the literature being removed addresses so much more. Na, Cruz, and Cervantes, you are proposing to change the very policy that governs these decisions by supporting the removal of these public hearing requirements. Why should the

SPEAKER_46 2:23:39

David Bola on an action item.

SPEAKER_23 2:23:51

I want to thank President Schaaf for putting forth this agenda item to bring board policy 514572. I encourage the rest of the board to vote in the affirmative. There are laws now more than ever that are harmful and wrong. Education Code 221.5F is one of those, and it's blaringly obvious. The ideals that you can mix girls and boys in sleeping quarters, competitive sports, bathrooms, and changing rooms is ludicrous, harmful, and insult to society. The children of California, especially the girls, should never have been subjected to such insanity. At a minimum, students should never be punished for rejecting being put into impossible situations that will mostly result in harm to themselves. We all know this and will not go without a fight from the state. But this is a fight that must happen. It is righteous change that must happen. I know truth and justice will prevail. President Shah, what a way to leave this board with the most righteous policy to be passed. You have my support. Board, vote yes on policy.

SPEAKER_46 2:24:45

DAVID BOLLOCK and a non-agenda item.

SPEAKER_23 2:24:55

President Shah, the last four years have been an inspiration to parents, teachers, advocates, lawyers, and other school board members, not only here in California, but across the nation. Yourself, along with this board, has done a great deal of work advancing education for our youth, and most importantly, protecting these children from harmful influences. While you were on the campaign trail, I always like to brag about the fact that you were part of perfecting the parent notification policy to where the state, who loves to attack you, admitted and retreat that there's nothing they can do about the policy, a policy that can be legally duplicated without fear of the state tangling that board in illegal action. Letting parents know what is happening with their children is the utmost important and the minimum that a school district can do to maintain a healthy parent-child relationship. Thank you for your service President Shaw. Your presence at this board was a blessing and the work you did was well done faithfully executed with the inspiration and guidance of our Lord Jesus Christ. I know you're working on fighting for children.

SPEAKER_46 2:25:50

David Golub on consent items.

SPEAKER_23 2:25:55

So on the consent item we have 1 1 C 4 or is it. Well, no, it's 11C2, school-sponsored trips. These are overnight field trips. Now, I usually don't come to the school board meeting because I don't need to. I know the school board's safe. The problem with Education Code 221.5F, that that board says that you can allow boys and girls to sleep together, to shower together. Now, I know the school board's not going to let this happen, but I want to let you everybody know that I'm not from here, but I have a right to be here, because I pay a lot of taxes. 10% of my taxable incomes goes to the state. Of that, 40% goes to the local control funding formula to fund schools across the state. So anybody from outside of this district who pays taxes has a say in this district. Thank you.

SPEAKER_46 2:26:48

We will adjourn on a non-agenda item.

SPEAKER_45 2:26:57

Thank you board. My name is Victoria Maheno, former California State Assembly candidate for District 50, current acting president for Cucamonga School District. As a board member, I value your guys' courage. I thank you, Sonia, for continuing to stand for resilience and righteousness. Education will always be the priority to be at the forefront of education, not transgender ideology. We continue to support children and we continue to protect the safety of all our children. And I thank you for standing for that courageously. I know that many more open doors will continue to open for you as I stand as a mother, as I stand as a board member, as I stand for a state candidate and a community member and a woman of faith. I know that this is the beginning and the stepping stone for much to come. So I bless you all. I bless all the students that are in this room and everybody that has a fight against you. Just know that they are more with you than there are against you. And so we thank you for all that you have done tonight and we continue to support you in the fight.

SPEAKER_46 2:27:58

That concludes public comments.

SPEAKER_40 2:28:05

Thank you to our speakers. A break was requested. I'll set the timer. We're going to take a five minute break. Board members, please take your seat. Where's Dr. Enfield? Okay, and now we can leave the meeting at 8.43 p.m. We're on to changes and deletions. Reagan, are there any?

SPEAKER_46 2:44:16

There are none.

SPEAKER_40 2:44:17

Thank you very much. And now we're on to action items. Item 2A1, new board policy and administrative regulation 5145.7, fairness in girls' athletics and privacy in sex-based facilities, revisions to board policy and administrative regulations 5145.3, nondiscrimination, harassment of students, and revision to administrative regulation 6145.2, athletic competition. Board President Sonya Shaw, that's me, recommends the Board of Education, A, adopt new board policy and administrative regulation, 514.5.72, fairness in girls' athletics and privacy in sex-based facilities. B, approve revisions to board policy and administrative regulation, 514.5.3, non-discrimination, harassment of students, and approve revisions to number C, administrative regulation 6145.2, athletic competition, and to make it all short and in common sense words, protect our daughters in their sports locker rooms and private spaces. May I have a motion, please? Thank you, Mr. Smith. Can I have a second? I'll move it. Second. Thank you, Mr. Cervantes. And now we have comments, questions, discussions. Board members, use your mic if you want to say anything. Cruz, mic is on.

SPEAKER_48 2:45:56

You know, we have two board members coming in the pike. And that is Megan Vickert and Frank Jordan. And they're Christians. They were voted. The community voted for them, and that's the right thing to do, okay? I have to say, the right thing that, you know, based on all the years and consistency that I have been on this board, the right thing would be is that they have a say to what's going on. It is so important that we hear their input. So the community can see the difference between their input and our input. So this item is too important to be decided by the present board. The community has spoken. They elected two new board members. Board members that represent Chino Hills and Ayala. And they should be the ones who hear this and vote on it. It just makes perfect sense. The truth tells us. I mean, what can you say? Deep down inside, you have to follow that, that truth. And that's what the people asked for. And so we can't silence the community that just voted. And it is kind of odd how how they voted, which is knowing the fact that our values, very common sense, just total common sense. But it's so important that the public hears their side. Okay. You know, so therefore, I make a motion that we pull agenda item 281 and bring it back at a later board meeting where you have these two board members so the whole entire community can see everything.

SPEAKER_48 2:48:14

It's so critical. And deep down inside, it makes perfect sense to have that. But that's how I feel. I don't know how the board members feel, but I need to go that direction.

SPEAKER_40 2:48:27

Okay, well, Cruz made a motion, but just let me remind you, my term and Sean's term doesn't end until December 17th. And I am here to serve and tell then, so to silence our voices for the people that elected us until the new ones get sworn in is a cowardly thing. Grow a pair of balls, Cruz. Does he have a second? If he has no second, the motion dies, and the motion died. Thank you, Cruz. Now we'll continue on to comments because I still have the item on the floor. Is there any other board members that want to speak to this? Okay, I will. So I came in because I was on the other side of that mic and the majority of the board members minus the two that had balls for the last four years, the other ones were on the wrong side of history. The only way the community knew that is because we exposed them. Now I've been busy going across the state and there's five of us to hold the fort and continue to expose them. It is not easy being in a position like this because when you have a five zero, you can do a heck of a lot of things that the state does not know about, but that does not mean that kids are not in danger. Listen to my words. Everybody who says it doesn't happen here, you just had people line up, talk about how their son is becoming their daughter, which is not reality.

SPEAKER_40 2:50:01

So what do you think is gonna happen We're gonna get sued no matter what. It's a matter of time. I stood here for four years and I took every sling and arrow and I welcomed them because every time they came up there at that podium and someone else heard, they saw the truth of what we're dealing with. I didn't win for this term. My crown was straightened. I'm walking out of this room knowing I served and I'll continue to serve with bigger balls than a lot of men, including some of them on this board. Because these two girls are representations of girls in our district that needs protection. And if boys are allowed in our restrooms, and I'm telling you right now, boys are trying to get in the girls' restrooms, I am going to sound the alarm over and over. And guess what? I'm not here to protect them anymore. So you better darn well believe I'm going to expose every freaking person on the wrong side of history when it comes to protecting our daughters. And this is the way. I prayed about it. God didn't tell me no. He said go. And if people want to back down a coward, let them because you now have a job to remove these people too that don't stand on the right side of history. They have pissed me off because these are my reason why. These girls. These ones. The ones that I saw three weeks ago, my daughter against girls because she plays with her heart.

SPEAKER_40 2:51:19

She's a team captain. Going in ambliance. Imagine if a boy's there. What would he do to my daughter? It probably would have been her last game. Never on my watch. I would shut down every game I saw a boy, whether it's your daughter or mine. And you know what? That brings me to Bonta and his cowardly letter. Come get me, Bonta. Because again, there you go. There's your cease and desist. And you know where to find me. You have my address. I welcome you. And the teachers unions, oh baby. I am a free agent to expose everything you did behind the scenes. Everything I wasn't allowed to say is now going to be said. And you better darn well believe I am going to expose you and make sure every good teacher gets out of your unions because you don't deserve the protections of hurting girls and boys and kids, bringing sexually explicit things, doing all these filthy things in the classroom. We have a darn good district. but it's because we had darn good leadership to do the right thing. And guess what? To you unions, when you're cease and desist, there you go, baby. You know where to find me. And you woke up the beast in the mom that I didn't even know existed because it was already there. So here's a letter to, I heard Nomar Torres is here, Congresswoman. If you are, let me talk to you too. You're on the wrong side of history.

SPEAKER_40 2:52:43

You're a coward. You sold out our daughters. Anybody else, you're a coward and sold out of your daughters. I have more time to reveal things on social media about you now because I'm not busy trying to wake up the people that I've been for two years on the road united people linking arms you woke up a giant that you didn't even know existed and trust me your unions can spend 10 million dollars to try to take me out you didn't take me out god said this assignment's done like i said earlier the next one's coming and it's already in place baby and there's nothing you're gonna do to stop it because we will be on the right side of history and those of you that you are Trust me. Call me. I will be there to protect you first because if you are protecting our kids, there is no way I'm backing down. My husband can pull us out of this state so fast. We can leave like most people, but he was called to support and protect me and my calling to God. It's our family's calling. My girls never once said, Mom, please don't. They actually said, please do. Go, Mom. So at the end of the day, Tabonta, to Tony Thurmond, to the new state superintendent, to the new governor. The only reason why Tony Thurmond didn't become governor is because we exposed who he was. And that was through these kinds of actions.

SPEAKER_40 2:53:57

Nobody knew who Rob Bonta was until he started suing parents and saying they didn't have a right and a seat at the table. But it took bold action. And I appreciate you, Cruz, for the last four years having enough courage and fortitude to do the right thing. But Frank and Megan aren't here yet. It's our job. And my job wasn't finished to bring it forward and put everybody on record for where they stand. Go ahead, Mr. Na.

SPEAKER_42 2:54:30

Yeah, I'd like to thank all the speakers who came, spoke tonight. I appreciate everyone's opinion, including one mother having doubt if our board cares for our children in our school district. So I was thinking, serving last 18 years on this school board, that I care for our students. And how much? Almost 20 years of my life, I was sharing my life with our children. And I would have dreams meeting students on campus. I would make phone calls with students after their graduations in their college years. I would watch Mr. Cruz talking to band students, asking them if they would need a recommendation letters to achieve their dreams. So, It gave me confirmation. Maybe the math and the numbers might not work or in someone's numbers or sense, but They gave me confirmation tonight that it is time to continue the battle against wrongdoers, against our female athletes in our high school and junior high schools. The timing, someone said, If you're going to do the right thing, the timing is always right. So I believe after long thought, tonight is the right timing to do the right thing, protecting our girls from locker room and their bath facilities. Whether our family members are from our school district or surrounding school district, we are the people. We are the people in California that who wants to bring the common sense back to Sacramento. And thank you, everyone. for sharing your dream and spending tonight's time in our board meeting because it means so much for us having a family like you.

SPEAKER_42 2:58:41

Thank you.

SPEAKER_43 2:58:59

You guys, it's been a very awesome evening tonight because for many reasons. Number one, we got to celebrate our amazing athletes tonight in girls' black football with Ayala, Chino, Chino Hills, and Don Lugo. They were girls' football teams for a reason. I mean, it's not that difficult. One thing that is difficult is this. This is the hardest, Vote for a reason. Let me tell you why. Number one, it's not about me. I have nothing to do with this. It's about doing what's right. Why is this even an issue that we're talking about safe spaces, that should be obvious. Girls have girl spaces, boys have boy spaces, girls have girl sports, boys have boys sports. I don't know, we didn't have cell phones when I grew up, I'm an old guy. But this was never an issue. It's always about fairness to me and safety. When did we stop protecting our girls? Why should it be controversial? This is the challenge that I have. I did it really early this morning because this is the challenge I have. And it doesn't matter. Like, I don't do things to appease a Republican, a Democrat, an independent. I don't care about that. I make decisions because they're right. And that's all that matters. Because let me tell you something. I'm accountable to only one person. And that's the Lord Jesus Christ. And that's the only thing that matters to me. So, when I'm When I'm thinking about this, it's like, you know what, this is brought forward.

SPEAKER_43 3:00:51

It's the right thing. I'll never not support our girls. I have a granddaughter who's an athlete. She's young. She's only five years old, but I'll tell you what, she's an athlete. Now, When we think about decisions, when we're making a vote, we've got to take our emotions out of it. We have to think about what's the right thing to do. So I've been battling this, not because it's a hard decision for how to vote. It's about timing. So I've been battling that. And I knew how I was going to vote, meaning I'll never vote to support boys and girls' private spaces. Because guess what? That's just wrong. Ultimately, that's just wrong. I just didn't know what we should do as far as should we wait a little longer? Should we seek counsel to get more information? So I've been playing as I'm up here and thinking over and over again, I don't know what's gonna happen. I think sometimes that's the best way to go because I don't want it to be necessarily mean that drives me and I knew what a lot of comments been up here made today about like, you know, I'm up here for a reason. I was put here not by not by just both. There's a reason why people because I was called to do this. And I believe that and I'll be called to do this. I'm no longer called to do this anymore. So I do things without fear.

SPEAKER_43 3:02:12

I hope everybody lives their life like that. I try to make decisions based on what's right, what's logical, to honor God and what's common sense. So The bottom line is this. We have to protect our girls, whether it's voting for it right now or if we happen to agree to do it later. I don't know, but the bottom line is this. I will always fight to protect girls and their safe spaces. There's no way they should be invaded by someone of the opposite sex. That's just it, period. So, yeah, thank you.

SPEAKER_47 3:02:54

Mr. Cervantes, I, too, agree that I don't do things based off of politics either. I just do what I believe is right, led by the same person that you are led by. I put my faith in Jesus Christ, and I put my faith in doing what is right. I believe that our morality is based off a higher power. Without a higher power, there is no objective morality. It's just based off of what you feel is right. So the thing about gender dysphoria and allowing boys that think they're girls into girls' spaces, we as a society have decided that girls have rights to their spaces. Boys do, but it never goes that way. Like one of the speakers said earlier, it always goes the other way. Even though a crazy statistic, if you look it up, the majority of the transgender are actually girls that think they're boys. But you never see that going into the boys' private spaces. The thing is, We all agree that these are rights. What you're asking for, they're not trans rights. You're asking for trans privileges. As soon as you're asking for something that infringes on the rights of others, that's not a right. You don't have a right to infringe on the rights of others. You're asking for a privilege to be granted to you. And frankly, I refuse to grant that privilege. I think that we need to... reinforce the rights of our girls and our boys, too, to have their private spaces.

SPEAKER_47 3:04:39

But like I said, it goes the other way. So that's all I have to say about that.

SPEAKER_40 3:04:50

Thank you, Mr. Smith. And seeing no other comments, we'll go ahead and register a vote. I'm waiting for one more. And the motion passes with Na voting yes, Smith voting yes, Cervantes voting yes, Shah voting yes, and Cruz voting no. Okay, we're on to item 2B1. Minimum wage and compensation increase to classified service non-bargaining unit recommends the Board of Education approve the minimum wage and compensation increase to the classified service non-bargaining unit effective January 1st, 2027. May I have a motion, please? Thank you, Mr. Cervantes, for motion. Thank you, Mr. Smith, for your second. And any comments? No, that's on the floor. Questions, discussions? Hearing nothing further, board members, please register your vote. And the motion passes with a vote of five to zero. And now to consent. Board members, if you have an item to pull, please indicate so on your monitors. And for the consent items, may I have a motion, please? Thank you, Mr. Smith. And a second? Thank you, Mr. Cervantes. Board members, please register your vote. Waiting for one more. One more. If you don't see green. Yours is good, Mr. Nunn. We're good now. Okay, motion passes with a vote of five to zero. And now moving on to information. Are there any comments or questions for your information? Seeing that there is none, we'll move on to communications board comments. Mr. Smith.

SPEAKER_47 3:07:38

All right, well, what a show tonight, huh? Okay. This is the, you know, I've had the privilege of liaisoning to some of the other board meetings, and everyone says that this is the one, right? This is the show for sure. I really appreciate everyone that showed up. Thank you for all your support. This has been, like I said earlier, it's been an honor and a privilege to serve on this board. I know you don't know, but I initially kind of got a little drug into this position initially. So but once I saw what needed to be done, I basically said, hey, you know, The only way for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing. So when I thought about it, I was like, let's go ahead and do it. I do have, I will not, I have plenty of things to do. I still volunteer heavily in the community. You'll probably see me patrolling around with the COPs. I've been there over six years now, volunteering with the San Bernardino County Sheriff's Department. I still want to go say hi to the fire district board. Those guys are fantastic. I do want to address some of these things that are brought up here. A lot of times, the lawsuits, as Sonia has brought up earlier, who's suing whom in these lawsuits? And it's kind of like, for those of you that had a big brother or an older sibling, you remember when they pulled you down and make you hit yourself?

SPEAKER_47 3:09:16

They were like, stop hitting yourself, stop hitting yourself. That's kind of what's going on here, right? we're getting pinned down and we're saying, oh, look at all the legal fees you're costing us. Look at all the legal fees you're costing us while they're punching us in the face and suing us. They're the ones that are costing the money and then have the audacity to come around and say, You know, oh, yeah. Mom, look, he's hitting himself.

SPEAKER_29 3:09:42

Oh, look, he's hitting himself.

SPEAKER_47 3:09:46

My brother was eight years older, so I got a lot of that growing up. So the other thing is sometimes, you know, laws aren't always good. You know, there are bad laws. I would like to ask a lot of the people that say, hey, well, the California state law says this. It's like, well, you must have been one of the people that supported Jim Crow laws, right? It was the law. So you must support it if the law said that. Would you have been one of those people like, oh, we can't go against Jim Crow laws because you might get sued? It's like, no, sometimes you have to make a stand. You have to say, listen, I disagree with this law, and I'm going to fight it. So while my time was short here, it's been an honor, Sonia. I love you, my sister in Christ. You're awesome. I'm sure we're not going to be far, so we'll still see a lot of each other. While it was, you know, I like to look back and see that maybe I had some good impact. So we have an auto shop coming, right? That's still in the works. The junior high track and field, right? Okay. The defibrillators with the fire department, right? Parking lot safety. All right. So I'd like to look back on my short little tenure here and say, hey, I had some pretty decent accomplishments. I'm proud of that. And I'm proud of still, you know, I volunteer with the band.

SPEAKER_47 3:11:21

I'm not going to go away from that. Obviously, I'll still be building and pushing props and hauling and loading and doing all that stuff. But again, it has been an honor, a privilege, and a pleasure to work with you all. Fantastic. And I hope to see more of you in the future. Thank you.

SPEAKER_40 3:11:44

Thank you, Mr. Smith. And Mr. It's kind of lucky for Mr. Smith and Sonia. They get to get small breaks.

SPEAKER_42 3:12:19

Unfortunately, me and Mr. Cruz, Mr. Cervantes, we still would have lots of meetings and lots of work to do serving our students. But really, we enjoy working together. working with our children, working with our teachers and our staff members. It's a great experience. It's time where we need to have a thankful heart, having each other, having a family, having this time and having this school district where we can gather and voice our opinions, our wants, and our hopes. That's why maybe we're calling it Thanksgiving season. We need to give thanks for the things that we have and also things that we don't have. I learned that while back, maybe 15 years ago, I was able to travel to Oregon In the beginning, I loved it because it was so peaceful. It was quiet. But then I was missing something. I was missing people. There's such a less people than California. that when we were driving through, you could hardly see any people. There's a bunch of trees and lakes, but no people. Then suddenly, I was able to see just few people passing by, and I was just waving at them, and they were waving at me. Then I learned, how important that the time is that we're spending with another human being. And what a privilege for us to serve all these young students, many of them, over 25,000 students in our school district, thinking about their education, and tonight we were talking about the girls' athlete safety.

SPEAKER_42 3:15:46

And the board was brave enough to stand up for their safety because we really love them. I'd like to thank Mr. Smith, Sonia, for sharing their time with us. And we will continuously work with Mr. Cruz, Mr. Cervantes, and new coming board members to make sure our students are safe in our school district. Thank you.

SPEAKER_40 3:16:42

Thank you, Mr. Na. Mr. Cruz? Thank you, Mr. Cruz. Mr. Cervantes?

SPEAKER_43 3:16:50

Mayor Mrakas, Okay, thanks everybody for being here and those that left already you know, thank you appreciate your your comments again, you know, one of the things I think it's really important is to have a. Mayor Mrakas, You know, they need respect the quorum it crucial respect, even if we we don't agree, because. I'm going to talk about a few things right now. I'll try to make it quick. There's a lot of things to cover from the last board meeting, things that we did, but I'm going to focus on a few things. Number one, Sean, Sonia, thank you guys. It's been an honor and privilege to serve with you here. I learned a lot from both of you, and I know it will help me going forward. And it's been just wonderful because you guys are warriors, both of you. Talking about warriors, we have our veterans. This was veterans. We celebrated Veterans Day last week. We had a couple of events. Howard Cattle had an outstanding event on the 10th that I got to, I was an honor and privilege to be invited to and participate. Principal King did an outstanding job setting that up because our veterans need to be recognized as often as possible, not just once a year, but every day because it's the sacrifices that they did like family members of mine have done, like my dad have done, that allow us to come up here and disagree with one another and vigorously fight and defend those rights to do so.

SPEAKER_43 3:18:27

And even if we don't agree, we have to support one another no matter what. Veterans Day celebration on the 11th, the city of Chino did an outstanding job. Chief Mensah led that event. It was outstanding. We got a lot of veterans out there that served and are also serving as police officers, first responders, firefighters. We thank you for your service. And it's not about just saying thank you for your service. They don't want to hear that because I have family members. I served in law enforcement. We want to know what you did with those freedoms. You know, what did we do with the sacrifice that they went out there on deployments where family members didn't know where they were going to come home or where they were going to be? And what did we do with that? How did we thank them by how we live our lives? You know, and Brother Andrew, I support you for even though you vote the way you have to vote. That's you. You're my brother, and you do what you have to do with what your convictions are. And just like with my heart and with anybody else's heart. I think we're on the same team. We might have a different way of getting there. But I know everybody's heart up here and what they stand for. It just depends on what route you want to take to get there. And so let's just remember, we don't want to make decisions

SPEAKER_43 3:20:01

based on what people say we should do, but we need to do them because it's what we know is right to do. So again, have a great, happy Thanksgiving, everybody, with your families. Thank you for being here late and looking forward to seeing you next time. Thank you.

SPEAKER_40 3:20:19

Thank you, Mr. Cervantes. Dr. Enfield?

SPEAKER_29 3:20:23

all right mr smith again i i want to thank you for your year of service here on the board uh to step in and fill in uh is a huge commitment and again i appreciate uh your time on the board and making that commitment to the community and serving on the board and you've done a a really good job on doing that so again thank you and i wish you the best in in all your endeavors all right mrs shong um As I look back on the previous four years on the board, I'm confident that those who agree with you philosophically and those who don't would both agree that these four years have not been boring. I would like to also take this opportunity, however, to thank you for being a board member who's always allowed me to do my job. that is the greatest gift a board member can give to a superintendent, the space to perform my daily duties without interference. You resisted temptations to tell me what to do or how to do it, though we had many, many, many conversations. And some of them I don't even know if they were conversations. But because of that, I will always be grateful for the steady support for these four years, and I wish you all the best in the future. Thank you.

SPEAKER_40 3:22:01

Thank you, Dr. Enfield. I go back to just remembering being so pissed off at everybody up here just saying, I'm done. We're gonna knock on every door and we're gonna change these seats. And we did just that. And again, I'll go back to what I said earlier. I am grateful we have had the opportunity from the very beginning to make history all together with Cruz, with Cervantes, with Monroe, who we miss, and with Smith, and with Na, and with our staff, I mean I came in because of schools being closed. I pulled my kids out for that time. I had no clue what a charter was. I learned I protected my kids. What a mom and my husband supported it. What a dad would do. I drove 45 minutes to an hour outside of the district that I grew up in. I never wanted to. make my kids leave to another district but i didn't trust the leadership in charge the board majority in charge to handle my most precious blessings and gifts and i didn't sit behind there i did something about it and i'm grateful the community came alongside us i remember One of our first board meetings, brand new, you guys trusted me to be your board president. I was like, what the heck are you guys doing? At least let me learn what this is. But I took it as an honor to represent all of us. And when I spoke, I spoke knowing that you guys were on the same mission.

SPEAKER_40 3:23:37

And I appreciate that. Again, Cruz, Cervantes, Monroe, you, you, and you, Cruz, and Smith, non-Smith, But I'll go back to brand new out of the gates. I'm watching legislators. I'm watching tampons being put into the boys' restrooms. I'm watching book policies that had very horrific things that I would never even feel comfortable saying out loud being passed. I traveled to Sacramento. I met the very moms that are sitting in this room, including those that are in our community and those that are surrounding California. And we said, we got to do something. And we did. And I am proud of what we did, because we exposed those that nobody knew what they were doing, except those of us that saw the harm when God showed us in his perfect timing these kids are in danger. And they are. And it kills me to not be behind here. Of course, I wouldn't want to ever tell you what to do. But of course, I would want to do everything in my power, including giving up my life if it meant protecting kids. I never once asked God why me, and I never will. But I'll go back to our very first board meeting, very, well, second one or third one, but very soon out the gate, when I saw an assemblyman at that time, Bill LaSelle, bring a bill that said parents have a right to know about their own child. It was simple. I used to beg our board to be the voice because we were traveling.

SPEAKER_40 3:25:10

But what a great thing is it for them to be the lobbyist? Don't get me started on that. They get tons of money for being advocates on things that are all on the wrong side of the history. But for our taxpayer dollars to fight against things that we do not want our kids exposed to. And I said, we're going to bring a resolution. We will go testify as a district. And the board supported that. Not just me. I brought it forward. The board has a decision. They can either say yes or no. And they supported it. I remember you freaking out. We're going to get sued. We're going to get sued. Yeah. Like Mr. Smith said. And like I said from the very beginning, if there's laws that are being passed every day in California that are harming people, you know what? I've always taught my kids, if there's rules, that are put in place that are harming you, I allow you to break them, but I also want you to be part of being the solution to remake them. And that's exactly what I did. I was part of the solution. I can only account for myself. I don't know what anybody else is going to do. And at the end of the day, after we passed parental notification and we were bullied by Bonta, we were bullied by Thurmond, the governor knew some, we were bullied by the teachers union, I remember you freaking out, for lack of better words, grabbing your head, saying some words that probably are explicit.

SPEAKER_40 3:26:29

Mrs. Shuttle, do you know what you did? This is gonna go national. And I sat there like this with Pat behind the curtains saying, why? It's not a big deal. We're just saying parents have their constitutional right. And you said, no, Mrs. Shaw, it's going to go national. Trust me, do you know what you just did? And I'm over there like, so what? Then let them be exposed. And from that point on, I appreciate you coming along and supporting what these people elected me to do and wholeheartedly seeing another example of maybe a different voice that you guys were not aware, because you guys are really focused and you guys do a really good job at pushing a district in the right direction when it comes to reading, writing, and math. But I saw as a parent that was being challenged by something deeper. And I said, no, you guys aren't going to be able to do your job if you didn't stand in the front lines. I can go on and on in how we got bullied in court. We got bullied in perp court, the administrative law court with kangaroo you know, courts that we both know of, and the union, you know, weaponizes that too, and nobody knows about it. But we check them every single point. We never stopped doing what we were called to do as a group. And you guys, I pray to God you do the right thing continuously.

SPEAKER_40 3:27:52

And at the end of the day, I'm not mad at you, Cruz. I'm sad. I won't be here to be your protector, but also advise you on things that I see coming. And it hurts my heart, but I'll still be there. Don't call away. I still love you for being on the right side of history. I know your heart, it's not bad. So just know that. But at the end of the day, I felt the burning fire to bring this forward because that's what God told me to do. And I know each of you struggled timing this, that, but we struggled with the timing of this for multiple years. And you know what, at the end of the day, People on the wrong side of history are gonna be exposed. If the two new board members coming in on their term, in their time to do what they want, wanna fight against it, so be it, let the public know. Because they definitely aren't gonna be on the right side when you guys have to make tough decisions, continue a lawsuit. But I will tell you, I never bring us to a fight without giving us the tools. And tools are coming to help us in this fight, just watch. You guys accept it. It's going to be there for you because I'm never dumb enough to not seek help in a big fight without making sure we recovered. I got this board's back. I got this community's back.

SPEAKER_40 3:29:11

But more importantly, I got my reason why's back. Again, those two beautiful daughters who I told multiple times, get your butts home. But they stayed here because it has been a family thing. So at the end of the day, I am grateful that God allowed me to link arms with people all across the state. And I see people in this room that drove eight hours, who is a board member now on the right side of history. I see people, moms, who we go crazy driving to Sacramento, throwing a bunch of us in a minivan or whatever, a Suburban. I see all the moms that have been there through the blood, sweat and tears, some of them driving me around California when we didn't have the money to fly or picking me up for the airport or making my family a hot meal. I see other board members in the fire wishing they had a board majority to do what you guys did so they can stand on the right side of history. But let me tell you, you don't need a majority to stand on the right side of history. It takes one person to ignite something else and another person that didn't know that they were gonna be called to a fight. We all have a choice. And I appreciate your choice to fight the good fight. My choice is to fight the good fight. Don't make me your enemy behind that, Mike. But at the end of the day, I will give God my yes every single day because I'm telling you, that fire is burning.

SPEAKER_40 3:30:33

You can ask my husband. He's telling me, rest, recover, let your body heal. You've been through a lot. And I'm over there like, I don't want to rest. There's kids being harmed right now. I can't rest. but I also know I'm supposed to be obedient and the next plan's coming, so get ready, California. This is just the beginning. Go ahead, Mr. Ngo.

SPEAKER_42 3:30:57

Yeah, I'd like to ask something that people need to know. This is kind of a secret. Sonia Shah actually owes everything to Mr. Cruz. She was discovered when she was a parent speaker on the other side of the aisle. And it was Mr. Cruz who said, look, look, I found a woman who could really speak intelligently, and she's so strong, a powerful person. And I said, who's that? Here, this is her. And this is how we met Sonia Shah in the beginning. And without that discovery, we would never have met Sonia Shah. from Chino Valley Unified. So I think this is a behind story that no one knows yet. So I'd like to thank Mr. Cruz for discovering Sonia Shah today. Thank you, Mr. Cruz.

SPEAKER_40 3:32:18

Thank you, Mr. Na. And with that said, I am grateful for this opportunity, but I'm gonna adjourn this meeting with the gratefulness and the joy in my heart for those that have protected us, continue to protect us, those that are in heaven because they fought the good fight, all of our veterans and all of our military currently standing, thank you for your service. Just know that the rights of the people here, we will continue to fight that fight so you have honor in serving and protecting those things throughout the nation. So thank you. And with that said, I now adjourn the Board of Education meeting at 9.32 p.m.