Board of Education — October 15, 2026
I call to order the regular meeting of Board of Education Thursday, October 5, 2026, at 425 PM. Yeah, why is it October 15? 2026 at 425 p.m. with Cervantes, Cruz, Naugh, Shaw, and Smith present. Are there any requests from the public to speak on closed session items prior to the board adjourning into closed session?
There are none.
Thank you. We will now adjourn into closed session regarding the following matters, which are all described in detail on the printed agenda.
Conference with legal counsel, anticipated litigation, one possible case. Conference with legal counsel, existing litigation, five cases. student discipline matters public employee appointments multi-track year round k-8 school principal and coordinator and then integrated technology systems public employee discipline dismissal release and public employees performance evaluation superintendent
I now reconvene the regular meeting of Board of Education at 6 p.m. with Cervantes, Cruz, Nash, Shaw, and Smith present. Before we begin, please silence all electronic devices and note that these proceedings are being recorded. Regan.
The board made a closed session from 425 p.m. to 557 p.m. regarding conference with legal counsel, anticipated litigation, one possible case, conference with legal counsel, existing litigation, five cases, student discipline matters, public employee appointments, multitrack year-round K-8 school principal and coordinator of integrated technology systems, public employee discipline dismissal release, and public employee performance evaluation superintendent. The board took the following action. Appointed Melissa Fisneros Alba as principal at Cal Aero K8 with an effective date of October 16th, 2026 with a vote of 5-0 with Cervantes, Cruz, Na Smith, and Shaw voting yes. And appointed Harry Rivera as coordinator of integrated technology systems with an effective date of 10-16-2026 with a vote of 5-0 with Cervantes, Cruz, Na Smith, and Shaw voting yes. No further action was taken that requires public disclosure.
Thank you, Reagan. And generally, we don't have those that were approved by the board here. If you would like to, Melissa, we would love if you want to say a couple of words. Congratulations as well.
Remember, Dr. Enfield and distinguished cabinet members, I am beyond excited and honored to be able to continue my leadership and my educational journey at CalAero Preserve Academy as the principal. For the last two years, I've invested in the community, the parents, the staff, and the students, and have grown to appreciate and love all the people that are connected with CalAero. We have made some incredible achievements at CalAero, including most recently the national recognition of the PLC Model at Work School, which I'm proud and honored to have been part of that process. I would like to acknowledge and recognize Mrs. Lori Warner as she is on her much well-deserved retirement. I congratulate her for the legacy that she established at CalAero. And my goal is to continue to amplify what she had already built and started and created quite the foundation of student success. As I am approaching my 30th year in education serving only Chino Valley Unified School District, I have had the privilege to have worked with many administrators, leaders, and mentors. All of them have had a piece of my leadership journey and my skills and my style, but there are two former administrators, two retired principals that have made the greatest impact in my leadership style. And those are my mom and dad, who are here today as proud parents of another administrator in the family. Thank you for your trust in giving me this responsibility to lead Cal Aero. And I'm excited to work alongside you in the coming years.
Thank you so much.
Congratulations. Very awesome. And thanks to her mom and dad for being here and for all your service as well. Very, very beautiful. I don't want to embarrass the other person behind the scenes, but Carrie Rivera. Most of you don't know. She's always helping us with sound and technical and all in between. But congratulations.
Good evening President Shaw board members cabinet members and distinguished community. I want to thank you for the opportunity to serve the district in this leadership capacity and I look forward to serving the district for many more years. I've been here 21 years serving the district and maintaining its level of excellence to our community and I look forward in serving in this capacity. Thank you.
Awesome. Awesome. Thank you. Thank you both and congratulations to you both. And now we're on to our Pledge of Allegiance. Cervantes, will you please lead us? Thank you. And tonight, it's my privilege to recognize Ayala High School girls' varsity cross-country team for their performance at the 2026 Palomares League Preview. Our female student athletes worked incredibly hard. They train, they compete, they push themselves, and they represent their schools and their teams with determination and pride. Their accomplishments deserve to be recognized and celebrated. Tonight, we are especially proud to recognize Phoebe Kim and Kate who both placed in the top 10 individually at the Palomares League preview. Phoebe and Kate, your hard work, perseverance, and commitment to your sport have not gone unnoticed, and we're so proud to recognize your accomplishments. We're also proud to recognize the entire Iola Girls varsity cross-country team. While cross-country recognizes individual performances, it also is very much a team sport. Every runner contributes, every effort matters, and the success of the team reflects the dedication of all these young women. And behind every successful team are coaches who invest their time, leadership, and encouragement to their athletes. Tonight, we also recognize IOLA's cross-country coaches and thank them for their dedication to these students and the program. As a district, we believe it is important to recognize, encourage, and support our female athletes and the opportunities they have worked so hard to earn. Tonight, we celebrate these young women, their achievements, and the dedication they have shown to their sport, their teammates, and their school.
At this time, I'll actually go up there, and then I'll call the coaches, and then we'll call each of our athletes to recognize them. We're actually going to do our coaches first. So that way, they can have the honor of also presenting the certificates. But yes, can we give our coaches a round of applause? And then we'll announce the names. Carolyn Kobo.
Thank you so much.
Enrique Villa. Thank you. And Matthew. How do you say your name? Allman. And one of you was going to not butcher the names like I have been, right? You wanted to? Oh, okay. And board, you're more than welcome to come and shake hands.
So Kate Beck. Phoebe Kim. Alyssa Alfaro. Genesis Almendarez. Kara Amaya. Julia Barasa. Victoria Cabadas. Zoe Carrasco. Ella Chang. Kaelin Denao. Mia Facenda. Autumn Fang. Jacqueline Figueroa. Randy Flores. Riley Flores. Jayden Galvan. Scarlett Garcia. Riley Han. Stella Leong. Aiko Navarro. Maddie Lau. Sabrina Leong. Olivia Lee. Beverly Lin. Ariana Lamelli. Eslyn Liu, Amy Luan, Mandy Ma, Lavelle Menti, Annabelle Morales, Jenna Morit, Nayeli Naranjo, Nicole Ramirez, Alicia Razo. Olivia Razo. Victoria Romero. Simran Sharma. Johanna Torres. Alyssa Velasquez. Bella Wang. And Isabelle Yu.
Can we give the whole team and our coaches a round of applause? And I heard either coaches and athletes or both. Does anybody want to say anything? I heard a few do. You're more than welcome if coaches want to go first.
So I think us coaches have already talked a lot about the issue. We've met with all of the athletic directors From our league, we've spoke with our league coaches. Unfortunately, there hasn't been much done about keeping female sports female and keeping the women's category protected. Thank you. so that our girls can race and compete fairly with each other, and so that they don't have to go against biological males. So tonight, I would like you to hear from some of our female athletes.
Hi guys, my name is Scarlett Garcia and I'm a senior on the cross country team in Ayala and the first thing I want to say is that I'm not trying to get in the way of anybody expressing themselves and I feel like it's none of my business so I shouldn't really care about that but what biological males are doing in sports right now is like inconsiderate and unfair to female athletes and I feel like this entire situation with James is like the district prioritizing an individual's wants over the rights of many which simultaneously impedes the achievements of biological women while like disregarding their thoughts on the matter and allowing him to race with girls brings up an even more pressing question that I'm sure a lot of students and parents are wondering which is how will the district handle future situations like this. Imagine if I had our fastest runners identify as girls. Men have bigger hearts lung capacities and faster recovery times. Should a male who can run a 14 33 mile be allowed to run with girls who have ever only gotten around 17 to 18 minutes. There is no way of determining who is lying for their own personal gain. And it is fair, and not to mention obvious, to split races between biological sexes only. Is there even a limit to what like-minded individuals can ask for? On the notion that James doesn't feel comfortable enough to run with the boys, what's to stop him from requesting to use the girls' bathroom and locker room?
And unfortunately this does have to be brought up because although what I'm saying might not apply to him I don't believe that girls at our school should be able to be subject to such offensive circumstances and allowing a male to run in a girl's race or just participate in any female sport at all ruins the purpose of competition due to the inequitable difference in biological capabilities. And I have no ill intent towards James and others like him. but I couldn't stay silent about this. Like normally I wouldn't have been bothered to go out of my way and speak in front of all these people, but I felt the need to articulate the justifiable feelings of the girls on my team who feel like they're overshadowed by a male playing in the same sport. And I just, I don't think it's fair to me and the other female athletes. Thank you.
Thank you.
Good afternoon, everyone. My name is Phoebe, and I'm here to speak about fairness in girls across country and protecting opportunities for female athletes. I understand that this is a sensitive issue and that every student deserves to be treated with kindness and respect. However, I also believe that we need to recognize that biological sex can affect athletic performance. Males and females have different physical advantages which is one of the reasons why sports have separate categories. Identifying as a girl does not necessarily eliminate the physical differences associated with being born male. I believe that these differences need to be considered when deciding who competes in girls sports. In cross country, every place matters. We train for months, wake up early, push through difficult workouts, and work towards goals like earning a top 10 finish or advancing to the next level. When varsity rankings and awards are affected, those opportunities matter. We want to know that we are competing under rules that give female athletes a fair chance. I'm asking our district to review the current policies for girls cross country and consider how they affect female athletes. We need clear and consistent standards that take biological differences into account while still treating every student fairly. I recognize that transgender athletes also want to participate in sports and feel included. However inclusion should not mean overlooking concerns about fairness for female athletes. I believe we can respect every student while still having an honest discussion about how to protect girls opportunities to compete.
Thank you for listening.
Good afternoon. Good afternoon everyone. My name is Alicia and I run cross country at Ayala High School. Today I wanted to talk about fairness with cross country and racing. Me and my team work extremely hard each and every day to then compete against girls. With that said, boys racing against girls is unfair because there are biological differences that affect athletic performance. Males typically have much higher levels of testosterone, which contribute to greater muscle mass, strength, and physical performance. Research shows that these differences can create a significant advantage in sports, especially when it comes to running. This isn't about disrespecting anyone or attacking anyone personally, and everyone deserves to participate and be treated with respect. My concern is more making sure girls have a fair opportunity, especially when it comes to competing, placement, qualified times, and team sports. We put so much effort and time into all our sports, and I believe our hard work deserves to be recognized through fair and consistent competition. Thank you.
Hello everyone, my name is Kate Beck and I am a sophomore in IALA cross country and I am here today because I, as well as my teammates, have serious concerns about fairness in our girls cross country division. As female cross country runners, we care about this sport. We put our time, effort, and so much of ourselves into cross country only to finish behind an athlete who may retain physical advantages associated with male puberty. We're concerned about transgender girls who have experienced male puberty competing in the girls division. The physical advantages associated with male puberty raises serious questions about fairness. It's frustrating to feel like these concerns aren't being heard, especially when we're the ones directly being affected by the decisions being made. In March 2023, World Athletics excluded transgender athletes who had experienced male puberty from the female category in world ranking competitions. If an international athletics organization has adopted eligibility rules based on the competitive fairness, then I believe our concerns deserve serious consideration as well. I don't want this to become about attacking another student, but respecting someone else shouldn't mean that the concerns, feelings, and rights of the girls affected by this decision get pushed aside. We're students, we're athletes, and our concerns matter too. We deserve to step onto that starting line feeling that the competition is fair. Thank you.
Can we give another round of applause to our athletes, please, and our coaches? We're going to take a picture, but unfortunately, their entire team was displaced because they had to compete against another district who had a male on the girls team. And two of our athletes were pushed down to fifth and sixth instead of fourth and fifth like they should have taken it. Our district doesn't play games. We don't do that here. You have board members that are protecting you. Trust me, I'm at every CIF meeting. I am in every state inbox every time this happens to a young female athlete. This is a hill that I would die on to make sure that you guys are protected. So just know you have a board and you have principals and you have coaches. They're on the right side of history. We'll never back down from that as long as even if we're out of this position. So just know from the bottom of my heart, this is something whether I am a board member or not, I will never stop fighting for you guys. I know I could speak on behalf of the entire board, they will never ever back down from this position of protecting you and your rights and your guys' opportunities and your privacy. So once again, let's thank our female athletes and let's celebrate them and their rifle spots. And we would love to have a picture and showcase you. That's why we wanted to honor you guys today, because you guys are the rifle earners of those spots here, despite what California, unfortunately, is doing to you guys.
Yeah.
Well, I'll come over here. Congratulations again to our student athletes and coaches, and thank you for representing Ayala High School and Chino Valley Unified School District with such dedication and pride. Please join me one more time for giving our Ayala girls varsity cross country team and coaches another round of applause. So tonight's the night of Bulldogs, it seems. We have another wonderful accomplishment from Ayala High School to celebrate this evening. Tonight, we are proud to recognize Mr. Michael, Mike Collins. Unfortunately, he's not here with us. He's enjoying his anniversary, as he should, of Ayala High School and his dedication to providing meaningful learning experiences and preparing students for future success through engineering career technical education pathway. On September 23rd, 2026, Mr. Collins had an article published in East full news titled inspiring curiosity for career exploration and mentoring for pathway success. The article highlights the importance of helping students explore their interests, discover potential career opportunities and develop the skills and confidence needed to pursue their goals. Through the engineering pathways, students have opportunities to connect classroom learning with real world applications, explore careers in engineering and related fields, and gain valuable experiences that help prepare them for life beyond high school. Mr. Cullen's dedication to inspiring curiosity, encouraging exploration, and mentoring students reflects the meaningful impact their educators have in helping students discover their potential. We are especially proud to see the innovative work taking place at Iola High School SHARED WITH EDUCATORS BEYOND OUR DISTRICT.
HAVING THIS WORK HIGHLIGHTED IN A NATIONAL EDUCATION PUBLICATION IS A WONDERFUL REFLECTION OF THE DEDICATION AND CREATIVITY OF OUR TEACHERS AND THE OPPORTUNITIES AVAILABLE TO OUR STUDENTS. ALTHOUGH MR. COLLINS IS UNABLE TO JOIN US THIS EVENING, WE ARE PLEASED TO HAVE FOUR STUDENT REPRESENTATIVES, THE ENGINEERING AND ARCHITECTURE PATHWAY, WHO WILL ACCEPT HIS CERTIFICATE OF RECOGNITION ON HIS BEHALF. ANIA GRANT, MAXIMUS RODRIGUEZ, ZACHARY DEVORE, and Lucky Zing. Would you please join me at the podium? And can I have Baldy View's rep?
And then we'll have Ayala.
We are so excited you guys are here.
So would you accept this on behalf of Mr. Collins, please? And would you guys like to say a few words? Yeah, we have a... Oh, perfect.
Perfect. The mic's right here. I don't want to hold it.
Okay.
Good evening President Shaw board members district leadership and everyone joining us this evening. My name is Zachary DeBoer I'm a four year senior in the pathway and I've been involved in both ACE mentorship and Forge Mechatronics programs and Iola High School. It is my privilege to share the following remarks on behalf of Michael Collins who sends his sincerest apologies for being unable to attend tonight's special recognition. He's currently celebrating his 32nd wedding anniversary with his wife previously on a previously planned trip and true And in true Michael Collins fashion, he wanted to say one message from afar. Aloha. The following are Mr. Collins' words. First and foremost, we are incredibly honored by this recognition and deeply grateful for the unwavering support, trust, and collaboration between Chino Valley Unified School District and Bodley View ROP. Each day, I have the extraordinary privilege of walking into the classroom filled with talented, curious, and ambitious young people. There is no greater reward than helping them discover their full potential, find their passion, and prepare for the opportunities that await them beyond high school. But what makes the program special is that we're not simply a CTE engineering and architecture pathway. We are at our core a career mentorship program. And the results speak for themselves. 90% of our students continue to college with 80% pursuing STEM majors. Another six enter the skilled trades and four pursue military service. These outcomes reflect something we believe strongly. Student success is not defined by a single destination, but by helping every student discover a meaningful pathway to their future.
Much of our program success, however, comes from something that happens after the final bell rings, our ACE mentorship program. It is now in our sixth year and grown to the largest high school ACE chapter in the Inland Empire. With more than 70 registered participants through this program, Students work directly alongside professionals in architecture, construction, and engineering, gaining invaluable exposure to real-world challenges, professional relationships, and career opportunities. Our partnership with Cal Poly Pomona's College of Engineering and Forge Mechatronics Robotics Program provide another remarkable opportunity. Students receive hands-on mentorship from Cal Poly robotics professor, And this year, they will expand that experience through direct collaboration with Cal Poly engineering students. These are not simply extracurricular activities. They are bridges connecting high school to the professional world. Tonight, I would like to recognize four extraordinary students whose accomplishments exemplify what happens when passion, opportunity, and initiative come together. As previously stated, I'm Zachary DeBoer. I'm a senior at IL High School. For the past four years, I've been in the program. And for the past two, I've been in the ACE and FORGE programs. These experiences taught me how to lead by example. This year, I'm leader of my ACE group and FORGE group, developing on my experience as a co-leader last year in the ACE program. Over time, I've focused on developing my technical skills, which allowed me to take on the responsibility of operating our CNC fabrication equipment. I've always strived to be reliable, dedicated, and supportive to my peers to contribute as much as I can to this program.
Hi, I'm Maximus Rodriguez. I spent two years in the IL engineering pathway and have constantly demonstrated exceptional talent in my abilities to do advanced computer modeling, prototype development, and fabrication. Through my involvement in both ACE mentorship and Forged Mechatronics, I was able to grow beyond being an accomplished student into becoming a mentor myself. helping younger students be able to develop their own technical skills and confidence. And through Colin's guidance, I've been able to exemplify my own skills, but others, and I think that's brought a new light to myself and others. Thank you.
Good evening. I'm junior Lucky Zhang, and although I'm only in my first year of the pathway, I've been trusted to take initiative, pursue my ideas, and turn them into something meaningful. Recognizing my ideas potential, I was granted special admission into our senior engineering capstone course. Being welcomed into a space for more experienced students showed me that others believe that I could contribute and take on challenges, even as someone new to the pathway. I'm now working to turn my vision into a real-world project. I have spoken to the board about this. I've founded Pathways, a student-led work-based learning organization in collaboration with the Chino Valley Chamber of Commerce. My goal is to connect students with local businesses and career opportunities, and I'm grateful for the support and trust that have been helped bring this idea to life. Our first pilot is scheduled to launch this spring with the potential to expand the chambers of commerce and high schools across the country. These experiences have shown me that students don't need years of experience to make a meaningful contribution. When we're trusted with responsibility, supported with mentorship, and given the freedom to learn, we can turn our ideas into action. I'm grateful to those who believed in me as I got started, and I hope to create similar opportunities for other students. In closing, Mr. Collins believe our student success is a direct reflection of the outstanding leadership and guidance of Principal Yarboy and the extraordinary CTE-focused partnership we share with Baldy View ROP.
From Mr. Khan's word, as educators, our greatest accomplishment is not simply what students learn while they are in our classrooms. It is what they are inspired and empowered to accomplish long after they leave them. On behalf of our students, our program, and myself, we are truly grateful, deeply honored, and incredibly blessed that we are able to invest in the futures of the young people we serve. Thank you and aloha.
So we just wanna say thank you on behalf of Mr. Collins. We wanna say thank you, Chino Valley Unified School District. We also wanna say thank you to ROP. Thank you for that partnership. We truly appreciate their partnership. We also wanna say thank you to Cal Poly Pomona and the city and all of the other partners that Mr. Collins has and he has a lot of partners and he's doing a fantastic job. Again, his records, his data speaks for itself. Thank you and thank you students for an excellent, excellent presentation.
I'll speak from your heart. You're good.
As a commissioner for Baldy View, I would like one of our amazing Baldy View employees there to speak on behalf of the program as well. And to parents, please make sure your kids know about Baldy View's pathways that we had partnered with, because there's even fire. There's a lot of different things that we offer that are great for kids who might be four-year bound, who might not be, and that just want certificates and programs available to them. So please, just to parents. So parents kids just tell them a little bit about this pathway.
Thank you. Thank you President Shaw. I'm Elizabeth Graham assistant superintendent of educational services at Baldy View ROP. First and foremost thank you all for recognizing Mr. Collins and all of our instructors and the support you provide, greatly appreciated, as well as your partnership. At Baldy View ROP, we offer free career technical education to all students in Chino Valley District. We have a lot of our programs embedded on your high school sites. We also have a campus just a few miles down the road in Ontario that is also free for you to attend. We have anything from medical careers to fire, public services, to computer, to art. So you name it, we probably have it. Again, free for you to enroll. We do have people on your campuses that can help you get connected with us. So we would love to see you all in our classes. And thank you for the time and recognition.
Thank you
Congratulations again. And now, tonight we're also honored to recognize the Chino Valley Fire District for its continued partnership with the Chino Valley Unified School District and its commitment to safety and well-being of our students, staff, and community. Through the Heart Safe and the Bleed Safe programs, the Chino Valley Fire District has generously donated two automated external defibrillators, or AEDs, and two trauma kits to our district. Give them a round of applause before I continue. These are definitely more than just pieces of an emergency equipment. Having the right life-saving resources available when they are needed most can make a critical difference during an emergency. And we're incredibly grateful to the fire district for helping us strengthen emergency preparedness across our district. Our partnership with the Chino Valley Fire District extends beyond this donation. Their ongoing commitment to education Prevention and community safety is an invaluable resource to our schools and the families we serve Joining us this evening is from Chino Valley Fire District our fire board director Andrew Romaine Firefighter, yes, give him a round of applause Firefighter paramedic, Nick, I'm not going to butcher your last name, Migiatis, and firefighter paramedic, Phil Vasquez. At this time, please join me at the podium.
Real quick, first of all, not only is this for the district, but it's for all of you, because this is a community, and this is what we do. We want to provide back to the community. This is a culmination of something we started, what, 10 months ago, Sean? I became the liaison with the school district. He's the liaison with the fire district. And so we said, how can we... get more service into our venues, our pools, our football stadiums. All the nurses' offices have an AED, but we want to get it where parents and people and grandparents come to watch the kids. And in case they have an event, we want to have something there. So tonight is just the start of what we plan on doing. Other thing I want to let you guys know, after 32 years of working, I started ROP. That's where I started my whole career. I went ROP and became an EMT, and then boom, fire. So what she said, it works. Real quick, I'll just let Nick give you guys a real quick rundown, and we won't take too much of your time, or Phil. Phil loves to talk, so.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, thank you, thank you very much. Thanks for having us. First off, President Shaw and board members and cabinet members, everyone here tonight, I always love to say, first off, my name's Philip Bosca, I'm a firefighter paramedic with Chino Valley Fire District. I always love to start by saying thank you for being here, because if it wasn't for your butts in those seats, there'd be no impact, no significance on the other side of what we get to do as your firefighter paramedics, and we truly do mean that. We started this program, Heart Safe, Bleed Safe program, back in 2017, had a little bit of a slowdown during COVID. You know, that was a crazy year. But since then, we've donated a total of 77 AEDs and a total of 650, I'm sorry, 733 trauma kits, 650 of those have been placed in the 34 schools in the school district. Initially, we strategically placed them all, all the trauma kits with the ADs that are located within your guys' health office. And then we got another grant through the Department of Homeland Security, and we were able to place another eight within all of your schools in the school district. And a lot of that took place during 2021, during the shutdown and things like that. But anyways, the reason for our program was to be able to have the highest the highest survival rate from sudden cardiac arrest. And we found that the best way we would be able to make the biggest impact to be able to achieve that goal is going to be through a community integrated approach, which means you guys.
So on top of not only promoting the program gathering the funds, like I said, it's a community-based approach, gathering the funds from community members and businesses, and then going out and trying to donate these pieces of equipment strategically throughout the communities that we serve of Chino and Chino Hills. and then provide the training on top of that. Our goal is to be able to, I love saying this line that, yes, it is rehearsed a little bit, but I love to say that we like to train our community members, their mindset, heart set, help them develop a skill set to utilize a tool set to get the heart reset. And the goal is we want to be able to view our community members not just as lay rescuers, but as immediate responders. So when someone collapses in sudden cardiac arrest and that emergency happens, We know that firefighter paramedics serving this community, we know that our community members are ready to respond and bridge that gap from the time the emergency happens to the time we arrive on scene as your firefighter paramedics. So thank you guys for taking on this piece of equipment. Thank you guys for having a partnership with us to be able to expand this program. We truly are blessed to be able to serve you guys as you guys as paramedics. Thank you very much.
and you were talking about having us community members be responders, but I've got to tell you, I live on Euclid and Eucalyptus, and by the time we call, my daughter is going to be a firefighter, so she's taking courses at Mount Satch. By the time we run out there, you guys are already there. So your response time is good. We like to hear.
Good response. Thanks for having us. Appreciate it.
One, two, and three. Three.
And one, two, and. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, sir. Appreciate it.
Thank you, sir. Appreciate it. Thank you.
Thank you again for your generosity, your partnership, and everything you do to help keep our schools and communities safe. Please join me one more time in giving the Chino Valley Fire District another round of applause. And I was gonna give a minute so everybody that is receiving awards can exit out OK, we're now on to our presentation. Next, we have our Measure G Citizens Oversight Committee annual report for the 2025-2026 school year. Throughout the year, the committee has continued its important work of reviewing bond expenditures, monitoring construction projects, and ensuring transparency and accountability in the use of Measure G funds. The report highlights the progress of several school improvement projects and the committee's continued commitment to overseeing the responsible use of these funds for the benefit of our students and our schools.
Good evening, President Schaub, Dr. Enfield, board members, community, and cabinet. I'm Greg Stasura, assistant superintendent, facilities planning and operations for the school district. And tonight I'll be presenting the Measure G Citizens Oversight Committee report for the 2025-2026 school year. the charging purpose of the committee. The Measure G Citizens Oversight Committee is charged with informing the public concerning expenditure of bond proceeds of Measure G. The purpose of the COC and their duties are specified in the California Constitution and are summarized in the committee's bylaws as stated. The purpose of the COC as set forth in Proposition 39 is to inform the public at least annually by issuing a written report concerning the expenditure of bond proceeds from Measure G which was approved by voters in November of 2016. The COC is required within the annual report to certify if valid that CVUSD is in compliance with Article 9A 8A, I'm sorry, Section 1B3 of the California Constitution. For the 2025 school year, 2025-26 school year, the CoC was comprised of 10 members. Those members are Chairperson Art Bennett, who is also the Taxpayers' Representative, and the City of Chino Hills Representative to the committee. And then we also have Karen Comstock from the city of Chino, Deborah Doris Parada from the city of Ontario, Tony Flores, senior citizens representative, Brandy Jones, an active PTA parent of a CEVUSD student, Kevin Lai, parent guardian of a CEVUSD student, Myra Lamas, at-large member, Akin Mohammed, local business representative, and Rogelio Palayo, also an at-large member.
The COC did not visit or tour any school sites in the 25-26 school year. However, individual committee members attended events at schools throughout the district. From the school district side, representatives of myself, Beverly Beamer, our director of planning, Sam Sousa, director of maintenance and operations, and Jonathan Rico, our construction coordinator. In 25-26 school year, committee meetings were held four times. And they were on September 3, 2025, October 29, 2025, January 28, 2026, and April 29, 2026. Just like the school district's budget is audited annually, the Measure G budget and expenditures were also audited by Scott Braddock, who is a partner with Eide Bailey. He is a certified public accountant with the accounting firm. He provided, reviewed, and answered questions about the Measure G bond performance and financial audits. The audit reports disclosed no instances of noncompliance with the terms of Proposition 39 or the terms of the bond measure as approved by Chino Valley Unified School District voters. At every meeting, myself and Mrs. Beamer distributed and reviewed the expenditure report with adjusted figures reflected for the applicable quarter. The first issuance of bonds sold was in the amount of $208 million. The second issuance of bond funds was $258 million. The third issuance, $140.5 million. The fourth issuance was $99.5 million for a total issuance amount to date of $706 million. As of June 30th of this year thirty two point nine million had been earned in interest six hundred and forty seven million had been spent on projects with the remaining cash balance of ninety three point three million.
Sixty three point five million has been reimbursed to the district under the state modernization program and that money will go back into the measure G pot for additional projects. And then there's a remaining bond amount of forty three point nine million to be issued. Construction updates. At every meeting, our construction coordinator, Jonathan Rico, provided a presentation and a construction update with information on the status and progress of each project site. The following projects were in progress or completed during the 25-2026 school year. Ayala High School performing arts construction, Donalico High School construction of an administration building and renovations of the kitchen, swimming pool, and gymnasium, as well as the multipurpose room refresh. Cortez Elementary School was completely re-piped to eliminate rusty pipes and rusty water. And then the following school sites received new classroom and administrative office furniture during that school year. Briggs K-8, Cortez Elementary School, Dickey Elementary School, Newman Elementary School, Magnolia and Ramona Junior High Schools, Buena Vista High School, and Don Lugo High School. And the following are just some photos of some of the completed projects. So this is the new administration building at Don Lugo, which opened for the new school year last year in 2025. This is the renovated kitchen at Don Lugo. And this is the renovated pool at Don Lugo. And then on a side note, as I think the board is aware and a lot of people in the audience tonight are aware, the swimming pool
facility needed to be shut down earlier this month due to an equipment failure of the main circulation pump. While the pump is being rebuilt under warranty it is not a quick process and it's not an off the shelf item that can be just picked up at a local pool supply house and installed. We do expect to have repairs completed within the next couple of weeks. This picture is the gymnasium at Don Lago which was renovated as well. And then this is the new gym lobby on the front of the renovated gymnasium at Don Legault. And then an interior photo of the same gym lobby. At Iowa High School, I'm sure everybody's aware of the construction that's ongoing there for the new Performing Arts Center. This is a architectural rendering of what it will look like upon completion in 2028. Currently, there's a lot of dirt being moved around. Underground utilities are being installed. And parking lots are in the process of being renovated and repaved for opening later this year. These are just more pictures of the underground utility trenching and utilities being installed. This is what's called an underground underground stormwater modular wetland system. It is essentially a maze of a concrete structure that is about 20 feet underground where the new parking lot is being built that when stormwater is is pumped through it it filters it and then it is pumped back out into the main storm drain system and is essentially cleaner water than it would start out what it started out as from runoff of the school.
And then prior to school opening this year, the new student drop-off lane was completed. And this is just a photo of that. I also mentioned Cortez Elementary School was completely re-piped. It's not really exciting photos, but these are a couple of photos of some of the work being done. And with that, open it up to questions.
Board, if you have any questions or comments, can you use your speaker guide? I am glad you addressed the pool. It's unfortunate, and I know you guys will give continuous effort to try to push the vendors as much as possible.
Absolutely.
Thank you. Smith, the mic is on.
Yeah, again, about the pool, and thank you to the students at Don Lugo who reached out to me. You said that part was under warranty Greg did I hear that right.
Correct under warranty. OK. The pool was turned over to the district in May of this year. So it's under one year warranty.
And that and that's what was that the underground wetland.
Yes it's called called a modular wetland system.
Modular wetland system. OK. That's a pretty Robust piece of architecture on the ground.
Yeah a lot of times what you'll see in front of a Development is a kind of a retention basin that's exposed and allows water to soak into it Because if we were to put that in at Ayala, we would lose a lot of valuable parking lot space So this is basically the same thing, but it's underground underneath the parking lot.
Is this some like a state requirement?
Yes Stormwater
I don't see any more comments or questions. Thank you for your updates on everything. Thank you for your presentation.
Thank you.
OK. We'll give them a second. And now we're on to our comments from our student representative, Malia.
Good evening, President Chai, members of the board, Superintendent Enfield, and distinguished guests. At Loyola High School, their most recent event was Battle of the Bone against Sheil Hills on September 25th, and the students enjoyed the spirit and posters which filled the bleachers. Currently, they are working hard to prepare for their winter sports rally in November 6th. US elections are also coming up as applications just got released this week and complain week is from October 19th to the 23rd. The class is excited to be running for election week. Next, at Chino Hills High School, they had a successful homecoming week highlighted by an exciting football game with a halftime show put on by ASB and a successful homecoming dance. Their theater program is also hard at work preparing for the upcoming production of Catch Me If You Can, Furthermore, the Chino Heroes High School Marching Regiment competed at the Ayala Music and Motion Tournament, where they delivered in its outstanding performance and placed second overall. They congratulate the marching regiment on their success and look forward to see what they accomplish next. Then, Don Lugo has recently been bringing more school spirit and student engagement, from having the arrival game from LK not too long ago to their homecoming week. The homecoming theme, Tangled Up in Hoko, brought spirit to their school with Spirit Days, the Friday Night Lights football game, where different students were honored in the dance team at El Prado Country Club. After homecoming, they plan to bring more spirit with their annual pink L game, showing support to breast cancer awareness.
They are currently planning for their next academic rally. Finally, Chino High School was able to keep the Malkin home in an exciting cross-town rivalry football game. The school spirit was kept high as we celebrated the win with the hallway rally in which the football players were honored along with cheer and band. The energy followed later on as we had our homecoming on October 3rd. The theme was The Tale is Oldest Time in reference to Beauty and the Beast. We had a spirit week, luncheon games, and crowned the homecoming king and queen at our pink out football game to honor birth cancer awareness. Last, we invite the community to attend our annual spectacular with food, games, and more on October 28th. Thank you so much.
Thank you.
Thank you, thank you. And now we're on to our comments from our employee representatives. Dr. William Renner, ACT.
And lately I've been thinking a lot about how I want to use my comments when I come up here and how to better serve members of ACT and the community. So I've decided that to use my comments I want to generally highlight our ACT members that make our schools great places to learn and to work and to highlight any ongoing collaborative efforts with the district and our union as well as bring any issues to the board that need to be addressed. But so tonight I want to highlight our school nurses. Our school nurses do far more then respond to injuries or illnesses. They manage complex medical needs, support students with disabilities, coordinate care with families and staff, respond to emergencies, and help ensure that students are healthy, safe, and ready to learn. Their work often happens behind the scenes, but it is critical to the daily operations of our schools. As our students' needs continue to grow, and our nurses have experienced that this year, so do their responsibilities. It is important to not only recognize their contributions in the past, but also ensure that their professional expertise is respected, their voices are included in decisions that affect their work, and that they have the resources and support necessary to serve our students effectively. On behalf of ACT, I want to thank our nurses for everything that they do. Something else I'd like to highlight today, we've heard some student highlights as well, but I would also like to recognize some outstanding students from our district who participated in the American Legion Boys and Girls State and Girls State programs.
These programs provide students with valuable experiences in leadership, civic engagement, and in the democratic process. Being selected is an achievement worthy of recognition. As somebody who was a recipient when I was a student as well, I know that this is an amazing program. So I want to highlight some of those students. The winners of this year's Girl State Awards are Nicole Chung, Claire Jung, Sienna Robles, Felicity Cannon, and Sarabi Muralidhar. Thank you. And I learned that this is a separate award, the Boys and Girls State Award from CVSC, Rhea Manoj, Kendon Miller, Anaya Marie, and Lucas Liu. And though I know that many student recognitions, not every single board meeting is possible, I would argue that it's important for the board and for the district to recognize as many student achievements as possible. It's great to highlight those things for our school district. And ultimately, I believe our success as a school district is not in just the awards, recognitions, and distinguishments of our staff and teachers, but also in the success of our students. Thank you.
and Dr. Annette Hatch, chair.
Thank you very much. Good evening, President Shaw, members of the board, Superintendent Enfield, and cabinet and community. On behalf of the acts of region 12 we would like to give a shout out to all of our district administrators. This is administrators week and across the district administrators have been celebrated and showered with love from the sites and you are encouraged to check out the Chino Valley Instagram account to see all of the different recognitions. We would also like to recognize Dr. Imelda Carasosa and all the school site English language learner teams. This year, from the last year's test scores, 550 students were reclassified as English language proficient. That's, yeah. That's more than any in the last five years. So she's doing an excellent job in getting all of our school sites and really helping students to become English language proficient. We would also like to recognize Levi Dickey. They held their AVID award ceremony where they recognized 212 students who earned proficient or advanced on either their end of the year SS or the SBAC in math, language arts, or science. 212 students from last year were recognized. They actually invited back the students from the middle school to be recognized if they earned the recognition. 47% of the population from last year earned the recognition, which accounted for or equated to 47% of the student population. They have started an after school avid tutoring program which uses fifth and sixth graders to be avid tutors for the first and third graders which is they use in the high school they have the college student the college people students come in and be tutors for the for the high school students and now we have our fifth and sixth graders at Levi Dickey tutoring the first and third graders and then the fourth fifth and sixth graders do a collaborative study group.
The program is currently serving 90 students which is something that the community has asked for for years. And so they're really excited that they were able to make it happen for their students and families. And finally today is the great California shakeout. So we would like to give a huge shout out to all the sites for having a successful earthquake drill. And across California and every district, every site participated in that drill at 1015. So we also want to thank Whitney Fields and his team for leading our district and helping us to be prepared. Thank you.
Awesome. Thank you. And just a note on awards. Just so you know, we've asked Dr. Enfield in the beginning when I first took a seat for the principals to ensure we get all information. Sometimes, unfortunately, we have to see it on post and stuff. So there will be more awards coming before I leave, at least, and things that just recently happened. So rest assured, we will acknowledge the students that are definitely shining bright for our district. And with that, we're now on to public comments. Reagan, how many requests to speak? There are 20. Thank you. That means that you have two minutes each. So if you'd like to adjust right now, because I know you probably made it for three minutes, but because of 20, it goes down to two. Board by law 9323 meeting conduct establishes public comment guidelines and the following process applies. Speakers will be called in the order you registered on the electronic request to speak device. Names are displayed on monitors. Please watch for your name to appear and line up at the designated numbers one, and through two behind the mic. Once the recording secretary announces the first name, request to speak will no longer be accepted. Additionally, government code 54957.9 authorizes removal of an individual or group when a meeting is willfully interrupted and order cannot be restored. Further, penal code 403 states in part, every person who without authority of law willfully disturbs or breaks up any lawful assembly or meeting not unlawful in its character is guilty of a misdemeanor.
Mr. Cruz.
Speakers, you have up to two minutes to address the board. You can now donate your time, one person at the mic at a time. If you read on behalf of the absent person, that would be considered your time. Begin comments when the clock starts, the clock begins, when the secretary announces your name. Please refer to board policy 1312.1 for the procedure regarding complaints against an employee. And lastly, speakers may not approach the diocese any time the board is in session. Please give any materials you wish to distribute it to the board, to the recording secretary.
Campbell Miller on a non-agenda item.
I don't want one reminder. I know he's coming, but there's numbers one and two. So if you see your name as number two, Trevor, please line up on two. And then when that moves forward, he starts the time as soon as the last one's done and you're supposed to move forward because we do listen to all the speakers instead of eliminating them. So we need to keep it in a timely manner.
and community members. My name is Camden Miller and I'm a senior at Don Antonio Lugo High School. You may remember me from last February when I addressed the school board asking for help to get our pool open. I also emailed each board member on September 29th. I thank Mr. Cruz and Mr. Smith because you're the only board members to respond to me. Unfortunately, just seven months later, we are facing the same situation again. Our new pool has been closed for about a month now. I am here tonight with some of my teammates because this is the second year that Don Lugo's water polo boys team will not have a league game at home. This is having a significant impact on my team. Players have to find rides to pools farther away and we can't practice unless we find an opening in another school's busy schedule. This also means more travel time and players having to miss additional class time. It breaks my heart that once again our team's senior night will be held at another school's pool instead of our own. We are lucky enough to have great support so we don't feel like guests at our final home game of the season this coming Monday. Please help get Don Lugo's pool repaired and reopened as soon as possible. My team has worked hard and we simply want to be able to practice and compete at home. It has taken a month just to remove the pump.
Our question is why did it take a month to get this far? Why did nothing happen until today? If it is under warranty, then why is it taking so long? Sadly, it looks like our girls' water polo team will inherit this polo situation and have the same difficulties as last year. It is still projected to take weeks to compete, even when there is a history of timelines not being met, and we have been told soon many, many times. Thank you for listening to me and for everything you have already done to help my team. I was truly hoping you could help me save my final water polo season and give Don Lu Aquatics a home again. Thank you, and if you'll excuse my team and I, we have practice to attend now.
Trevor Brown, on a non-agenda item, Trevor Brown on a non-agenda item. Mayra Caldonado on a non-agenda item. Adox on Cheney Park's hearing.
Okay, yeah, I called myself as a Doxed on Chino Talks parent today because that's what brought me here. I was in a social media place and I was sharing my views and I got introduced to the Chino Valley Unified School District Board through this website and I was seeing all this stuff and I'm like, wow, this is interesting stuff. I gotta come check this out. So I came, but in my sharing on this social media, they doxxed me and they kicked me out and they did all kinds of terrible stuff but in the process of learning who these people were, it turns out there were a lot of individuals that come to this board meeting and they blasphemy and they post all this hateful stuff And I started coming and I was watching the board and getting to know what they did and seeing the differences that they were making in the community. And I was coming with my own issues with regard to protecting my boy and my girl. And the funny thing is they sit back there and some of these individuals are even videoing my kids in the meetings and just weird stuff. But I felt the need to come and share that I really appreciate the board and all that they've done and all that they do. I know tis the season, and I really don't come with a script or anything, but I truly believe that you guys are here to protect our children and parents' rights.
And I love the fact that you know what a boy is and you know what a girl is. And when my kids reach high school, I want them too to be able to be protected. And that's why as a community member, educated, street smart, kind of got it all, I teach my kid five things. Don't lie, don't cheat, don't steal, be fair, help others. Emphasis on helping others. So if this message helps anybody, I think... John, on a non-agenda item.
Just a quick reminder, when people are talking, if you're interrupting, that's your warning. Your next warning, you have to escort yourself out.
Hello board hello board and superintendent. I'm John. On November 4th 2021 I stood next to my mom while she spoke at the podium about face masks. While my mom spoke a group of adults started shouting and interrupting. They were yelling at me. My face mask was placed at the tip of my nose. By the time my mom was finished speaking you can clearly hear Sonia Shah pull your yell pull your face mask up. Sorry. I started crying. I was only nine years old at the time. Sonia Shah is a bully, not a mama bear. Thank you.
Good evening. My name is Peiwen Liu, and I'm speaking as a parent, an immigrant, and the mother of a student in CityUSD. 25 years ago, I immigrated to this country with hopes for a better future. After my husband passed away from cancer, I faced the responsibility of raising my son on my own. Like many parents, I have known the joys and worries of watching a child grow up. There is a special feeling in watching your child discover his potential and work toward his goals. As a mother, I'm deeply grateful for the opportunity my son has had and immensely proud of what he has accomplished, becoming a National Merit semifinalist, participating in California Boys State, and earning perfect AP exam scores. Every parent wants to see their child's hard work acknowledged. Recognition is not simply about a title or an award. It is about knowing that an effort behind an achievement has been seen. CVUSD recognized perfect AP scores perfect AP exam scores in October 2023, national merit semifinalists in October 2024, and boys and girls state participants in October 2025. This year, none of these are on tonight's agenda. I understand that not every accomplishment can be recognized at every meeting, but I respectfully ask for transparency. What are the criteria? The district on board policy 5126 states that the superintendent shall develop criteria for the selection of student award recipients. I asked the board to publish those criteria and apply them consistently each year.
So every family has a fair opportunity to experience that same pride. Thank you.
Hello, everybody. My name is Yi Yu Banks, and I was here last month. I'm an SH teacher, and I didn't get to finish up my speech. I'm going to continue on. But last month, I had talked about the stories as a teacher in SH field. I talked about my brother who goes off because he was emotional. I talked about another student who came, walked about a mile or so, just to find me. And I also talk about another student who went on the train track because he thought it was funny. And I just want to tell you on the side note, which is kind of interesting because this is actually a side note that I had put in here. The side note before I went to my main point. One of the side note is that at that time when the student was on the train track and everybody's yelling at him to get up, I was hoping for a male aide, and I looked around. All my aides were female. And I was like, I could use a male aide right now. And why? Because for some reason, in SH, we just know that the students listen to guys. They don't have to be loud. They don't have to be big. All they have to do is just show up, and the kids will listen to them. There is a difference between male and female, and that's why in our classrooms we need to have at least a few male aides or something like that.
I don't want all male aides, but at least a couple of them to help manage our classrooms. So, you know, it's just kind of interesting that this actually came up, that we're talking about male and female issue. We need male aides. Now the side note number two. My brother when he came to this country he we came from Taiwan 30 40 years.
SPEAKER 1 RONALD RADDATZ ON AN INFORMATION ITEM Good evening members of the board.
I'm here today and I just I'm here today just as a consent parent but as a father who is afraid of my daughter's safety in the future. My daughter is a straight A student who has been dealing with ongoing bullying and harassment at school. I have reported these concerns to the school numerous times and have made approximately eight separate no contact agreements yet their harassment continues i have brought evidence forward contacted the district and repeatedly asked for help despite all of this i still do not feel that enough has been done to protect my daughter recently the situation has become even more concerning individuals connected to this situation have been involved in incidents where my brother-in-law and more recently a friend of his were attacked i'm deeply concerned about my daughter's safety and the possibility of the behavior escalating further Meanwhile the students involved have reportedly not been suspended and some continue participating in school sports. My daughter who has worked hard academically and was recently accepted onto the Chino Hills High School basketball team is now one who now feels she may lose the opportunity to enjoy her high school years because she is afraid of her safety. Why should my daughter's education opportunities and future be put at risk when she is the one asking for help. I have reached the point where I do not feel comfortable sending my daughter back to school until meaningful steps are taken to address these safety concerns.
I am not here asking for special treatment. I am asking for accountability, consistent enforcement of school policies. a through investigation and concrete plan to protect my daughter from further harassment and retaliation. As a parent, I should not have to keep coming back and repeating myself while nothing changes. I'm asking the board to take these concerns seriously, ensure that the appropriate people are held accountable and help us find a solution before someone gets hurt. I have more, but thank you.
Lucia, a non-agenda item.
Good evening elected members of the board community members and our students for our future. I'm here today as a concerned parent because enough is enough. The amount of bullying that our representative our president issues to the community is out of hand. She keeps talking about all like the greatness of this board but I haven't seen a single policy put in place by her. Millions of money is being spent on lawsuits which is ridiculous. While some of our educators who are really doing the work are putting money out of their pocket to sustain the items that they need in the classroom. I'm tired of the book bans. I mean how do you expect to educate students when you don't even allow them allow them to read books. On top of that, like the petty behavior, the yelling, the screaming. I mean, you mentioned something earlier about if people are talking out of hand, yet we've all watched you online doing that everywhere. So, you know, what I learned is that we lead by example and you're not a great example. On top of that, the curriculum restrictions, I mean, enough is enough. At the end of the day, I want to thank all the teachers who make it possible for our students to progress and do amazing because the work that they're doing is what gives this Chino Valley Unified School District the results. As a parent who has two amazing children who are always excelling, I give all the credit to the teachers and to ourselves as the parents.
Thank you. And students, I'm really proud of you for being here today. Enough is enough. Oh, and absenteeism is not a buzzword. Absenteeism. Nisa G, .
I have a hypothetical question. What would have been your response if I'd walked into this boardroom after public comments had concluded but stood up and demanded my three minutes to speak, even if I'd said I had been stuck in traffic, even if I believed I had a reason for speaking that was more important than anything on the agenda? It's safe to say that within 10 seconds, Ms. Shaw would have directed security to throw me out. Heck, you've ended entire meetings and thrown everyone out for less than that. So why did you, Ms. Shaw, think it was appropriate to storm into a regional CIF meeting last month and scream about wanting your time to speak even though time for public comments was over? Did you think because you didn't make it there on time you should be afforded that right? Or when you declared that you're running for state superintendent of public instruction, did you think that gave you privilege? And when the president banged her gavel and asked you to stop disrupting the meeting, you thought it was appropriate to get even louder? Your tantrum was an embarrassment to our district and sets a horrible example for our students. But it got you the headlines you were seeking, so at least there was that. You know, when you believe in something, it's easy to get swept up in also believing that you're above the law. But guess what? Everyone here tonight believes in what they're saying, too.
The difference is that you routinely deny members of the community their right to be heard. even when we're following the rules. You routinely walk off the dais when you don't like what speakers have to say. You change the rules about when and how we can speak. You throw people out of the boardroom for talking to the person next to them. When you think nothing of changing the rules to benefit yourself while you're in power and also think the rules don't apply to you, well, that's how a dictator thinks. Voters should keep this in mind when they're casting their vote November 3rd. Anyone who believes they're above the law shouldn't be trusted to hold any public office, let alone the top education position in the state. Thank you.
Sonia, I can't wait for God to pluck you, Timu Erika Kirk, from that seat. Here are some of your worst highlights. Number one, you don't fight for children. You fight children, specifically trans children and their parents, because you're a sad and miserable human being.
I'm trying to give you more time not interrupted. If you guys are going to continue to interrupt, you're going to have to escort yourself out. This is a public meeting. You're not allowed to have outbursts, so please keep quiet while she speaks.
Go ahead.
You're racist and refuse to acknowledge how ICE has affected our community. You created an outing and flag ban policy that are useless and have cost the district millions in lawsuits. You don't ban books, you have them thrown away without a process. You call teachers groomers while you married your groomer, Mr. Dark Maga Chris Shaw. Hey Chris, I hear you like him young. A 26-year-old flirting with a 17-year-old is gross. Now he's running for your spot. And as a board, you have collectively received $225,000 from the Reynoso family. Follow the money. You bragged about our PBIS platinum status. But then when we got downgraded to gold, you had Enfield create a fake fake. Diamond Award, and then called it a trash program. You allegedly lied under oath in court about not knowing who was behind the hateful online account, CVSchools, while the recovery email and phone number is yours, Sonia. You lied about being the reason why we recovered so quickly from post-COVID learning loss when you actively screamed at our former board for approving the extra 30 minutes of instruction. You gave a board position to Sean Smith because he's your friend's husband that you mooch from. You successfully got sued by Natalie Cooney for lying about her because you picked on the wrong teacher. Sonia, you're leaving behind a legacy of hate and ignorance, and I hope the door hits you on the way out. Bye.
My question is for Sean Smith, Sonya Shaw, a.k.a. Chris Shaw. You all campaign on fiscal responsibility, keeping tax dollars in the classroom and keeping politics out of our schools. What do you think that means? This board has spent millions fighting culture war battles that do nothing for student achievement while claiming you care only about academics. I wish I could say exactly how much this has cost us, but I can't because the district at this board's direction is hiding from parents what these lawsuits cost. In 2023, we requested a breakdown of legal fees by case. We were told it was confidential because of ongoing litigation. An attorney told me this isn't true. We resubmitted and were refused again. This June, I submitted a new request. The district has used every tool to delay it, blowing past legal deadlines. Weeks go by, I get a clarifying question, I answer, and more weeks go by. Finally, on September 4th, I received some documents, partial documents of what I requested, and pages and pages of documents so redacted, they look like the Epstein files. This is only one month worth of legal fees and only some of the documents because I ran out of ink. So this is only April 2026. The excuse was the same, attorney-client privilege, ongoing litigation. I answered the district's last question five and a half weeks ago. The response was due in 10 days, nothing. Dr. Enfield and Dr. Park, you were on that email.
So when does this community get to know what your politically motivated lawsuits cost? When the case ends? When you're off the board? It looks like you don't want this public before the election, where it could hurt Sean Smith, Chris Shaw, and Sonia Shaw. If you have nothing to hide, then release it. You rail against keeping secrets from parents, yet you keep secrets about legal fees, about the books you're banning, and about what happened to PBIS. You have added nothing of value.
Page 20, I'm not a gender item.
Good evening, members of the CVUSD board. I'm here as a student advocate who believes that students deserve a voice in the very decisions that shape our education and our futures. Since 2022, CVUSD has reportedly spent nearly $4 million in legal fees ever since Sonia Shah has been elected. How is it acceptable that our school district has reportedly spent $4 million on legal services while students are left fighting for the resources and support they deserve? That is $4 million that could have gone towards our classrooms, our teachers, and our students. And instead of asking how we can better support our students, this board is choosing to spend more money reopening legal battles. Incumbent board members, including Shaw and Smith, you have a responsibility to put students first. Yet when students feel ignored while the district continues to face expensive legal disputes, a serious question emerges about whose interests are actually being prioritized. How can this board claim to put students first when students are left asking for resources and representation and accountability from the school board? Because every dollar spent by this district should bring us closer to better schools, not farther away from them. Thank you.
Plans on a new agenda item.
Good evening, board. I'm here today dedicating my time on a school weeknight to express my deep dissatisfaction with the current board incumbents these past years, including Sean Smith. My overall contention is with how you all claim to put students first with your policies. You have all proven that your real priorities lie within putting your own political agendas by deliberately ignoring the voices of over 300 students who are simply demanding to have our own voice within our education. Because at the end of the day, we are the people who are actually affected by our decisions and the unsafe environment you have fostered from your harmful policies such as book bans, flag bans, and forced queer outing. So by walking away when confronted by those same students you all claim to represent, how can you really say that you're putting us first? What about the $4.3 million in legal fees that have accumulated within just the past four years from frivolous lawsuits with the state, where our classrooms constantly lack basic supplies that our teachers are expected to pay for themselves? Our learning is disrupted every day by inconsistent Wi-Fi, and countless educational programs that we valued have been cut over the years. Is that still putting us first, or are you too preoccupied fighting these political and religious culture wars to actually put your focus towards improving our education, such as AP, STEM, visual performing arts, and college readiness programs? As school board members, it is your job to advocate for the needs of students.
But take a look around at all the students who have gathered here today who feel so underrepresented by their own board that they feel that they need to advocate for themselves because the people in power have failed to do so. The fact that I am now a senior and I've been attending these meetings since I was a sophomore and I'm still fighting to make my voice heard on these same issues truly shows how you don't actually care about listening to our concerns or representing us like you claim. It's time for change. Thank you. So now we start moving on to the other end.
Good evening, my name is Serenoza, a Chino Valley student attending Ayala High School. Today, I stand before you all as a student advocate because we deserve a voice in the decisions that shape our educations and our futures. This board has spent countless dollars on political culture wars, particularly on keeping girls' sports safe while neglecting its actual responsibilities. By prioritizing exclusion over inclusion, you allow personal biases to shape policies meant to serve all students. Although concerns regarding fairness of competition between all girls are understandable and female athletes feeling neglected is completely valid, the situation between James and the girl from Ayala is out of CVUSD jurisdiction. So why attempt to apply CVUSD policy? Why is the board attempting to apply this policy? And the safety and comfortability of girls within our local sports are of utmost priority. But this includes all girls, transgender and cisgender. LGBTQ plus students continue to be overlooked. While parental consent is enforced for pronoun changes, yet meaningful parental involvement in our education is too often neglected. The incumbent CVUSD board members, including Shaw and Smith, claim to put students first. Yet how can they claim this while continuing to ignore us? Sonia Shaw, when 300 students came forward to make their priorities heard, you attempted to walk away. Those students were asking you to listen, not to prioritize politics. SO I ASK YOU, AFTER ALL THE POLICIES THAT HAVE BEEN IMPLEMENTED, WHERE IS THE EVIDENCE THAT STUDENTS COME FIRST? WE WILL CONTINUE FIGHTING FOR POLICIES THAT REPRESENT ALL STUDENTS, TEACHERS, AND PARENTS, NOT POLITICAL AGENDAS, BECAUSE STUDENTS SHOULD NOT HAVE TO FIGHT TO BE HEARD BY THE VERY PEOPLE ELECTED TO REPRESENT THEM.
THANK YOU.
Good evening, board members. My name is Sophia Hernandez, and I'm a senior at Don Lugo High School. For nearly 13 years, I've grown up in this district. I've had teachers who believed in me, friendships that shaped me, and experiences that taught me something beyond textbooks. They taught me that my voice matters, that I should think critically, stand up for what I believe in, and have the courage to speak even when my voice shakes. But I realize that finding your voice and feeling heard are two very different things. Students across this district have organized, signed petitions, and attended board meetings to express their concerns. Yet during one meeting, board president Sonia Shaw walked away while the student advocate was speaking. He even had to ask her to hear him out. I'm not sure why she left, but I do find it concerning that students are encouraged to use their voices, only to question whether anyone is actually listening. because behind every policy, petition, and disagreement, there is a real student, a student who walks into school hoping to feel safe, respected, and understood, a student who opens a book and finally finds a character who reminds them of themselves, a student who spends hours finding the courage to speak at a meeting, rehearsing what they want to say, hoping that people sitting in front of them will listen, and a student who may never stand behind this microphone, but whose life is still affected by the decisions made here.
Sorry.
That's all.
Hello and good evening to everyone here who came to take time out of their day to support our schools. My name is Audrey and I'm a junior at Juneau High and I've been in CVSC since kindergarten. Something that I learned throughout my life is that being a good member of society means being able to celebrate accomplishments while being able to recognize mistakes. A very big mistake that I've been frustrated with throughout the last couple of years and continue to question is the unnecessary politics in classrooms and the lack of student representation and sensitivity in our board meetings. It isn't encouraging and quite embarrassing to know that the people who are supposed to be supporting you have been willingly neglecting you for all to see. Many books, such as More Happy Than Not by Adam Silvera and Juliet Takes a Breath by Gabby Rivera, stories about growing up queer have been banned from CVUSC for being sexually obscene and not necessary to the curriculum. Yet, we have programs like Turning Point USA coming to junior high schools without parent consent and teaching very morally incorrect views. While students are advocating for change and being shown disrespect at board meetings, the CVSD board members, including Sean Smith, are allowing the future generations to be taught that young women with innocent minds should be embracing the idea of motherhood and allowing themselves to stay at home rather than getting an education. which I view as a direct opposition to their Students First campaign.
But considering the fact that these members are friends with very controversial figures, it isn't shocking, just disappointing. We have members of the board saying that politics shouldn't be in classrooms, yet they're allowing politically controversial and well-known groups attend junior high schools. Students deserve to feel comfortable no matter where they are and shouldn't have to give that up because of someone else's beliefs. Although there is more that I can speak about my focus of the speech isn't to point out everything wrong with the board but to beg for perspective on how their decisions are actively affecting students as many have felt silenced and discriminated by them. I don't expect everyone to agree but I hope to be understood. I love my school and the people in it and my one wish before I'm finished with not just high school but Chino as a whole is that students feel comfortable respected and represented all around. I hope that, oh.
Maya Limon .
Hello, my name is Maya Limon, and I'm an upcoming graduate at Chino High School. At an age where adulthood is creeping around the corner, there's a harsh reality check that arises with it, which is the fact that a small fragment of those who carry the obligation to oversee and accommodate for the youth will alternatively use that authority to coincide with their own personal agenda. political agenda. On a daily basis, teachers have five to six teaching periods with up to 30 or more students, which is a particularly common issue at Chino High since the population has grown from recent advancements. And although that can be viewed as positive, teachers are reportedly asked to sign a form which allows them to exceed the maximum amount of students permitted in their classrooms with no extra pay. Students are also impacted as they gain a severely diminished chance of enrolling in their desired courses due to a maximum capacity. This is undeniably unfair, as teachers and students, rather than you, the head administration, are left to face the burden of a surplus population. Moreover, teachers are not granted a yearly classroom supply fund. They rely on their own finances, along with the federal tax deduction, which does not fully compensate for the expenses of students who can't afford it. So I ask why so much funding is spent towards lawsuits that have continuously ended against your behalf. The incumbent CVSD board members, including Schott and Smith, have a responsibility to focus on the well-being of students they were elected to serve for.
But when these concerns remain neglected, skepticism arises about whether district decisions accurately reflect our students' needs. Furthermore, I'd like to address the distinction between the personal political beliefs and the responsibility of managing public education. Incumbent board Sandra Shaw reportedly shared a photograph on social media which displayed imagery associated with a particular ideology. Although everyone is entitled to their own beliefs, the public distribution of these affiliations raise concerns about whether personal ideologies are being separated from district policy making. Public education is meant to accommodate students of various political, cultural, and religious backgrounds. Ergo, it is crucial that the decisions made on our behalf actually consider the educational needs of students rather than the personal beliefs of those in authority. On a final note, I ask how the district can continue to promote the phrase students first if students are left questioning whether they're Lucas J. Rue on a new agenda item.
Well, well, well, as a student advocate, I suggest a slight tweak to board policy 5145.2. On campus, CVUSD respects students' right to free speech sometimes. Whenever I communicate with the school board, they always share the emails with my extracurricular advisors, where I then have awkward conversations about their bosses. After I petitioned you guys, I was sent to the admin office. Yesterday, my civic engagement club was pressured to shut down their meeting. So the CVOC board, including Shaw and Smith, They are pretty clever, because instead of forcing outright compliance, they've only pressured us to be silent so they can technically respect our right to free speech. And you guys did take an oath to the Constitution, but my free speech has been abridged. And yet I still stand here. I stand here alongside a whole lot of other Chino Valley students for change. I'm protected by the law, and I'm backed by teachers, peers, and parents. Every bit of political notoriety, each time you've ignored the students, every time you've pressured us to be silent, that's just more reason to keep going. You've watched me go at this for two years now, and that same face of indifference that you give these other students where you don't even look at them in the eye, that indifference towards student voices is how you have is how a student movement has grown right from under the nose of your authority. So every student has a voice here, and I'll use mine to quote a historical student advocate.
Conformity is the jailer of freedom and the enemy of growth. So I say to all students, stand up, speak up, and organize, knowing the only thing we can lose are the shackles of silence. I hope CVUSD can recognize that soon. Thank you.
Tim Armstrong on another gender album.
So I actually have a short tolerance for white supremacists. So I'm going to make this real quick, Sonya. I'm here to address the white supremacy, racist, homophobic, transphobic representative that is Sonya and her husband, people who openly support a man who looked at a child and said he would be dating her in a few years, a man who was in the Epstein files for pedophilia. Meanwhile, you're here saying that trans people are a threat to sports. You're the threat. You and your husband shouldn't be near any child. If you would vote for a pedophile so you can uphold white Christian nationalism, you shouldn't be near a child. I wish I could say that I'm surprised, but this is America. So Sonya, since you are adamant on making America great, which period would you like to go back to? You want to go back to the founding of America where Christopher Columbus had a child slave sex ring of nine and 10 year olds, would you like to push a few years later after he committed genocide to black people being enslaved for 200 years to kickstart the American economy? Would you like to kickstart even after that when we fought for our rights to Jim Crow so white people could feel good about being in their homes and enslaving people? Would you like to push past that, where black people actually made it past Jim Crow? Then what happened? The CIA dropped drugs into black communities so that they can distinctively stop black power movements.
Where else would you want to go? You want to go to current now? Let's go forward. Actually, let me go back. You want to go back to when women couldn't vote, when women couldn't even get a bank account? They had to stay right up under their slave masters, their former slave masters, which were the men? Exactly. So if you really love America, stop banning books. Let's listen to what America really is. It is a white supremacist country full of capitalists, white supremacists. And with that, all power to the people and fuck Donald Trump.
Last one. Moving on to consent, board members, if you have an item to pull, please indicate so on your monitor.
Please escort yourself out.
You know the rules, escort yourself out.
Board members, please indicate if you have any polls. Seeing no polls. Okay, escort yourself out. Any more need to escort themselves out? We're good? Okay. Seeing that there's no polls, we'll move on to consent. Board members, if you have an item to pull, please indicate so on your monitor. For the consent items, may I have a motion? Yes.
I have a change on the agenda.
What is that?
I have a change on the agenda.
For changes and deletions. Okay. We'll go back. We'll give a minute to clear the room. Okay, from this point on, please keep order. We're back to changes and deletions. Reagan, are there any? Yes.
The following changes in the agenda. Item 2D22, Fourth Amendment to Land Lease Agreement and Reimbursement Agreement for Department of State Architect Inspection Services with Horizon Wireless. Page 129, background information. In the first sentence, delete the date, February 15, 2004, and replace it with June 3rd. There are no further changes or deletions.
Thank you so much. Moving now back on to consent. Board members, if you have an item to pull, please indicate so on your monitor. Okay. For the consent items, may I have a motion, please? Thank you, Mr. Na. And thank you, Mr. Cervantes, for your second. Board members, please register your vote. Preferential? Yes. Thank you. And the motion passes with the vote of 5-0 with preferential voting yes.
There we go. Okay.
We're now on to information items. Are there any comments or questions? Seeing that there is none, we're now on to board comments. Mr. Smith. Question. Mic is on.
Wow. That was interesting. So first off, thank you for all those that decided to stay. It would have been great if the students stayed. Because really, even though there was a lot of criticism here, these students need to be commending on their bravery to get up here and speak, where even a lot of adults are afraid to speak. But these students might not agree to everything, but at least they're up here speaking their minds, and they're being brave enough to do it. Some of the things, it seems like there's a lot of influence in the way that they're going about things. And I wish that they would take things out a little further. And I've said this before, for the board, you inject politics. I'd like an example of the politics that we're injecting. I think what's happening here is that we remove the politics from the classrooms, and that in and of itself is being taken as some sort of political thing. No, we are actually the ones that are removing the politics from the classroom. If you see, please provide proof. So that would be like taking this thought process out a little bit further instead of just saying these things. Dr. Enfield? Can you give us a quick breakdown on the book policies? Because I think there's a lot of confusion here. You keep hearing, oh, you're banning books, you're banning books. But let's take that out. Again, it seems like they stop right there.
A lot of people stop right at that point. They don't take it out further. What is being banned? Do we have the capacity to store every book that's ever been written in the history of mankind in our libraries and classrooms? no we do not have that ability to so should we have some discretion on what's in the in the libraries and classrooms i would hope the school district would have a discretion on the books that are in their library right and so what is our policy with this book banning
The policy is that if the book is describing a sexual act, not saying that they had sex, that's none of those books would be pulled. But if it describes a sexual act between two adults in detail, it's removed.
Mr. Smith, really quick, I've tried to read some of the books in question in TV and radio when asked about it, including L.A. Times, and they will not post. the parts of these books because they're so sexually explicit. It's disgusting and mortifying, just so you know.
So here's a little test. If you think a book has been banned, maybe go home and have AI illustrate that book on your home computer and see if AI is even comfortable with doing something like that. Because remember, kids are illustrating. When we read, we illustrate in our minds. So this is something that, do you really want this kind of material? So when you keep saying, book banning, book banning, oh, it's Nazi Germany, really? take it out and I hope that with the educators that they explain to the students like hey let's take this out a little further let's go to the next step right let's not just stop here let's examine this let's get into the critical thinking aspects of educating our students so a lot of these students I think they kind of they kind of stop right at that at the buzzword to really think critically they need to go deeper now they got a great start this is fantastic i actually i really enjoyed um even the criticisms and things that me uh my i have two daughters in college one is an arrow in aerospace engineering the other is going for dermatology so i guess i did a poor job at saying hey you need to uh be a housewife or something like that so i i guess um I'm pretty bad at teaching that. I have strong, independent young women. I have three daughters that are fantastic, intelligent, and yeah, so there's that.
Again, proof of the politics, right? Let's see it. Let's take it out a little bit more, a little farther out there, right? We need these kids to think independently and objectively. We don't want to teach them what to think. We need to teach them how to think. Let's think critically. Let's go further. But again, fantastic. It was great having these kids out here doing that thing. And praise to them. the Don Lugo or the Ayala cross country girls for coming out here and speaking their hearts and their minds. Again, a lot of courage. A lot of student representation here tonight. The Don Lugo water polo team, that's kind of close to my heart, my son did water polo. So I can feel the frustration there as a parent and I hope that we can light a fire under the vendor for that for sure. If we can, because that's a serious thing. I really empathize. I can feel that, seriously. The bullying issue, we had a parent come up here and talk about bullying. We take this very seriously in this district. The principals are given a lot of discretion and a lot of flexibility to take disciplinary action, and we allow that in our district. We let the principals know, like, hey, if you need to take action, we will back you up. So I hope that Dr. Enfield, that parent, I didn't see an email from that parent, but he said that he reached out to us.
And Dr. Fried is already addressing that.
Okay.
Yeah, we've already been going back and forth during the meeting regarding that issue. So they'll be following that with the parent.
Perfect. Yeah, because that's what we do. We allow that flexibility. We're not one of those schools that says, hey, you can't take disciplinary action because we're not going to vote on it or anything like that. We will vote on it and we will take disciplinary action to make sure that there's no bullying in the schools like that. Students first. Again, we do put students first. There's a bit of confusion here when it comes to like when you say trans rights. A trans child has all the same rights that any other child has. The thing that we're not going to grant is additional privileges. If you are requesting a right that infringes on the rights of others, That's not a right. That's actually a privilege, because you can't infringe on the rights of others. Girls and boys have a right to their safe spaces, plain and simple. When you request to go infringe on that, we're going to say no, plain and simple. And this is students first. Frankly, that's what it is, because every student gets equal rights. They're not going to be granted privileges to infringe on the rights of others. Okay. So, Ms. Yi came in and she talked about some of her issues. That's fantastic. I've been talking with her about some SPED improvements. We're going to get to that. Count Lero, congratulations to Principal Alba. I was there just the other day for a color guard recruitment training. That was fantastic.
So we appreciate Kyle Arrow opening their doors to us. I was able to attend Harmony in the Hills. Mrs. Yarbrough was gone. That was fantastic as well. Even though it rained in the middle of the performance, it still turned out really well. That was great. I got to go Battle of the Bone and Milk Can. Attended both those events. The Milk Can was actually really exciting. Battle of the Bone, it was a little, yeah, it was a little rough there. But anyway, now on to some updates, Dr. Enfield, some things that we've been working on. How are we doing on the auto shop?
We are currently in talks with Chafee College on that. And so it's going through the process. So we continue the conversation. It takes a while, so there'll be more conversations, but it will be moving forward. Ms. Post over there is looking at a couple year budget on the cost of that and securing the funding for that project.
Fantastic. And then the Measure G, I know we've been kind of keeping this other project secret because we didn't want to necessarily release it too prematurely. And it goes along with the Measure G things, but the track and field at the middle school,
Yeah, so I don't necessarily know if it's a secret that it's all in the bond or and it's part of the plan that was submitted years ago to the district when we went out for the bond. Part of the request from the junior highs were to have a gymnasium and we're coming towards the end of the bond and There has been money that we recouped back from the state that allows us to go and add more additional projects to our bond. And one of those is to add gymnasiums at the junior high schools that do not have them. So there are six different gymnasiums across our district at the junior high level, K-8s, junior highs that do not have a gymnasium. and facilities and planning is working with the architect. And currently, they've been working for several months on a design that would be able to use at all of our junior highs. So that would cut down fees. Architectural fees can be high. So we're looking at the same model that would be able to drop on all six of the campuses. And so we will be able to, I think we're about a year out from the architect design getting approval from the state and then starting construction. So we're about a year out from that. We'll do three junior highs, K-8s. There's six total, so we'll do three in the first phase and then another three in the second phase.
Fantastic. That's exciting stuff. And good to hear that we're making improvements across campuses. It was good to see the partnership with the fire department. I had a great time and he had developed a good relationship with him from the fire district. And it was nice to see that also come true to fruition here. Again, I would like to thank everyone for coming. Thanks for staying. And, you know, the kids did a fantastic job, whether you agree with them or not. They had a lot of courage and bravery. Thank you.
Mr. Na. Mike's on.
Yeah, I'd also like to thank students at Danubo High School. Dr. Enfield, could you please make sure that we can have that swimming pool up and running as soon as possible? I think the season has started or coming in days. and they have a great concern over that at Don Luvo High School. So, Dr. Dennefield, please make sure that we're on top of game. Yeah, Mr.
Stature already sent me the update on it. They're working to get it done as quick as possible, but it's a defective pump, I think, that was placed in there, and so a crane had to be brought in to be able to pull it out. We had a diver that had to go into the pool and do some other repairs regarding that. The pump was actually is being shipped as we speak to Fresno because it needs to go back to the manufacturer to do some work on it and then to bring it back down there. But they know that we've requested to get it done as fast as possible, but we're relying on the outside. It's under warranty. So we're doing all that we can, but a lot of that is out of our control. But we're working with our vendor who we purchased that from to speed that up.
Is there any other way that... our swimmers could practice somehow?
Whenever a pool goes down, we allow them to go to, we work with another school site, so they're working with Chino High, so they're over at Chino High, so they have a facility to go and use.
All right, thank you. And I had a pleasure of speaking with our former representative, a student representative of Phoenix. And I wish I had some of those children from Ayala High School be still here tonight because Phoenix is in one of our top universities in the nation. And he has sent greetings to all of our staff members here for his He said he had a great time for a year serving as a student representative. And he also sent blessings to Mrs. Shaw. And I think this is where our children needed to hear. When you address adults, you use Mr. or Mrs. And I think they have missed that when I was hearing. So I hoped they were here tonight to listen what Phoenix would have used if he was here when addressing an adult. And also, you know, I have a sad news. Terry Hargrove, who was a longtime secretary at Rhodes Elementary School, she had faced another passing of her dear family member, who happens to be our substitute teacher and a daughter. So I'd like to ask Mrs. Shaw to close our meetings in prayers for Terry Highgrove's family for tonight's meeting. Thank you.
Of course, Mr. Na. Thank you. And Mr. Cruz. Mic's on.
As for the students, I get it. I was just like them as well when I was a high school student. So it's good that they're exercising their thoughts. And eventually, as we get older, we begin to understand more things in life. So at least I'm very, very happy that they're here exercising their speech. So that's excellent. and hoping for the pool to open up soon. These students deserve it, definitely deserve it. UBanks, yeah, as I agree, we should, we should attempt to hire more males paraeducators. That's also important, too. And as for the woman's son receiving national merits and so forth, that is a good idea. And hopefully, maybe in the future, we can recognize our excellent students. That's really important for our students. And that's about it. Thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Cruz. They will be recognized next meeting. And we still leave the invitation open to all of our principals and staff to bring stuff forward that happens uniquely at their sites. And Mr. Cervantes? Mic's on.
Again, thank you, everybody, for being here tonight. And absolutely, our speakers did a fantastic job. It was a packed house, and we love to see that. Whether we agree or not, it's very important that you come and speak about the issues that matter to you. If it's an issue that matters to you, you need to be here, because it's important to be represented and be heard, and so everybody knows what's important to you. I mean, let's face it, everybody that's here tonight, you could have been You know, hey, there's game four going on at the Dodgers, right? You could have been home watching that game comfortable. I think a lot of people that agree with some of the things I might think is important, instead of being here, they felt more important to be home. So guess what? You guys were here and your voices were heard. So I applaud you for that because it's important. A couple of things that I think that's really important to talk about tonight, some of the bigger issues that have to do with life itself. Let's think about breast cancer awareness, things like that. Mr. Knott mentioned it, the Harvard family has been part of this community for such a long time. I think there's many of us that have worked with Terry and worked with Mark, who's been part of our district before he passed from cancer, who served our community, our schools, our city, our prisons, our law enforcement communities.
Terry Hargrove doing the same thing in our schools, dedicated. They have a daughter teaching. And then Stephanie who lost her battle with cancer. And I'm grateful that Mr. Knob brought it up because we absolutely need to close our board meeting and recognize her and appreciate the life that she gave to so many others. You know, someone lost a daughter, a sister, an aunt, a friend, and that needs to be remembered always. I thank God every day. My sister-in-law was just recently told she's in remission from cancer. I think everybody here pretty much could say they know somebody who's going through it. have lost that battle, so it's close to every one of us. And we appreciate you having the courage to fight and to even mention when you're at loss so we can actually share that grief with you. So that's one of those important things we have to remember on the big spectrum of things. I know we have a lot of issues that we might think it was important, think about some of the petty things that we complain about when we should be so thankful, not to diminish anything that you might think is important because there are important issues, but there's so much more that I think we need to reflect on sometimes. So I think that's important. I'd be remiss not to mention that. You know, Mr. Smith, in a couple of days, we got to attend the milk can game and the Battle of the Bone.
That was outstanding. So those games are outstanding to be part of. You mix it with the community. You get to see people you haven't seen in a while. It's a good time. It was a packed house in both stadiums. Great events. Ayala High School, again, congratulations. You know, you guys earned it, and we want to recognize you. There's a lot of things that maybe didn't get recognized, but we're never going to forget them. We'll get those things on the agenda. Don Lugo, I appreciate you guys being here. Your water polo team, yeah. When that issue came about, you know, just remember, like, We see those emails, but we have representatives that represent certain schools. We all represent every school. However, certain represents are going to contact you because we do respond. We take turns. We kind of tag team on different emails that we're going to respond to, but they don't get ignored. They're going to get they're going to get addressed and they're going to get they're going to get handled. And that issue is being handled. It is important. And you're not going to be without a pool. I get it. it's you know it is inconvenient i get that it's inconvenient but you're not going to be without some type of uh a pool or some type of you know facility that you're going to need our chino valley fire partners we thank you again i remember i was part of that 2017 when you guys went out and we gave out those aeds and they're so needed and we thank you again for doing that that partnership is huge we appreciate that our first responders do so much and then
To be able to get so many of us to be trained on those things is so easy to use. And I know we talked about tourniquets. We did those before. Maybe that's something we could do in the future. We could talk about that another time. But there's so many things that we could do to make sure that everybody out here has a tool in their tool belt to be able to help in time of need. So thank you again for that. And one more thing, I want to again congratulate those who recently got promoted. Your service is well-deserved and respected here, and we appreciate you with that. Have a good night, and thank you again.
Thank you, Mr. Cervantes. Mr. Smith has a correction for something.
There it is. It was music in motion at Ayala, not Harmony in the Hills. So Harmony in the Hills is next month. That's Gina Hill. So I get my do so many music things at this point that I'm confused. So sorry, Mrs. Yarboy, for that mix up. It's music in motion. And it was fantastic. Thank you.
Thank you. And Dr. Enfield.
Looks like Mr. Smith used my time. No comments.
I guess it's my turn. Thank God the Lord goes before me and he fights my battles. I don't really need to defend myself because the results are here. Dr. Enfield, we should be celebrating today. Actually, we celebrate every day, regardless of the attacks from those that don't want to do great by our kids. But can you give us just a tad bit of an update on the test scores that were released today? While most districts are covering their faces here in California because the results are exactly what we've been saying, because they're pushing things out, unfortunately, are the result of what happens when you have activists in the classroom. But thank God we have a majority of great teachers. And I would like you to give an update on our current test scores, despite what's happening in the state. Please.
Yeah. When you look at our test scores, again, they continue to go up year after year. This year in the area of ELA, we went up, what, 1%. So we're at 63.12% in ELA across the district. In math, we went up 1.2%. We're at 50.99, almost 51%. And in science, we went up 2.94%, so we're at 45.34. And again, we continue to do the work in our areas of emphasis, looking at our central standards, looking at student engagement in the PLC process. And it's through that process that our school sites do a phenomenal job of educating our kids. We want high academics for our kids. We're not satisfied with those scores. I'm not satisfied with them. We need to continue to get them higher. But we look at surrounding districts and compare with certain districts. We outshine them. But again, we continue to make that progress at increment levels. And I know we'll continue down that path because we just get better and better every year in the work that we do around our central standards in the PLC process.
Absolutely, thank you for your leadership. That's why this board supports exactly your vision on how to push our district in the right direction. It's called systems work. You guys do it well. Thank you for continuing to do that. Thank you to our good teachers, our admin, and our staff who continue to be on the right side of history. Again, I would love to just go and say everything that I need to say against all the lies and the hatred that are spread about myself and my family. If you're not doing something right and you're not challenging the culture that, unfortunately, California has created, then you wouldn't be getting the attacks. And I truly hope this community continues to show up and put the right people on this board. I will continue to fight, not only for CBSD, for all the kids here in California, because it's really unfair that CBSD has the right leadership. And unfortunately, the rest of California is suffering. I mean, we see the results. I agree the results aren't exactly where we want to be but they are trending upwards continuously every single year instead of going downwards like all the rest of the districts the majority. There is great districts in California but there's only maybe I can count them on both hands. That's how minimal they are. And the test scores for math. That's a hard one because you know even nationally kids are struggling with math. In California the average is about 38 to 39 percent correct proficient in math.
and we've hit over 50. So that goes to show you we're definitely heading in the right direction. Our district is doing the right thing. I will continue to be an advocate for this district as long as they're on the right side of history. Tonight you heard from some female athletes. I had no clue they were going to speak up when I saw them be displaced by another district allowing a male on their team, I was mortified and I will fiercely defend these girls. And again, if I have to shut down every CIF meeting, I will, because they don't deserve to do business if they're not protecting kids, period. And if it takes someone like me to go and tell a bunch of adults to actually acknowledge what's happening to these young females, then oh well, charge me, I'm guilty. I do not care. Just like prior when the board wouldn't listen to us and I was a mother at the other side of that microphone, you better believe I will also be the most fiercest defender of anybody on the right side of history and I've shown that through the last four years. Of anybody who's doing the right thing, I will stand in the way so they don't have to endure what these people are doing to myself and my family. I have two beautiful daughters. One is still in CVUSD. And you don't think that she's messaging me how horrible the things that they're saying about not only myself but my family.
But no one cares about the mental health of my family. But that's OK. Because again, I'll say the Lord, God goes before our family and he fights this battle and he will continue to fight and protect my family. And every time a dagger is thrown at my family, I can tell you with whole heart, my family is blessed even tenfold. So go ahead and throw the daggers because we just get multiple blessings and we get multiple people showing the wickedness that wants control of our children. I will never back down from that. I will never back down from who I serve. I serve God and I don't serve man and I don't serve human. And my calling is to protect kids. And I take that very seriously. And I will do that till the day I die. And with that, we will also end with somebody who was amazing. Not only the whole family, because one's a teacher in our district. One was actually the mother, Terry Hargrove was, you know, our secretary where my kids went to school roads, but also we have Stephanie Hargrove, a substitute teacher here. Unfortunately, she passed, but gratefully she's in heaven with our almighty maker. God, we will definitely have a moment of silence for her and end in her memory. And with that, now I adjourn the regular meeting of the Board of Education at 8.09 p.m.